OAPD Mentoring workshop
October 15, 2020- 00:04Good afternoon, I'm Sam ball
- 00:05from the office of academic and
- 00:08professional development and I'll be
- 00:10facilitating this presentation welcome.
- 00:12I'm glad so many could join my objectives
- 00:15for this seminar to provide an overview
- 00:18of some of the characteristics of
- 00:21effective mentoring and the roles and
- 00:24responsibilities of mentors and mentee's.
- 00:26And I'll also briefly touch on
- 00:28some of our offices plans and the
- 00:32resources we hope to roll out.
- 00:34In 2021 to support departmental
- 00:37leadership in their implementation
- 00:40of Department based mentoring plans.
- 00:44Just to start off and say that there are
- 00:47many ways to get mentoring and range
- 00:49of people who can be helpful to your
- 00:53career development as junior faculty.
- 00:55In my presentation,
- 00:56I will focus on the more traditional
- 00:59format of mentoring as a one to one
- 01:02relationship between a more senior
- 01:04and a more junior faculty member.
- 01:06But I don't in any way mean to
- 01:09diminish these other mentoring formats.
- 01:11And as I'll emphasize later,
- 01:13you should be thinking about
- 01:15mentoring relationships.
- 01:16In the plural,
- 01:17rather than as one person who can do all
- 01:21facets of mentoring equally well for you,
- 01:24the old mentor protege model of that
- 01:28single established experts tearing
- 01:29their trainee along a path to success,
- 01:32is somewhat outdated when it comes to
- 01:36most junior faculty career development.
- 01:39Later I will return to an important
- 01:43distinction between career mentor,
- 01:45a promotion advisor and a job supervisor.
- 01:49But putting aside those distinctions
- 01:51for a moment,
- 01:53whether the mentor you have is
- 01:56a formal or informal one,
- 01:58there are usually important
- 02:01differences in expertise,
- 02:02position,
- 02:03or power between a mentor and
- 02:06mentee and nonetheless,
- 02:07mentoring is usually considered.
- 02:10A more collegial or collaborative
- 02:13relationship than is atypical,
- 02:14supervisory or management relationship.
- 02:19Common elements of mentoring include
- 02:22focusing on the career development of
- 02:24a more junior person by providing them
- 02:27support and guidance to achieve their goals.
- 02:30Other elements include role modeling,
- 02:32socializing, and coaching.
- 02:34Role modeling involves setting an example,
- 02:37but being a respected and
- 02:39accomplished professional.
- 02:40Socializing involves making connections
- 02:43within one's academic institution as
- 02:46well as with a professional network
- 02:49beyond the walls of where we work.
- 02:52And then finally,
- 02:54coaching focuses not so much on
- 02:57teaching technical skills but more
- 02:59on the interpersonal or strategic
- 03:02or communication skills that are
- 03:05needed to effectively navigate
- 03:07the academic hierarchy.
- 03:09The promotion process,
- 03:11and some workplace politics.
- 03:15Before I dig deeper into the characteristics
- 03:18of effective mentors and mentee's,
- 03:20I would like to ask you to do a brief
- 03:23exercise to reflect on your own concept
- 03:26of a great mentor and I'm a psychologist.
- 03:30And so I've got to do some kind of imagery
- 03:34exercise to kind of break the ice.
- 03:37To do this short imagery exercise.
- 03:39It'll take a couple minutes.
- 03:41Then I'll ask if you're willing to share in
- 03:44chat some brief impressions for the imagery.
- 03:47Exercise just so people aren't
- 03:49self conscious about it.
- 03:51I ask you if you have your camera on now to
- 03:54just turn it off for a couple of minutes.
- 03:57That way you can close your eyes and
- 03:58not feel like somebody's watching
- 04:00you with your eyes closed.
- 04:01So if you just take a minute and
- 04:03then turn your cameras off for a
- 04:05couple of minutes and then I'll begin
- 04:08and then I'll tell you when you can
- 04:10turn your camera's back on.
- 04:12So we could start.
- 04:14Please close your eyes and let's
- 04:16start by picturing the person you were
- 04:18when you first started high school
- 04:21or whatever your school was called
- 04:23when you were 14 or 15 years old.
