Advances in Colon and Rectal Surgery
December 06, 2021Information
December 5, 2021
Yale Cancer Center
visit: http://www.yalecancercenter.org
email: canceranswers@yale.edu
call: 203-785-4095
ID7241
To CiteDCA Citation Guide
- 00:00Funding for Yale Cancer Answers
- 00:03is provided by Smilow Cancer
- 00:06Hospital and AstraZeneca.
- 00:08Welcome to Yale Cancer
- 00:09Answers with your host
- 00:10Doctor Anees Chagpar.
- 00:13Yale Cancer Answers features the latest
- 00:14information on cancer care by
- 00:16welcoming oncologists and specialists
- 00:18who are on the forefront of the
- 00:20battle to fight cancer.
- 00:22This week, it's a conversation about colorectal cancer
- 00:24with Doctor Ira Leeds.
- 00:26Dr. Leeds is an assistant professor of
- 00:28surgery at the Yale School of Medicine,
- 00:30where Doctor Chapgar is a
- 00:32professor of surgical oncology.
- 00:34Ira, maybe we can start
- 00:36off by laying the groundwork.
- 00:38Tell us a little bit
- 00:40about colorectal cancer.
- 00:41How common is it?
- 00:42How lethal is it?
- 00:44How many people get it?
- 00:46I'd be happy to.
- 00:47Colorectal cancer is one of the most
- 00:49common cancers worldwide.
- 00:51It's the third most common cancer and
- 00:58concerningly,
- 00:59it's also the second most lethal cancer
- 01:01by number of total cancer deaths.
- 01:03The good news
- 01:04on the colon cancer side of
- 01:06things is that early detection
- 01:08has survival rates of over 90% whereas
- 01:12late detection has rates of 15%,
- 01:15so it really gives us
- 01:17an important urgency in the
- 01:19cancer care community to identify
- 01:21individuals with
- 01:23precancerous lesions early because the
- 01:25survival difference is significant.
- 01:27To put it in kind of very real terms,
- 01:341 in 20 individuals in their lifetimes
- 01:36will have colorectal cancer,
- 01:38and so it's something where all of
- 01:40us probably know someone or will
- 01:42know someone or been affected.
- 01:52And speaking of early detection,
- 01:56tell us a little bit more
- 01:57about the screening guidelines.
- 01:59I understand that those have
- 02:01changed recently so that younger
- 02:04people now are being recommended
- 02:06to get colorectal screening.
- 02:08Is that right?
- 02:10That's absolutely correct.
- 02:11The screening guidelines continue
- 02:13to evolve and have for many years.
- 02:15The age of 50 was the magical
- 02:18number where everyone should be
- 02:20lining up to get colonoscopies or
- 02:22alternatives to colonoscopies for
- 02:24their colorectal cancer screening.
- 02:26Many, if not almost all
- 02:29societies that provide guidelines
- 02:31on this topic have moved to 45 as
- 02:35the new age when people should start
- 02:37screening for colorectal cancer,
- 02:38that's for average risk individuals.
- 02:40So there's a number of individuals,
- 02:41both with more rare diseases that
- 02:44predispose themselves to colorectal cancer,
- 02:46but also a particularly high risk
- 02:48sociodemographic groups, for example,
- 02:50African Americans who have earlier
- 02:53screening guidelines as well.
- 02:55Interestingly,
- 02:55one of the other
- 02:56parts of the guidelines that's
- 02:59always a discussion point
- 03:00when guidelines come up is
- 03:02how do you screen?
- 03:03Colonoscopy has been the
- 03:05gold standard for decades.
- 03:07Colonoscopies require you to typically
- 03:08get a little bit of sedation,
- 03:11and it's a procedure where you have
- 03:12to take a bowel prep the night before,
- 03:14so it's certainly a bit of a burden
- 03:17on the average person to do so.
- 03:19There are alternatives to colonoscopies.
- 03:21There are a number of reasons
- 03:23why a colonoscopy is arguably
- 03:25better for people that
- 03:26are able to adhere to the schedule,
- 03:28but the guidelines do really try
- 03:29to balance the burden of screening
- 03:31along with the benefits of screening.
