Focal Therapy for Prostate Cancer/Prostate Cancer Awareness
September 14, 2020Information
September 6, 2020
Yale Cancer Center
visit: http://www.yalecancercenter.org
email: canceranswers@yale.edu
call: 203-785-4095
ID5581
To CiteDCA Citation Guide
- 00:00Support for Yale Cancer Answers
- 00:03comes from AstraZeneca, dedicated
- 00:06to providing innovative treatment
- 00:09options for people living with
- 00:13cancer. Learn more at astrazeneca-us.com.
- 00:14Welcome to Yale Cancer Answers.
- 00:16with your host Dr. Anees Chagpar.
- 00:19Yale Cancer Answers features the
- 00:21latest information on cancer care by
- 00:23welcoming oncologists and specialists
- 00:25who are on the forefront of the
- 00:27battle to fight cancer. This week,
- 00:29it's a conversation about focal
- 00:30therapy for prostate cancer
- 00:32with Doctor Preston Sprenkle.
- 00:33Doctor Sprenkle is an associate
- 00:36professor of urology at the Yale School
- 00:39of Medicine where Doctor Chagpar
- 00:41is a professor of surgical oncology.
- 00:44September is
- 00:46Prostate Cancer Awareness Month.
- 00:48Tell us what's new and
- 00:51interesting in the world
- 00:52of prostate cancer.
- 00:54Well, we're making a lot of
- 00:56advances in the treatment of
- 00:59high risk advanced disease with
- 01:01many new medications that have
- 01:04been released in treatments
- 01:06on the diagnostic side,
- 01:08we've continued to pioneer
- 01:10improvements in noninvasive
- 01:11diagnostics such as prostate MRI.
- 01:14And we're very excited to continue
- 01:16to identify patients who may
- 01:18not need evaluation.
- 01:19Or maybe we can avoid a prostate biopsy.
- 01:22Wow, that all sounds
- 01:23really interesting.
- 01:24Those are two very
- 01:26different ends of the spectrum,
- 01:28so maybe we will take each of them in turn
- 01:31and work our way from prevention
- 01:34all the way up to metastatic disease.
- 01:37In terms of prevention and detection,
- 01:40you mentioned that you have been doing
- 01:42some great work in terms of detection.
- 01:45Tell us more about that and
- 01:47what are the current guidelines in terms
- 01:50of what people should be doing in order
- 01:53to either prevent prostate cancer or
- 01:56find it early.
- 01:58Prostate cancer screening, which is evaluation of risk
- 02:00factors for prostate cancer,
- 02:02has been somewhat controversial
- 02:04over the last decade. Fortunately,
- 02:06within the past five or six years,
- 02:09it has become pretty clear that screening
- 02:12for prostate cancer remains a very important
- 02:15part of menn's general health.
- 02:17So we screen for prostate cancer
- 02:20starting in men at around the age of 50.
- 02:23If a man has a higher risk feature for
- 02:26potentially having prostate cancer,
- 02:28which currently is a first degree
- 02:31relative with prostate cancer or
- 02:33being of Afro Caribbean descent,
- 02:35those men can be screened even
- 02:37earlier at around age 40 to 45.
- 02:40And by screening.
- 02:41this entails a PSA blood test.
- 02:43So it's a simple blood test
- 02:45as well as a
- 02:48physical examination of the prostate
- 02:49with a digital rectal exam.
- 02:52Are those recommendations in terms of if you
- 02:54don't have one of those high risk features,
- 02:57every man at the age of 50 should have
- 02:59a PSA and a digital rectal exam?
- 03:02As you say,
- 03:04it's been so controversial and it seems
- 03:07like it gets really confusing.
- 03:09They say everybody should do this,
- 03:10sometimes they say, well,
- 03:12you should really talk to your
- 03:14doctor about pros and cons.
- 03:16So where are we at right now?
- 03:18I think the large part
- 03:21depends on who you talk to.