- 04:27Imagine yourself walking through
- 04:29the hallways of that school and
- 04:32those times in your life.
- 04:41And remember, some of the positive
- 04:43adults who were major influencers
- 04:45of your success and satisfaction
- 04:48in these teenage years and beyond.
- 04:53He's adults may have
- 04:55been exemplary teachers.
- 04:58Or sports coaches?
- 05:00Or Performing Arts instructors.
- 05:04Or a religious leader or club advisor.
- 05:07Or perhaps a parent or another
- 05:10older family member.
- 05:12Then just get a picture of them.
- 05:21And as you bring to mind an honor,
- 05:24these special people try to single
- 05:26out one person whose influence
- 05:28was especially important during
- 05:30these years and think about them.
- 05:42The next picture yourself when you
- 05:45first started college or University.
- 05:48Imagine yourself walking through
- 05:50campus, in and out of buildings.
- 05:56Again, remember those positive adults
- 05:58who were major influencers of your
- 06:02success and satisfaction at this time.
- 06:21Again, try to single out the one person.
- 06:25Who was especially influential shaping
- 06:28your development your interests?
- 06:31In your talents at this time?
- 06:41And finally picture yourself in
- 06:43medical school or Graduate School
- 06:46or other some other time during your
- 06:49advanced health specialty training.
- 06:53Once again, picture some of those
- 06:56major influencers of your development,
- 06:59direction and achievements.
- 07:11And select one who was especially
- 07:14influential in important to you.
- 07:17And before I ask you to open
- 07:20your eyes in another minute,
- 07:22I would like you to just take a minute
- 07:26and picture this select group of people
- 07:30standing together in front of you.
- 07:33Whether that's three of them or two,
- 07:36or if it's just one.
- 07:39But picture that group
- 07:41standing in front of you.
- 07:44Picture them looking at you with
- 07:46pride at what you've become.
- 07:48A faculty member at Yale Medical School.
- 07:52And try to come up in your mind with a
- 07:55short phrase or a brief sentence that
- 07:58would summarize for other people what
- 08:01those mentors did or meant for you.
- 08:04A short explanation or phrase that
- 08:07succinctly captures the essence of what
- 08:11those important people did for you.
- 08:14And steering you along your path.
- 08:16To success over the past decades.
- 08:36And remember that summary sentence
- 08:39or phrase is you now open your eyes
- 08:42and as you turn your video back on,
- 08:45if you had had it turned off before.
- 08:49And after you get your video back on and.
- 08:53Eyes open if you're comfortable doing so,
- 08:56please type in the phrase or sentence
- 08:58that came to mind that describe these
- 09:02special people in the chat and.
- 09:04I'll I'll try to read out some of them that
- 09:07that people hopefully are willing to share.
- 09:15Of caring believed in me.
- 09:19Knew you could do it?
- 09:21Kind. In my corner.
- 09:31Beyond imagination. Time generous.
- 09:34They were confident I was.
- 09:37So I gotta get my.
- 09:40Those confident was capable of succeeding,
- 09:43even if I wasn't sure encouraged
- 09:45and kept me motivated.
- 09:47Positive supporting gave tough feedback,
- 09:49unnecessary presented opportunities,
- 09:51supported me and suggested
- 09:53opportunities whenever possible,
- 09:54generous with their time.
- 09:56These special people encourage my
- 09:59creativity and helped me on my path,
- 10:02not forcing me on someone elses path.
- 10:06Support me in difficult decisions,
- 10:08nurturing, knowledgeable in lightning
- 10:09made my dreams feel within reach.
- 10:12Maybe strive for my for the best.
- 10:15That thanks.
- 10:16Thanks everybody for sharing those.
- 10:18I appreciate that.
- 10:19Very inspirational as as you would
- 10:22as you would imagine them to be.
- 10:25I do this exercise for a couple reasons.