- 03:34Let's talk a little bit
- 03:36about a few things that you
- 03:38touched on.
- 03:40So the first point is that screening is now
- 03:43being recommended at 45 rather than 50.
- 03:46Is that because the demographics
- 03:48of colon cancer are trending
- 03:51towards younger populations?
- 03:57And who gets colon cancer in terms
- 03:59of the age demographic?
- 04:02So the trends in colorectal cancer are,
- 04:06at the very least, interesting, and
- 04:09potentially concerning in many ways.
- 04:11New onset of colon
- 04:14cancer is actually declining nationwide.
- 04:18The overall rate of colorectal cancer
- 04:20in the United States is declining and
- 04:22and also favorably the mortality rate
- 04:24from colorectal cancer is declining,
- 04:27and we attribute those overall
- 04:29trends to fairly good adherence to
- 04:32colonoscopy and colonoscopy
- 04:35alternative screening schedules
- 04:37in older individuals that are
- 04:38getting good colonoscopies and
- 04:40the adherence to that currently is
- 04:41about 60 to 70% of people that are
- 04:43supposed to be getting them on time.
- 04:45The risk of colorectal cancer
- 04:48occurring in those patients seems
- 04:50to be declining and we attribute
- 04:52that to better screening.
- 04:54The concerning part is that in young people,
- 04:56which is defined as
- 04:5820 to 49 years old,
- 05:00the rate of colorectal cancer is
- 05:03increasing and that is concerning
- 05:04not just because that's a patient
- 05:06population that historically has not
- 05:08been screened and one of the major reasons
- 05:11why the guidelines were changed to 45.
- 05:13But we also don't know why the rate of
- 05:16colorectal cancer incidence is occurring
- 05:18more frequently in that younger population.
- 05:21So for those of us that
- 05:23think about this every day,
- 05:24it's relatively easy to agree that
- 05:26the screening guidelines
- 05:28should be lowered to younger ages
- 05:30and 45 is where it is now and
- 05:33in a completely unofficial
- 05:36role I would not be surprised if
- 05:39those guidelines potentially got
- 05:40even earlier in future years,
- 05:42but we don't know at all why there
- 05:44is a higher rate of
- 05:47cancer in that population.
- 05:50The other thing that you mentioned was
- 05:53that these guidelines are for average
- 05:54risk people and that there are a number
- 05:57of things that increase a person's
- 05:59risk of developing colorectal cancer.
- 06:00So you mentioned certain demographic
- 06:02groups such as African Americans.
- 06:05I was wondering if you could talk a little
- 06:08bit more about some of the conditions,
- 06:10genetic conditions,
- 06:12other predisposing factors that
- 06:15increase a persons risk and whether
- 06:18those people should be screened
- 06:21earlier than the 45 year old guideline?
- 06:25When we think about a risk factor,
- 06:26as I always try to break them down
- 06:28into what I call non modifiable
- 06:30versus modifiable risk factors.
- 06:31So non modifiable risk factors or
- 06:34the risk factors that an individual
- 06:36has an increased risk based on
- 06:38compared to the average population.
- 06:39But at the same time there isn't a lot
- 06:41that could be done about that other
- 06:43than changing a screening schedule
- 06:45to suit that increased risk which is
- 06:47modifiable or things that we really
- 06:48spend a lot of time talking to patients
- 06:51about because those are risk factors
- 06:53that if certain behaviors are changed,
- 06:55may actually reduce their risk.
- 06:58Increasing age is probably the
- 07:00one that's most frequently cited
- 07:01as a nominal risk factor.
- 07:03We cannot get younger overtime and we
- 07:05need to recognize that as we get older,
- 07:07we do have an increased
- 07:09risk of colorectal cancer,
- 07:10which is why screening continues after
- 07:12that first episode of colonoscopy at
- 07:15the original age of 50 and now 45.
- 07:18Family history and personal history
- 07:20are both incredibly important.