- 03:24Unfortunately, the US Preventive Services
- 03:26Task Force which is given the power
- 03:30to review and make recommendations on
- 03:33what kind of screening is necessary,
- 03:35in 2016, finally gave prostate cancer a
- 03:38more likely to be beneficial than not
- 03:42in terms of prostate cancer screening,
- 03:45so it is still, however,
- 03:47something that not everyone does routinely.
- 03:49I think for a man who is concerned
- 03:52about possibly having prostate cancer,
- 03:55they definitely should be screened.
- 03:57There are men who preferred not to,
- 04:00and the language,
- 04:01as used in many of the guidelines,
- 04:04is informed decision-making.
- 04:06And informed decision making is
- 04:08a challenging term because who
- 04:10is informing the patient?
- 04:11Very often primary care physicians
- 04:13do not have time to have a full
- 04:16informed discussion with their
- 04:18patients about what are the risks and
- 04:21benefits of prostate cancer screening.
- 04:23And so it is kind of challenging for
- 04:26them to be able to figure out when they
- 04:30should screen and when they should not.
- 04:33As urologists we are very comfortable
- 04:35having those discussions,
- 04:37but it's hard to say that across the
- 04:40board everyone should be screened.
- 04:48I think I'm still a little confused because,
- 04:51you know, at least coming
- 04:53from the breast cancer world,
- 04:54which is kind of my neck of the woods,
- 04:58it seems to me that screening
- 05:00allows people to detect cancer earlier,
- 05:02so if you told a woman
- 05:06you can get a mammogram,
- 05:07but it's really up to you,
- 05:10most women would say, well,
- 05:12I want to detect cancer early so that it
- 05:15can be treated more effectively and it
- 05:17reduces my chances of dying of the disease.
- 05:20So what does that conversation really
- 05:22look like in terms of prostate cancer?
- 05:25When you're talking to a man about,
- 05:28should you get prostate cancer
- 05:30screening or not?
- 05:31Let's suppose that they don't have
- 05:33one of those high risk features.
- 05:35They haven't had a family history and
- 05:37they are not of Afro Caribbean descent,
- 05:40but they are your regular 60
- 05:42year old Caucasian gentleman who
- 05:44really doesn't have family history
- 05:46of cancer but doesn't want to be
- 05:49the first one to get it either.
- 05:51And doesn't want to find it late.
- 05:54What does that conversation look like?
- 05:57How do men make that decision?
- 06:00because it seems to me that a
- 06:02lot of gentlemen are going
- 06:04to do whatever you recommend.
- 06:07I think you hit it on the head
- 06:10when you said men don't want to be the
- 06:13first one to be diagnosed with it either.
- 06:16I think there is a large
- 06:19component of fear.
- 06:22And as we discussed mens health,
- 06:25many men do not necessarily take care of
- 06:29themselves to the extent that women do,
- 06:32and so in a sense, we,
- 06:35as urologists and as physicians that
- 06:37are concerned with men's health,
- 06:40a large part of it is
- 06:43an information campaign to
- 06:45reassure men that we do have ways
- 06:48of managing these scary diseases,
- 06:50so the conversations are a large part
- 06:54about information,
- 06:56and helping men assess what is their
- 06:59actual risk of having prostate cancer.
- 07:02What is the drawback to screening?
- 07:04What is a drawback to having
- 07:07a simple blood test,
- 07:09which can be exceptionally
- 07:11reassuring if it's normal
- 07:13and a little bit anxiety provoking
- 07:15if it's not.
- 07:16But then what are the benefits of doing that?
- 07:20So there are more extended risk benefit
- 07:22discussions on a pretty routine basis.
- 07:25Overall the important thing to
- 07:27understand is that
- 07:29prostate cancer is common,
- 07:30but it's not so common that everyone gets it.
- 07:34It's common enough though,
- 07:35that most men as they get older
- 07:38are at risk and it's worth having
- 07:40some simple tests to evaluate if
- 07:42you are at higher risk than others.