- 10:291st, for many people,
- 10:31it powerfully brings to mind
- 10:32the characteristics of excellent
- 10:35mentors influence influential
- 10:36people who provided knowledge,
- 10:39guidance, teaching,
- 10:39help, advice,
- 10:40stimulation during really
- 10:42important transitional times,
- 10:43and 2nd if you're like me remembering,
- 10:46these people can evoke a variety
- 10:49of emotions and whatever those
- 10:52feelings happened to be for you.
- 10:54One thing is pretty clear,
- 10:56these people have been very
- 10:59important to our development.
- 11:01They believed in us inspired us,
- 11:03encouraged us,
- 11:04but they may also have also been criticized,
- 11:07challenged,
- 11:08corrected us all in an effort to make
- 11:12us better at what we were trying to do.
- 11:16And then a final reason I raise
- 11:18it is that I think it's really
- 11:21important to be realistic when
- 11:22you begin the process of finding
- 11:25a career mentor here or anywhere.
- 11:27And that is that you alone don't have
- 11:30the power to recreate your old mentors.
- 11:33Don't unrealistically expect a new
- 11:34mentor to fill an old mentor shoes.
- 11:37The Times are different and you
- 11:39are in your different and no one
- 11:42mentor can check off all these
- 11:43boxes that the qualities on on
- 11:46this slide our aspiration's.
- 11:47They're not role requirements and and
- 11:50you should also keep these in mind
- 11:53as you become a mentor for others
- 11:55and and also keep in mind that no one,
- 11:58including you can do all of these well.
- 12:01So be realistic about yourself in
- 12:04others as you approach mentoring
- 12:06from either side of the coin and
- 12:09this gets back to my prior point
- 12:11about the plural of mentors.
- 12:13It's really important to use multiple
- 12:16people to provide as many of the
- 12:19things on this list as you feel
- 12:21you need and accept the reality.
- 12:24Sometimes painful reality that
- 12:26some faculty are truly amazing,
- 12:28it providing certain kinds of personal
- 12:30or professional development support.
- 12:32And at the same time they can be
- 12:34totally mediocre or even terrible
- 12:36at doing other things.
- 12:38So be being realistic is important.
- 12:42I've tried to assemble from a couple
- 12:45of sources, some mentoring essentials.
- 12:47Excellent mentors promote sponsorship
- 12:49and visibility through network
- 12:51facilitation and involving you
- 12:52and collaborations with others.
- 12:54They provide positive regard and
- 12:56still confidence and give help,
- 12:58help and kind of know when to give
- 13:02help and when not to give help.
- 13:05They push for excellence in productivity,
- 13:07but they don't expect perfection.
- 13:10Good mentors are trustworthy
- 13:12and professional.
- 13:13They follow through and
- 13:15provide constructive feedback.
- 13:16Trusted mentors are aware of and
- 13:19respectful of differences in gender,
- 13:22race, ethnicity and other identities
- 13:24different than their own and are
- 13:27able to discuss sensitive issues
- 13:29as they arrive as they arise.
- 13:32They. Advocate,
- 13:33they protect or support their men.
- 13:36Tease during and after adverse
- 13:38or painful experiences.
- 13:40Good mentors are aware that a mentoring
- 13:43relationship that shifts into a
- 13:45romantic relationship is considered
- 13:48unprofessional and is almost never
- 13:50helpful to the career development
- 13:52of either person in the long run.
- 13:56And then when difficulties or
- 13:58obstacles do occur and they,
- 14:01and they certainly do good mentor,
- 14:03strive to be non defensive,
- 14:06transparent and admit their
- 14:08limitations or mistakes.
- 14:10And then finally,
- 14:11excellent mentors are active in their field.
- 14:13They know how to set limits on time,
- 14:16demands that they have,
- 14:18and they role model satisfaction
- 14:21both in their work in their life.
- 14:23And likewise there are some
- 14:26essentials to being a good mentee.
- 14:28It may be unrealistic for you
- 14:31to be all these things,
- 14:33just as it's unrealistic to expect
- 14:36perfection in your mentor or mentors.
- 14:38However,
- 14:39research suggests that these are
- 14:41among the many qualities most
- 14:43mentores value in working with them.
- 14:45NT motivation, hard work, good communication.