- 07:23Almost all the screening guidelines have
- 07:25a carve out for patients who have
- 07:28early onset colon cancer in a family
- 07:30member and most of the guidelines
- 07:31say that an individual should start
- 07:34their own personal screening 10 years
- 07:37before the age of onset
- 07:39in a first degree relative.
- 07:42The thinking there being that
- 07:44there is this idea that is widely
- 07:47accepted that most colorectal cancer
- 07:50comes from polyps that form in the colon,
- 07:53which is from the natural turnover
- 07:55of the surface of the colon,
- 07:59and so those polyps,
- 08:00then overtime have more and
- 08:02more turnover of cells,
- 08:03and those cells get increasingly
- 08:06cancer like and as that occurs
- 08:08in anywhere between a five
- 08:10and 10 year progression cycle,
- 08:11you can have what was a non cancerous
- 08:14polyp turn into a cancer.
- 08:15So that's where this thought that if
- 08:17you start 10 years before a primary
- 08:19relative who had colon cancer,
- 08:21you should be able to identify that
- 08:23at the precancerous stage and address
- 08:26it by removal with colonoscopy.
- 08:28There is also a personal history if
- 08:30certain patients have been exposed
- 08:32to various environmental factors or
- 08:38cancer causing agents,
- 08:41that would be another reason to
- 08:42screen them earlier and then there
- 08:45are relatively rare diseases,
- 08:46particularly inherited syndromes
- 08:48like Lynch syndrome or
- 08:50Familial adenomatous polyposis.
- 08:52These are conditions where
- 08:56numerous family members
- 08:59who have already had colon
- 09:01cancer or related cancers,
- 09:03and because of that increased risk,
- 09:05there are very well early
- 09:07screening guidelines for those
- 09:09particular patient groups.
- 09:11Those diseases and inherited
- 09:13symptoms are relatively rare,
- 09:15and typically patients are getting
- 09:16passed on from family members saying,
- 09:20I started screening earlier than average
- 09:21because of this and you should too.
- 09:30Tell us about the modifiable risk factors.
- 09:33So modifiable risk factors are incredibly
- 09:35important because this is where our
- 09:37patients own agency has something they can
- 09:39do to reduce their risk moving forward.
- 09:42There are things that we oftentimes
- 09:43don't like to hear about when
- 09:45we are patients ourselves,
- 09:46because it does typically
- 09:48involve behavior change.
- 09:49But you know, I really tried to have
- 09:51patients wrap their heads around that.
- 09:54You can essentially
- 09:55eliminate your increased risk if you
- 09:58do these changes in behavior early
- 10:01enough on in the exposure cycle and
- 10:03the modifiable risk factors that
- 10:05we think about most are alcohol use,
- 10:08tobacco smoking,
- 10:09being overweight or obese.
- 10:12And then the more controversial area
- 10:16are the dietary changes that one
- 10:19can do in addition to simple weight
- 10:21loss that's related to obesity.
- 10:23So, for example,
- 10:24this evidence is still evolving.
- 10:25We don't know for sure,
- 10:26but things like high fiber diets,
- 10:29reducing complex artificial sugars,
- 10:31and so forth may have an improvement
- 10:34on one's risk factors for colon cancer.
- 10:39The other one that
- 10:41I would controversially put in
- 10:42the modifiable risk factor
- 10:43group is race.
- 10:46Obviously a patient can't change their race,
- 10:48but I think at the society level
- 10:49we have to ask if whether or not
- 10:51the fact that African Americans
- 10:53in particular have an incredibly
- 10:55higher rate of colorectal cancer
- 10:57than the average population,
- 10:58is that because of something
- 10:59genetic and the data suggests that
- 11:01that's probably not the case.
- 11:02The data suggests that the risk of
- 11:05increased colon cancer in certain
- 11:07races is likely due to socioeconomic
- 11:09factors and access issues to care,
- 11:12so I think as a society and
- 11:14also as a group of physicians,
- 11:17Health care providers,
- 11:17we need to think seriously how we're
- 11:20making sure that race is acknowledged
- 11:22in our care of patients because
- 11:23there are increased risks that we
- 11:26likely could modify with improved
- 11:27access to care and addressing both
- 11:29social terms of health as well
- 11:31as biomedical risk factors.