- 07:45Because cancer can definitely be
- 07:48treated and stopped in his tracks, right?
- 07:50So it sounds like the general recommendation,
- 07:53and I know that
- 07:55we don't always want to give
- 07:57general recommendations,
- 07:58but it seems to me that in general this
- 08:01is something that people really should
- 08:03consider andvtalk to their doctor
- 08:06about in terms of getting screened.
- 08:09So let's move on to the next kind
- 08:11of phase after screening comes detection,
- 08:14and you alluded to some of the really
- 08:17interesting work that's been happening
- 08:19and pioneered really here at Yale.
- 08:21Tell us more about that work and
- 08:24where we are in terms of state of the
- 08:27art detection for prostate cancer.
- 08:31The first step as you
- 08:33mentioned is screening so that the
- 08:35first test with a PSA blood test and a
- 08:37prostate exam are the initial ways
- 08:40that we evaluate if a man may be at
- 08:42risk for harboring a prostate cancer.
- 08:47As you mentioned, Yale was one of the
- 08:50first sites around the country to
- 08:52be interested in use an MRI or a non
- 08:55invasive imaging test to evaluate a prostate
- 08:59and look at a prostate for
- 09:01possible cancers within it.
- 09:03It's really interesting as the
- 09:05prostate is the only solid organ
- 09:07until we started doing these mris,
- 09:09for which we did not have cross sectional
- 09:12imaging that could look inside the
- 09:15inside that organ to evaluate for tumors.
- 09:18So this has been a real boon
- 09:21in terms of our ability to
- 09:24diagnose prostate cancer in
- 09:24a non invasive manner.
- 09:30And so if somebody's
- 09:32PSA comes back high or
- 09:35somebody finds a lump in their
- 09:37prostate on digital rectal exam,
- 09:39is that the next step?
- 09:41It is at our institution.
- 09:44It is not the next step everywhere,
- 09:46because the reading and performance
- 09:48of the mris is an acquired skill
- 09:50and it does take experience.
- 09:52It is becoming more widespread to use
- 09:55an MRI of the prostate as the next step,
- 09:58and there recently have been
- 10:00some publications in major medical journals,
- 10:03including the New England
- 10:04Journal of Medicine,
- 10:06looking at MRI of the prostate,
- 10:08and really the important thing
- 10:10about MRI is combining it with
- 10:13a targeted prostate biopsy.
- 10:15So then using that information from
- 10:17the MRI and if suspicious areas are
- 10:19identified using that information
- 10:21to target or direct prostate
- 10:24biopsies to detect prostate cancer,
- 10:26the MRI alone is very useful,
- 10:29but it's really in combination
- 10:31with the biopsy.
- 10:32And is MRI
- 10:35covered by insurance
- 10:37for people who are at risk
- 10:40of prostate cancer or
- 10:42people who have an elevated
- 10:43PSA and so on, are most
- 10:46insurance companies covering this?
- 10:48I would say most
- 10:49are and especially now after
- 10:51some of those recent articles,
- 10:53including the one in the New England Journal,
- 10:56there is more support of that,
- 10:59but there still are some insurance
- 11:02companies that will not pay for an MRI
- 11:05as an initial diagnostic biopsy,
- 11:07they still require an initial transrectal
- 11:10ultrasound guided prostate biopsy,
- 11:11which is the goal which has been
- 11:15the gold standard for 30-40 years.
- 11:19They will require that first,
- 11:21and only if that does not detect cancer
- 11:23would they pay for an MRI targeted biopsy.
- 11:26I believe we're continuing
- 11:27to see a shift, though toward
- 11:29use of MRI as an initial diagnostic tool.
- 11:31In the United Kingdom
- 11:34it actually is mandatory.
- 11:36Anyone with an abnormal PSA
- 11:37that next step is an MRI,
- 11:39and they use it as a screening tool.