- 14:48Following through on plans and completing
- 14:51tasks in emerging independence.
- 14:52And then depending on the.
- 14:54Mentor that you have there may be other
- 14:57qualities that they particularly value,
- 14:59and that's important to have an
- 15:02open discussion about those as well.
- 15:05A good meant he regards their time
- 15:08with a mentor as precious and doesn't
- 15:11waste it by by not following through
- 15:14on plans or canceling meetings or
- 15:17taking the relationship for granted.
- 15:22So here's another just very short
- 15:24exercise that will use chat for not
- 15:27now now that you're equipped with some
- 15:29information about good mentoring and
- 15:31based on your own prior experiences and
- 15:34some of those images that you had before,
- 15:37I like you to take a look at this picture
- 15:40for a second and type into the chat 2
- 15:43details about the picture that seem
- 15:46relevant to the theme of effective mentoring.
- 15:49What is happening in the picture really?
- 15:52Anything that you see that relates to this
- 15:55theme of effective mentoring and just.
- 15:58Type in a few if you feel so moved.
- 16:03Steady. Leading collaborative
- 16:12Com one can see forward right?
- 16:14Yeah, the other ones got doesn't
- 16:16really know where he's going, does He?
- 16:19Horoz on both sides yes.
- 16:21And and they're both in the water,
- 16:23which is, which is good.
- 16:25Only one person using yours.
- 16:28Trust active.
- 16:33Engaged.
- 16:38Happy. Someone unnoticed 1 one time.
- 16:42That said, You know she's
- 16:44keeping him out of the weeds,
- 16:47which is sometimes really
- 16:49important in academia, balanced.
- 16:51Reflection great thanks, thanks Ann.
- 16:53One more set of images.
- 16:55These are what I would call
- 16:57unseaworthy images and if you
- 16:59could take it just a quick look
- 17:01at each of the four pictures and
- 17:03trying to identify what just one
- 17:05detail from each of them that seems
- 17:08inconsistent with the theme of
- 17:10effective mentoring and again just
- 17:12type them into the box and I'll.
- 17:14I'll try to read read them off.
- 17:22Romantic. One person doing all of the work.
- 17:31Unbalanced chaotic.
- 17:40Not moving forward,
- 17:42not no one doing the work.
- 17:45Top left loss of control distracted.
- 17:54Overwhelmed top right?
- 17:59Anything else about the top right one?
- 18:03And I don't mean that one to be an
- 18:06insult to you know mentoring that's done
- 18:10among among peers of about the same age.
- 18:14But it's not entirely clear.
- 18:16Kind of who the mentor is in that boat.
- 18:20And then about the one in the
- 18:23lower right, let's matter.
- 18:24But what does that mean for people?
- 18:30I'll I'll touch on this a little bit later,
- 18:33but the way I read that is that you
- 18:36can have a great mentoring plan,
- 18:39but you don't get two people in the same
- 18:42boat or find a way to make that happen.
- 18:45It's not going to happen.
- 18:48Thanks, some kind of other,
- 18:50just touch on some other
- 18:52obstacles to effective mentoring.
- 18:54Here are some other ways that
- 18:57they can get in the way of finding
- 19:01and working with a good mentor.
- 19:05First, the best mentors are sometimes
- 19:07very busy and sometimes you know getting
- 19:10on their schedule can be difficult and
- 19:13staying on their schedule can be difficult.
- 19:16Most mentores have not received
- 19:18training and how to mentor some.
- 19:20Some old timers are not.
- 19:22Academia still have mistaken beliefs
- 19:24rooted in their own hard worn one success.
- 19:28They may feel that particularly
- 19:30places like Yale that true superstars
- 19:32shouldn't need much help along the way.
- 19:35And and again,
- 19:36I would argue that.
- 19:38So that's an outdated viewpoint.
- 19:42And obstacles for men Tees often
- 19:44center around the actual initiating
- 19:46and sustaining the relationship,
- 19:48overtime,
- 19:49or sometimes feeling a cornice
- 19:51of fit with a particular mentor.