- 11:34A couple of pointed questions.
- 11:36I guess the first is in terms of gender.
- 11:39Is there a difference
- 11:41in colorectal incidence?
- 11:44The relationship to gender and
- 11:46colorectal cancer has more to do with
- 11:48where the cancers occur in the colon,
- 11:51and this is a complex issue that we can
- 11:53probably come back to if we have time.
- 11:54But colorectal cancer occurs
- 11:56in three general places.
- 11:59The right side of the colon,
- 12:00the left side of the colon,
- 12:01and the rectum.
- 12:03These are very different areas
- 12:05in terms of how they are handled
- 12:07from a suregons standpoint,
- 12:08which is why it's really relevant and
- 12:11to go to your direct question,
- 12:14the gender differences between the
- 12:16various anatomic sites varies as well.
- 12:19We don't really understand why and
- 12:21it's an area of open investigation,
- 12:23but it does seem to color
- 12:25where these cancers occur,
- 12:27and therefore genders seem to have
- 12:29differences in treatment strategies
- 12:31because of where the sites of disease.
- 12:35So women have more colon cancers
- 12:37on one side of the colon than men?
- 12:40Correct, the right side.
- 12:42Interesting, and my second question,
- 12:44what about inflammatory bowel disease?
- 12:47Does that increase your
- 12:49risk of colorectal cancer?
- 12:50And if so, are we seeing more
- 12:54inflammatory bowel disease in
- 12:56younger people which might give
- 12:58us a clue as to one potential
- 13:01etiologic factor for younger onset?
- 13:05So, inflammatory bowel disease
- 13:07absolutely increases your risk.
- 13:10The screening guidelines for both
- 13:12patients with Crohn's disease and
- 13:15colitis specifically target those
- 13:18groups for early onset colonoscopies,
- 13:21partially to evaluate their
- 13:23inflammatory bowel disease,
- 13:24but also to evaluate for the early
- 13:27development of colorectal cancer.
- 13:30We talk a lot in that
- 13:32population about dysplasia.
- 13:33Dysplasia is what cells
- 13:34look like under a microscope when they're
- 13:37headed towards potentially being a cancer,
- 13:39and so those patients get routine regular
- 13:43biopsies to evaluate for dysplasia as
- 13:45a sign that that would be the case,
- 13:48and in that patient population the
- 13:50recommendations in terms of what
- 13:52you do with that are changing,
- 13:53but the historical recommendations
- 13:55have been to move towards early
- 13:57surgical intervention to remove
- 13:59diseased portions of the colon because
- 14:02of their increased cancer risk.
- 14:04You bring up an interesting point
- 14:06about inflammatory bowel disease
- 14:08incidence and early onset of colon cancers,
- 14:11and I think I would capture that
- 14:13more broadly,
- 14:14what one of the leading theories
- 14:16around why we have increased colorectal
- 14:19cancer in younger populations is
- 14:21the inflammatory burden that the
- 14:23colon is seeing younger in life.
- 14:25And there's a lot of reasons
- 14:26why that may be the case.
- 14:27The question has been raised,
- 14:29is it a matter of psychosocial
- 14:31stress and modern society?
- 14:33Is it a matter of
- 14:34the artificial sugar
- 14:37ingredients that are in food.
- 14:38Do they have
- 14:41an established higher
- 14:43inflammatory load that's seen by the
- 14:45body and is that somehow creating
- 14:47more inflammation in the colon?
- 14:49More inflammation begets this
- 14:50dysplasia that we talked about
- 14:52and does that lead to cancer?
- 14:53These theories are out there,
- 14:56they're often discussed and they
- 14:58have good biology that supports them.
- 15:01We just haven't made the missing
- 15:03link connection to the clinical evidence.
- 15:08Well, we're going to pick up the
- 15:10conversation right after we take a
- 15:12short break for a medical minute.
- 15:13Please stay tuned to learn more
- 15:15about the surgical care of colorectal
- 15:17cancer with my guest doctor
- 15:19Ira Leeds.