- 11:42We're not quite to that point
- 11:44yet in the United
- 11:45States.
- 11:47That's so interesting because we always think
- 11:48about the UK as being
- 11:50a country that really does put
- 11:52a premium on value in terms of
- 11:54healthcare costs and so on
- 11:57and their National Health System.
- 11:59It seems if they're adopting it,
- 12:02they have such a rigorous process to
- 12:04make sure that things are cost effective,
- 12:07that that would be reasonable to adopt.
- 12:11I think we're starting to get into
- 12:14some of the nuances of
- 12:17the health care systems and some
- 12:19of the cost and price disparities
- 12:22across providers that we see in
- 12:24the United States,
- 12:27which is a much bigger and
- 12:29more complicated discussion.
- 12:30But in general MRI is significantly
- 12:33cheaper across the pond than it is here.
- 12:37Interesting, so the next step,
- 12:39as you mentioned that goes hand in hand
- 12:43with the MRI of course is the biopsy.
- 12:46So tell me a little bit more
- 12:49about some of the work that's been
- 12:52going on with prostate biopsies.
- 12:55I understand that people are now
- 12:57looking at artificial intelligence
- 12:59and machine learning to improve
- 13:01biopsies of the prostate.
- 13:03That just sounds so Avantgarde.
- 13:07Well it is. It is one of the
- 13:10directions that
- 13:12we are embracing technology
- 13:15to improve what we do
- 13:18using that same MRI image
- 13:20in an MRI of the prostate,
- 13:22we are able to make a 3D model
- 13:25of the prostate gland and we
- 13:27combine that with a real time
- 13:30ultrasound 3D model of the prostate
- 13:33to guide our needle biopsy in
- 13:35the office so it's different than
- 13:37doing it in the MRI scanner where
- 13:40you do have an image and you
- 13:42have a 2D image and you can place
- 13:45the needle by using 3D imaging
- 13:47which allows us to perform the procedure
- 13:50in the office in the outpatient
- 13:52setting in a more convenient and for
- 13:54many patients more comfortable way.
- 13:56The machine learning is
- 13:59enhancing our modeling so it is
- 14:01making the way that we target
- 14:03the biopsy is much more accurate.
- 14:06We need to do delve more into that,
- 14:09but first we need to take short break
- 14:12for a medical minute. Please stay
- 14:15tuned to learn more about prostate
- 14:17cancer with my guest doctor
- 14:19Preston Spenkle.
- 14:22Support for Yale Cancer Answers comes from Astra Zeneca.
- 14:24Proud partner and personalized
- 14:26medicine developing tailored
- 14:27treatments for cancer patients.
- 14:29Learn more at astrazeneca-us.com.
- 14:32This is a medical minute about Melanoma.
- 14:35While Melanoma accounts for only
- 14:37about 4% of skin cancer cases,
- 14:39it causes the most skin cancer
- 14:41deaths. When detected early,
- 14:43however, Melanoma is easily treated
- 14:45and highly curable. Clinical
- 14:47trials are currently underway to test
- 14:49innovative new treatments for Melanoma.
- 14:51The goal of the specialized programs
- 14:54of research excellence in skin cancer
- 14:56or spore grant is to better understand
- 14:59the biology of skin cancer with a focus
- 15:02on discovering targets that will lead
- 15:05to improved diagnosis and treatment.
- 15:07More information is available
- 15:09at yalecancercenter.org.
- 15:10You're listening to Connecticut public radio.
- 15:15Welcome
- 15:16back to Yale Cancer Answers.
- 15:18This is doctor Anees Chagpar
- 15:20and I am joined tonight by my
- 15:23guest doctor Preston Sprenkle.