- 19:54Sometimes performance,
- 19:55anxiety or impostor issues,
- 19:56intrude or we want to show a
- 19:59senior faculty that we can succeed
- 20:01with minimal mentoring or advice?
- 20:04Or we don't want to intrude on
- 20:06their busy schedule?
- 20:08Other obstacles or problems only
- 20:09emerged over the course of a
- 20:12relation of the Relationship.
- 20:13And when that happens,
- 20:15a good mentor and mentee know how to
- 20:18slow things down and reopen the up.
- 20:21The lines of communication and try
- 20:23to understand the impasse, or.
- 20:26Or rupture in the relationship.
- 20:29Wanna spend just a few minutes talking
- 20:32about various relationships that
- 20:34I think are important to consider
- 20:36under a broad category of mentoring?
- 20:39All our important,
- 20:41extremely important to successful
- 20:43academic career?
- 20:44One of the benefits of being in a
- 20:46place like this is that there are
- 20:49usually a large number of exceptionally
- 20:51talented and committed people who
- 20:54could potentially serve some form
- 20:56of mentoring function for you.
- 20:58Many are very willing to meet with you
- 21:01occasionally if you take the initiative.
- 21:04But it is really important to be
- 21:07aware of just how hierarchical and
- 21:09academic culture can be and how
- 21:11one goes about accessing advice or
- 21:14guidance from various faculty who
- 21:17might be in mentoring relationships with you.
- 21:20Importantly,
- 21:20how to manage conflicting opinions
- 21:22that often arise in these discussions,
- 21:25differences between what you want to
- 21:27do and what one mentor thinks you could do,
- 21:31and how all that aligns or
- 21:34doesn't align with.
- 21:35The expectations of the more senior
- 21:37Pi or clinical director or training
- 21:40director or section chief that you report to.
- 21:46And related to this,
- 21:48it's really important to appreciate the
- 21:50distinction between a job supervisor,
- 21:53Anna career mentor a job supervisor's
- 21:56role is to direct your assignments,
- 21:59steer your activity,
- 22:00and evaluate your performance.
- 22:02Career mentoring is not
- 22:04necessarily the primary purpose
- 22:05of a supervisory relationship.
- 22:08You may get occasional Nuggets of
- 22:11mentoring gold from those relationships,
- 22:13but you should view these as gifts.
- 22:17Rather than entitlements
- 22:19within the relationship.
- 22:21And whenever a relationship strongly
- 22:23mixes sort of equal parts supervision
- 22:25or direction and mentoring,
- 22:27it may be important for mentors to be
- 22:30clear when they're changing hats and
- 22:32for you for you to seek clarification
- 22:35when you're unsure if something said
- 22:38was meant as a kind of a suggestion
- 22:42of something to think about,
- 22:44versus something was said,
- 22:45that is an expected action
- 22:47that you're expected to take.
- 22:52Job supervising appointment and promotion
- 22:56advising and career mentoring are best
- 23:01thought of as distinct activities that.
- 23:05Sometimes overlap the frequency of job,
- 23:08supervisory or performance focused mentoring
- 23:10will usually not be determined by you,
- 23:13but usually more by your Pi or
- 23:17unit director or section chief.
- 23:19When I say strive for monthly
- 23:22meetings with the supervisor,
- 23:24I don't necessarily mean a 30 minute
- 23:28individual office appointment.
- 23:29Alot of these meetings can occur
- 23:32on the fly or in small groups, or.
- 23:36Hallway conversations but just having
- 23:38some regular contact with the people
- 23:41that are really steering your your
- 23:44your job as a faculty member in the
- 23:47early years of being here is important.
- 23:50With regard to amp,
- 23:52advising appointment, promotion advising,
- 23:54most departments offer annual
- 23:56meetings with junior faculty to
- 23:58discuss academic progress,
- 23:59but you should always request
- 24:02additional meetings when you need
- 24:04it or when you have questions.
- 24:11Finding a career mentor can be more
- 24:14of a challenge for some faculty.
- 24:17As in most cases, the faculty who serve
- 24:19as your job supervisors will have been
- 24:22involved in recruiting you or been
- 24:24assigned to you and and the advisors
- 24:27around Reappointment and promotion may
- 24:29be assigned or managed by committees
- 24:31or senior leaders in your Department.
- 24:33You'll usually need to be more active
- 24:36and take the most initiative in
- 24:38finding and selecting someone who's
- 24:41more of a general career mentor and
- 24:44finding a good match may take the
- 24:46better part of your first term,
- 24:49may involve getting to know people
- 24:51in your Department or outside your
- 24:54Department and setting up some
- 24:57informational interviews with them.
- 24:59It's important to find someone.
- 25:03Lost my place here.
- 25:06Can everyone still see the slide?
- 25:10Someone can just yes.
- 25:14OK, oh OK, here we go.
- 25:17Just on this last slide,
- 25:19before I move on to the next one,
- 25:23it's important to find someone more
- 25:26experienced than you as a mentor.
- 25:28They don't don't have always have to be
- 25:32a full professor or have been here for
- 25:35as long as some of us have been here,
- 25:39but but someone who's been here longer
- 25:42who can bring a broader perspective
- 25:45to advise you on your plans.
- 25:48Can be honest with you and help expose you
- 25:51to various academic resources and people.
- 25:54Very important to find someone you
- 25:57respect who's interpersonal style
- 25:58feels compatible with yours and
- 26:00who is understanding or sensitive
- 26:02to issues of diverse identities.
- 26:04And then once you find them,
- 26:07ask if they would be willing to
- 26:09meet with you several times a year.
- 26:13Three times a year or four times a year,
- 26:15and and to kind of ask them to be
- 26:18one of several mentors for you.
- 26:20Sometimes people are not so willing to say,
- 26:23will you be my mentor?
- 26:25Where where you see them as being
- 26:27the only person that they're going
- 26:29to that you're going to rely on.
- 26:31But most people are willing to
- 26:33be one of a group of people that
- 26:35will meet with you periodically to
- 26:38kind of kind of help steer you.
- 26:40And then once you have someone
- 26:42agreeing with that,
- 26:43just sort of clarify expectations boundaries.
- 26:45In goals
- 26:48As part of the selection process,
- 26:50it's really important to reflect on your
- 26:53broader long-term objectives and how
- 26:55mentoring can help reflect on what you
- 26:58want out of a particular relationship
- 27:00and what you want to accomplish.
- 27:02How you want to change,
- 27:04and what risks and initiatives you are
- 27:06willing to take to develop new skills.
- 27:09I wanna show just a short 2 minute
- 27:12video to illustrate by asking
- 27:14yourself these important questions
- 27:15about kind of what type of mentor?
- 27:18You need is important after the
- 27:21first 30 seconds of the chalk talk.
- 27:24Listen to how differently these students.
- 27:26I think their students described
- 27:28their view of a mentor and what,
- 27:31if anything, they look for with a mentor.
- 27:36Mentoring.
- 27:38Starts
- 27:40with. Mutuality and that is a
- 27:44relationship between two people.
- 27:47There is based on give and take
- 27:50both give but both received,
- 27:53but it's grounded in two philosophes
- 27:56and those philosophes include trust.
- 27:59And respect. So any good,
- 28:02effective mentoring would
- 28:04have a mutual relationship.
- 28:05A mutually beneficial relationship
- 28:07between two individuals.
- 28:08That's grounded in trust and respect.
- 28:11I think mentoring is like a moving target.
- 28:15It's this amorphis thing doesn't
- 28:17really have this particular form,
- 28:19which makes it hard to
- 28:21describe or understand,
- 28:22but it exists in it's important and
- 28:25effective mentor is someone that
- 28:26allows them NT space to grow and
- 28:29to find their voice and academics
- 28:31and really find their identity.
- 28:34So for me,
- 28:35an effective mentor is someone who
- 28:38challenges me an challenges my
- 28:40ideas and really pushes me too.
- 28:42Lauren experience different things.
- 28:44I'm an individual that really needs
- 28:47to be challenged in away and sort of
- 28:49stimulate it in order to find what
- 28:51I need in my life and in my career.