- 15:25We're talking about diagnosis and
- 15:27treatment of prostate cancer and
- 15:30right before the break Preston you
- 15:32were talking about this really cool
- 15:34technique of using MRI to diagnose
- 15:37prostate cancer and what was interesting
- 15:39was that you were talking about how
- 15:42that really gets paired with biopsy,
- 15:45but you're not doing biopsies
- 15:47in the MRI suite,
- 15:48which I can imagine is just
- 15:51claustrophobic and not the most
- 15:53comfortable setting in the world for men.
- 15:55But tell me a little bit more about how
- 15:58you take that MRI guided image
- 16:01to actually guide a biopsy that you're
- 16:05doing with ultrasound in your office.
- 16:09Yeah, so there are a few different
- 16:11technologies that are available.
- 16:13We talk about this as sort of a fusion.
- 16:16How do we fuse these two images
- 16:18and we can use cognitive fusion which
- 16:21is using the human brain to look at
- 16:252 pictures side by side and say OK
- 16:27this looks like where they line up.
- 16:30We then use computer fusion which is what
- 16:33we use at Yale with our Artemis Device.
- 16:36And then there are quite a few
- 16:38of these computer fusion devices
- 16:40that exist around the world.
- 16:46And we like using this Artemis device because it has,
- 16:48like I mentioned earlier,
- 16:50the ability to take a 3D model
- 16:53of the prostate from the MRI.
- 16:56We use Artemis Device to create a 3D model of
- 17:00the prostate with the ultrasound
- 17:02and then we overlap those and
- 17:04we're moving towards the computer
- 17:06having the ability to overlap them.
- 17:09Right now the urologist and surgeon are
- 17:12very involved in making sure
- 17:14the pictures lineup,
- 17:16but then the artificial intelligence
- 17:18side is learning what are the shapes
- 17:21of these prostates and can we predict
- 17:23how these prostates are going to
- 17:25deform and change and really matching
- 17:28up that fusion product or that model
- 17:31of the prostate so that it's much
- 17:34more precise and this translates
- 17:36to more accurate biopsies.
- 17:38The Artemis Device, just so that
- 17:41I've got this straight,
- 17:43I kind of get the idea that the
- 17:47man goes in and gets an MRI of the prostate,
- 17:51just like you get an MRI of your
- 17:54knee or your brain or whatever else.
- 17:57They get an MRI of the prostate.
- 17:59This Artemis device kind of takes that
- 18:02image and transforms it into an image
- 18:05that you could get with an ultrasound
- 18:07so that it can overlay it well.
- 18:10Interestingly,
- 18:11we still rely very much on
- 18:13non human interpretation so
- 18:15the radiologist takes the MRI,
- 18:16so a man will have an MRI of his prostate,
- 18:20the radiologist will read that and will
- 18:22evaluate and look at the MRI for
- 18:24any areas that look suspicious,
- 18:26they grade it on a standardized grading
- 18:28scale that was helped developed by
- 18:30one of our radiologist here at Yale,
- 18:32Jeff Weinreb.
- 18:33So it's an international scale and is
- 18:34now the gold standard,
- 18:36and that was partly designed at Yale,
- 18:39so they'll get a score of any
- 18:41lesions that are in the prostate.
- 18:43The radiologist then
- 18:45outlines the prostate and those images
- 18:47are imported into our Artemis device.
- 18:53I, or one of our other urologists,
- 18:55are doing the biopsies.
- 18:57We similarly use an ultrasound to
- 18:59make a model of the prostate and,
- 19:01then the job of the computer and what
- 19:04we're trying to improve with some of
- 19:06our mathematical models and
- 19:08artificial intelligence has now improved how
- 19:10those two pictures of the prostate,
- 19:13look or
- 19:16if they look different,
- 19:17why are they different and how do
- 19:18we correct for that difference?
- 19:21So this is interesting
- 19:24because you're taking two different
- 19:25pictures of the same organ done by
- 19:28different modalities, and
- 19:30if I understand this correctly,
- 19:32you're putting both of them
- 19:34into this Artemis system,
- 19:36which kind of lines them up and says
- 19:39what you saw here on the MRI is what
- 19:42you see here on the ultrasound and
- 19:45kind of making this image that
- 19:48when you see that on the ultrasound,
- 19:51that really is that area that was
- 19:52on the MRI and that's what you
- 19:54need to go after with your biopsy.