- 28:53So for me it could be someone
- 28:55who is pushing me to write a new
- 28:58grant or to go and like do these
- 29:01training exercises then gain
- 29:03this experience that will one day
- 29:05hopefully making more successful.
- 29:07When I think of mentoring,
- 29:08I really think about access because
- 29:10in this core body of knowledge are
- 29:13theories and ideas and people to which
- 29:15students typically don't have access.
- 29:17But mentors can bribe them.
- 29:19Access to these people access to
- 29:21these ideas through potentially
- 29:22journals or other ways,
- 29:23but access to resources,
- 29:25grants and other kinds of things.
- 29:27But a key part of mentoring is also
- 29:29support when you think about all of the
- 29:32things you need in your discipline,
- 29:34sometimes you just need that physical
- 29:36support and emotional support.
- 29:38Sometimes it's spiritual that
- 29:39personal support.
- 29:40You need to get from a really
- 29:42challenging data the next day
- 29:44and the last is information.
- 29:45Those are the rules.
- 29:47The policies and procedures
- 29:48that every program, every job,
- 29:50everything we do seems to have and
- 29:52someone can help you through a mentor,
- 29:54ship,
- 29:55roll,
- 29:55give you that information so
- 29:56that you don't spend too much
- 29:58time seeking it out yourself.
- 30:00So the three areas together really
- 30:03define effective mentoring relationship.
- 30:04Really knowing your mentee or
- 30:06getting another on a personal level
- 30:08so it's one thing to know your
- 30:09mentee at a superficial level.
- 30:11Or maybe just looking at their
- 30:12resume or their
- 30:13CV or their application and
- 30:15knowing them on the surface,
- 30:16but you really need to get
- 30:18to know them as a person.
- 30:20If you're going to be an effective mentor,
- 30:22you need to be able to know who they are,
- 30:25what makes them tick,
- 30:26what they want to do,
- 30:27how they want to do,
- 30:29and what their expectations are,
- 30:30what their goals are, what they find as,
- 30:32or what they define as success.
- 30:34Words like open minded come up
- 30:38receptive but also sort of.
- 30:41Willing to participate in a
- 30:44sort of volume back and forth.
- 30:47I think of reciprocal sort of pedagogy,
- 30:51so like being open to learning from them NT,
- 30:56as well as helping them NT learn themselves.
- 31:00I also think of security
- 31:03knowing that you can.
- 31:05Be someone that creates a safe place
- 31:07for someone to talk about exploration,
- 31:11like in my case or. Even.
- 31:15Just fellowship with people.
- 31:18Let me give you more information
- 31:20about what I mean by mutuality.
- 31:22When I think about mentor
- 31:24mentee relationship,
- 31:24I think of a mutually beneficial partnership.
- 31:27Each person gives an gains
- 31:28from the relationship.
- 31:29Now this may be contrary to what we
- 31:32think about mentoring in an academic
- 31:34environment where a faculty member or a
- 31:36professor possesses all the knowledge.
- 31:38And in fact the definition of
- 31:40professor means an expert in something.
- 31:42But that's an old way of thinking
- 31:45about mentoring.
- 31:45That's the protege model or The
- 31:47Apprentice model where one person
- 31:49gives and the other person receives.
- 31:51But I consider it a partnership,
- 31:53two individuals, each gaining an,
- 31:55each giving in the relationship
- 31:57because each person brings something
- 31:59unique to that Partnership.
- 32:00For example, in an academic environment,
- 32:02a faculty member may bring expertise
- 32:04about research for teaching,
- 32:06but a student may bring expertise
- 32:08because they've been in industry
- 32:10for the last 15 years or they
- 32:12worked in the community.
- 32:14They bring expertise to
- 32:15the relationship to an.
- 32:16It's recognizing that
- 32:18partnership is Akita mutuality.
- 32:20So for me,
- 32:20because I had such a great
- 32:22experience as a mentee,
- 32:22I want to pay it forward in any
- 32:24students who come to me or refer
- 32:25to me for mentor ship like I just
- 32:27want to make sure that they have the
- 32:29same kind of experience that I had.
- 32:30Or I could do everything possible
- 32:31to make sure that they stick in
- 32:33the community that they find a
- 32:34friend group or someone that they
- 32:35can have support with.
- 32:37So as you can see in that video,
- 32:41the views of what we need for metrics
- 32:44can vary widely between men. Tease.
- 32:47Next, I'd like to shift a bit from
- 32:50individual to organizational plans.
- 32:52All departments are expected an
- 32:55I believe have a plan for their
- 32:58Department based mentoring program.
- 33:01Listed here are the recommended guidelines
- 33:03for mentoring of new assistant professors.
- 33:07Mentors are expected to help
- 33:10with career planning, advice,
- 33:12networking, an feedback.
- 33:16And men Tees are expected to be
- 33:19accountable for the goals they set.
- 33:22Seek advice and feedback.
- 33:24Take the initiative on
- 33:25scheduling mentoring meetings,
- 33:27and keep documents up-to-date
- 33:29to facilitate various career
- 33:30development discussions.
- 33:34Before we open up for some chat questions,
- 33:39just a couple slides related to plans
- 33:44are office hopes to implement in 2021.
- 33:49We hope to revisit and re evaluate
- 33:52the mentoring program plans for
- 33:54each Department and get a better
- 33:56sense of whether faculty are meeting
- 33:59with a more senior faculty members
- 34:02serving in one or more of those roles
- 34:05that we've talked about advising,
- 34:07supervising, and or mentoring.
- 34:09We hope to provide more tools to support
- 34:12departmental implementation of their plans.
- 34:14An one way we've had proposed is to
- 34:17support departmental mentoring by
- 34:19offering or mentor training workshop.
- 34:21That's adapted from the model
- 34:24used at Yale Biwi CCI,
- 34:26and Jonathan Grauer is leading our team's
- 34:29effort to overhaul the oh APD website so
- 34:32that it can serve as a useful resource
- 34:35for career development initiatives,
- 34:37including guidance and tools for
- 34:40faculty to use and mentoring.
- 34:43Here's just a sample of some questions
- 34:45that can help guide and individual
- 34:47development plan you can complete along
- 34:50with your CV and CV Part 2 and will be
- 34:53doing a workshop on CV and CV Part 2
- 34:56later in the year or starting next year.
- 34:59These documents are important to help shape
- 35:01discussions in your mentoring meetings,
- 35:03giving some thought to these plans can
- 35:06help you focus on the longer term goals
- 35:09you have for your first years of your term.
- 35:13And then you can drill down on the
- 35:15shorter term is what they call smart goals
- 35:18that are more specific and strategic
- 35:21and can help guide requests that you
- 35:23make for support or assistance from
- 35:26other faculty within your Department
- 35:29or outside of your Department.
- 35:31Other examples of really good mentoring
- 35:34resources can be found through the
- 35:37VA's career development award program.
- 35:40They on their website,
- 35:43they have developed useful downloadable
- 35:45forms for various aspects of initiating
- 35:48or maintaining a strong goal focused
- 35:52mentoring program.
- 35:55And I'll leave this slide up for
- 36:00a minute as we begin the chat.
- 36:05For people to look at while
- 36:08we have a little bit of Q&A.
- 36:10If people want to turn their videos and
- 36:13audios on to ask questions, that's fine.
- 36:16Or if you just assume use the Q
- 36:19and a function on chat are used,
- 36:21chat, that would be fine,
- 36:23but Suffice it to say the research
- 36:25on mentoring is extensive and it's
- 36:28not limited to higher education.
- 36:30Mentoring has shown to improve retention.
- 36:33Advancement, professionalism,
- 36:34commitment, motivation,
- 36:35productivity and job satisfaction
- 36:38and mentoring and importantly
- 36:40helps decrease stress conflict.
- 36:42Unhappiness reduces turnover and burnout,
- 36:45so with that final kind of summary
- 36:49of why we should be all be doing
- 36:54more of this and availing ourselves
- 36:58of of our mentors.
- 37:01Thank you very much for
- 37:03your time and attention.
- 37:04Please feel free to reach out
- 37:06to those in your Department or
- 37:08at the office of academic and
- 37:10professional development if
- 37:12you have any related questions.