- 19:57Do I have that right?
- 19:58Yep, you're absolutely correct,
- 19:59so it's taking
- 20:00two things side by side.
- 20:02You can imagine these
- 20:04two pictures just merging into
- 20:06one and overlapping and we make
- 20:08sure that where those overlap
- 20:10appears correct and so then
- 20:11that that is a real boon because then
- 20:14you can use something that is
- 20:17patient friendly like an ultrasound
- 20:19and do the biopsy in the office.
- 20:21I mean that is just such cool technology.
- 20:24I wonder if the same thing can
- 20:26be done in other organ systems.
- 20:28Do you know if this Artemis
- 20:31devices is being used in other
- 20:33diseases?
- 20:35It isn't really
- 20:37because
- 20:39if you think about many other
- 20:41lesions, in liver lesions,
- 20:43many of those are very well
- 20:45visualized with ultrasound,
- 20:46and so the real time ultrasound is actually
- 20:50as good or better at characterizing
- 20:53where the lesion is than MRI or CT.
- 20:57That kind of fusion that we need
- 20:59to do for the prostate is kind of
- 21:02unique compared to, for example,
- 21:04the brain where you have a solid
- 21:07calvarium around the brain and
- 21:09so the ability to predict and do
- 21:11stereotactic localization within
- 21:13this solid structure is much
- 21:15easier than with a soft,
- 21:17malleable organ that is very able
- 21:19to move around within the pelvis.
- 21:22So the process is really kind of a
- 21:24unique location and a unique target
- 21:27given all these sort of anatomic limitations.
- 21:35Moving on from once you get the biopsy,
- 21:38let's talk a little
- 21:41bit about getting screening or a
- 21:43gentleman went and got screening,
- 21:45he got his MRI,
- 21:47he had this really cool artificial
- 21:49intelligence thing happening so
- 21:51he could have his biopsy in the
- 21:54office and he gets diagnosed
- 21:56with early stage prostate cancer
- 21:58because he found it really early.
- 22:02Tell us a little bit more about what's
- 22:04new and interesting in terms of the
- 22:07management of early prostate cancer.
- 22:10In the field of
- 22:12urology we are becoming much
- 22:15more comfortable with active
- 22:17surveillance or really a deferred
- 22:20treatment for men with prostate cancer.
- 22:22And that's based on many large studies.
- 22:25Now with long term follow up as well
- 22:27as a better understanding of the
- 22:30genomic nature of prostate cancer.
- 22:33So not only are we typically talking
- 22:36about things like the Gleason score
- 22:38when we are diagnosed with prostate cancer
- 22:41and the higher the Gleason score,
- 22:44the sort of worse the prognosis,
- 22:45or the more aggressive prostate cancer
- 22:47we are now able to sub stratify
- 22:50many of these patients using
- 22:52genomic testing which is specialized
- 22:54testing of the cancer cells themselves
- 22:56that tells us if it is at a lower risk
- 22:59and intermediate risk or higher risk of
- 23:01progression and developing metastasis.
- 23:03So I think one of the many
- 23:05exciting things is we feel more
- 23:08comfortable knowing who does not
- 23:10need treatment and really can avoid
- 23:12many of the side effects that
- 23:14we associate with treatment.
- 23:17And part and parcel of that is,
- 23:20I know that many gentlemen who
- 23:22get their prostate biopsy,
- 23:24they've got a low Gleason score and
- 23:26they're put on this watchful
- 23:28waiting regimen.
- 23:29But for some of them,
- 23:31that's really anxiety provoking, right?
- 23:32Because they're sitting there
- 23:34and we already talked before the break
- 23:37about how fearful some people are
- 23:38with a diagnosis of prostate cancer.
- 23:40Here you are telling people
- 23:42you've got a prostate cancer,
- 23:44but it's really
- 23:46pretty indolent, we think,
- 23:48so you don't need to be treated,
- 23:50but it sounds like with genomics
- 23:52you can get a little bit more
- 23:54personalized and say no,
- 23:55we've looked at your tumor,
- 23:57this is a very low score,
- 23:59but are there some people who would normally
- 24:02be in the watchful waiting category who,
- 24:04based on genomic analysis,
- 24:05you think, geez,
- 24:06I need to be a little bit more aggressive?
- 24:10I just want to
- 24:12caution and correct
- 24:13the terminology just for a second.
- 24:15So active surveillance is what
- 24:17we do for men with low grade,
- 24:19and low risk prostate cancer.
- 24:21Watchful waiting is what we
- 24:23characterize men with prostate
- 24:24cancer who do not want to treat it,
- 24:26nor do they want to do any follow up of it.
- 24:29Because prostate cancer
- 24:30is so slow growing,
- 24:31there are some men who are diagnosed
- 24:33who are elderly or have other health
- 24:35problems that decide they do not
- 24:36want to treat it because prostate
- 24:38cancer is so slow growing it will
- 24:40not cause them a problem ever.
- 24:42Those are sort of who we say are on
- 24:43watchful waiting because we're waiting
- 24:45for them to have any symptoms of
- 24:47their prostate cancer before we treat.
- 24:49Active surveillance is kind of the
- 24:51other end of the spectrum where
- 24:53men have a very low grade,
- 24:55low risk prostate cancer and we
- 24:57are actively surveilling their
- 24:59cancer for any signs that it has
- 25:01progressed or gotten to the point
- 25:03where it may require treatment
- 25:05or we may advise treatment,
- 25:06but you're absolutely right with
- 25:08a genomic testing we can now have
- 25:11much more confidence and much
- 25:12more security and telling some
- 25:14men that it's appropriate to watch
- 25:16their cancer and not treat it.
- 25:18And you're right,
- 25:19anxiety is a major component.
- 25:21Very understandably, I think we
- 25:23gain confidence with
- 25:24data in the genomic testing,
- 25:26we can more strongly tell our patients with
- 25:29security that they don't need treatment.
- 25:31They are not in danger from this cancer.
- 25:38Let's say there are some men though that
- 25:41do really want to have treatment.
- 25:44As a general rule,
- 25:45if they have very low risk
- 25:48and low risk prostate cancer,
- 25:50we do not treat them. Getting
- 25:52into an intermediate risk,
- 25:54some of those men actually
- 25:56don't need treatment either.
- 25:57Some intermediate risk men
- 25:59may benefit from treatment,
- 26:00and again we're using genomic
- 26:02testing to stratify that.
- 26:04An one of the main reasons that
- 26:06we are concerned and we try not to
- 26:10treat everyone with prostate cancer
- 26:12is that there are side effects so
- 26:14there can be an impact on urinary function.
- 26:17There can be an impact on sexual function
- 26:20with any treatment for prostate cancer,
- 26:22whether surgery or radiation
- 26:24or even ablation.
- 26:25So we're going to talk a little
- 26:27bit about that unless you had
- 26:29another question.
- 26:31I'd love to learn more about ablation,
- 26:33because it sounds like
- 26:36that might be a minimally invasive
- 26:38way to treat prostate cancer without
- 26:40having major surgery that can cause more
- 26:43side effects, so
- 26:48much of the discussion that we
- 26:51have in the urology community is,
- 26:53will ablation replace surgery,
- 26:54or radiation?
- 26:56I would say no, it is not a replacement for
- 26:58these gold standard treatments,
- 27:01but it is an alternative for the appropriate
- 27:04person and it is a good alternative.
- 27:06So ablation is typically using
- 27:08some form of energy beacon.
- 27:11Heat, or we can use cold, we can use other
- 27:14things like light or ultrasound
- 27:17or electricity to generate heat,
- 27:19but we're trying to destroy just the part
- 27:22of the prostate that has prostate cancer.
- 27:26By doing this,
- 27:27we can often avoid the structures
- 27:29and areas near the prostate that
- 27:32are associated with urinary
- 27:34control and sexual function,
- 27:36so we can have much less impact on
- 27:39someone's quality of life while having
- 27:42a successful treatment of their cancer.
- 27:46So do we know what
- 27:47the long term results of that are?
- 27:49I mean, do you get recurrence rates
- 27:51that are as low as you would get with
- 27:53surgery and radiation with ablation?
- 27:56It's interesting, there have
- 27:58been no randomized trials
- 28:00comparing surgery or radiation
- 28:01to an ablation, so
- 28:04all we can do is compare the sort
- 28:07of data from the different studies.
- 28:11The combination of treatment with
- 28:13ablation tends to be quite successful,
- 28:15though because
- 28:16we're held to a high standard,
- 28:19we are doing repeat biopsy's and many of
- 28:21these patients who are having an
- 28:24ablation or treatment of
- 28:25this part of their prostate,
- 28:27and we find very greater than
- 28:2980 or 90% success rate when we
- 28:31biopsy areas that were treated.
- 28:33The trick is that if we're treating
- 28:35only part of the prostate and
- 28:37this is why it's hard to compare
- 28:40to surgery or radiation.
- 28:41When we are treating just
- 28:43part of the prostate,
- 28:44there still is the other side of
- 28:46prostate or the rest of prostate that
- 28:48could develop cancer in the future.
- 28:50So you know,
- 28:51if we look at the areas that are ablated
- 28:54then yes, things like Cryo Ablation,
- 28:56irreversible electroporation,
- 28:57HIFU or high intensity focused ultrasound,
- 28:59those are very good techniques
- 29:00to destroy the cancer tissue
- 29:02in the area that is ablated
- 29:04but inherently it's not treating
- 29:06the other side of prostate so it
- 29:08is a little bit of a trade off.
- 29:10It's a little bit less treatment.
- 29:12Meaning we're not treating the
- 29:15whole prostate,
- 29:16but definitely associated
- 29:17with fewer side effects.
- 29:19So in terms of picking patients
- 29:22in whom this technique might be optimal,
- 29:26it seems to me that if you've
- 29:29got somebody who's really worried about
- 29:32the side effects of radical surgery,
- 29:35has a relatively small prostate cancer,
- 29:38and wants a less invasive
- 29:40technique and may not have
- 29:43long to really wait and get
- 29:45a new prostate cancer in another
- 29:47part of the prostate,
- 29:49that might be a
- 29:51good candidate.
- 29:52Yes, definitely.
- 29:53And this moves towards focal
- 29:56ablation so it is becoming more popular,
- 29:59especially in academic centers,
- 30:00and this has really grown out of
- 30:02the interest in it and the increased
- 30:04usage of these techniques has really grown
- 30:06out of the MRI in a targeted biopsy,
- 30:09because we now can localize prostate
- 30:11cancer within the prostate, which is new.
- 30:13It's new since MRI.
- 30:16We can know where to treat.
- 30:18So one of the reasons we don't
- 30:20have long term data is this is all
- 30:23relatively new technology that
- 30:24has really been born out of our
- 30:27ability to identify and localized
- 30:28prostate cancer with much more
- 30:30accuracy.
- 30:31Doctor Preston Sprenkle is an associate professor of urology
- 30:34at the Yale School of Medicine.
- 30:36If you have questions,
- 30:37the address is canceranswers@yale.edu
- 30:39and past editions of the program
- 30:41are available in audio and written
- 30:43form at Yalecancercenter.org.
- 30:44We hope you'll join us next week to
- 30:47learn more about the fight against
- 30:50cancer here on Connecticut public radio.