- 15:21Funding for Yale Cancer Answers comes
- 15:23from Smilow Cancer Hospital,
- 15:24where integrative medicine services
- 15:26help patients navigate physical,
- 15:28mental, and spiritual Wellness
- 15:30during and after cancer therapy.
- 15:32To learn more, visit
- 15:36yalecancercenter.org/integrative.
- 15:38The American Cancer Society
- 15:40estimates that more than 65,000
- 15:42Americans will be diagnosed with
- 15:44head and neck cancer this year,
- 15:46making up about 4% of all cancers
- 15:50diagnosed when detected early.
- 15:51However, head and neck cancers are
- 15:54easily treated and highly curable.
- 15:56Clinical trials are currently
- 15:58underway at federally designated
- 16:00Comprehensive cancer centers such
- 16:02as Yale Cancer Center and at Smilow
- 16:04Cancer Hospital to test innovative new
- 16:06treatments for head and neck cancers.
- 16:08Yale Cancer Center was recently awarded
- 16:11grants from the National Institutes
- 16:13of Health to fund the Yale Head
- 16:16and neck Cancer Specialized program
- 16:18of Research Excellence or SPORE to
- 16:21address critical barriers to treatment
- 16:23of head and neck squamous cell
- 16:26carcinoma due to resistance to immune
- 16:28DNA damaging and targeted therapy.
- 16:30More information is available at
- 16:33yalecancercenter.org you're listening
- 16:35to Connecticut Public Radio.
- 16:38Welcome back to Yale Cancer answers.
- 16:40This is doctor Anis Jaguar and I'm
- 16:42joined tonight by my guest Doctor Ira
- 16:44leads we're learning about the surgical
- 16:47care of patients with colorectal cancer.
- 16:49And before the break IRA we spent
- 16:52a lot of time talking about kind
- 16:55of what causes colon cancer,
- 16:57or at least what are some of the
- 17:00risk factors and what are the
- 17:02factors that lead to colon cancer,
- 17:04particularly occurring at
- 17:05a younger age so that.
- 17:08Guidelines have now changed
- 17:10to get colonoscopies earlier.
- 17:13One thing I want to talk about just
- 17:15before we get into the management
- 17:17of colorectal cancer is the type
- 17:19of screening you mentioned.
- 17:21This briefly before the break in terms
- 17:24of colonoscopy versus alternatives.
- 17:27It can you flesh that out a little
- 17:30bit for us so clearly nobody is,
- 17:32you know, chomping at the bit saying oh,
- 17:34sign me up I'd love to get a prep and
- 17:37have a tube put up my rear bottom end
- 17:40so that you can look at my colon,
- 17:42but we know that colonoscopy is a
- 17:45great test to find colorectal cancer
- 17:48early and allows one to actually
- 17:51remove potentially precancerous polyps.
- 17:54But if you're not terribly enthused
- 17:57about having a colonoscopy,
- 17:59how good are the alternatives and
- 18:01D recommend them?
- 18:03That's a loaded question
- 18:04when it's all said and done,
- 18:06but we'll try to break it up
- 18:08here into bite sized pieces.
- 18:10So I think to go to colonoscopy first, the.
- 18:13The two biggest values to colonoscopy
- 18:16for me are the following.
- 18:19The first is that colonoscopy has
- 18:21been shown to be able identify
- 18:23lesions typically earlier than a
- 18:25lot of the alternatives out there,
- 18:28and the reason being is that
- 18:30colonoscopy can dentify both truly
- 18:32benign what so non cancerous lesions
- 18:34it can identify precancerous lesions,
- 18:37and it can identify cancer and
- 18:39why that's valuable is that.
- 18:41It by getting your regular screening,
- 18:44colonoscopy.
- 18:44It kind of gives a time lapse image
- 18:47of what's happening in your colon,
- 18:49which I think is valuable.
- 18:51If something were to ever develop,
- 18:52kind of what somebody saw before.
- 18:55The second reason why colonoscopy is
- 18:56so valuable is that you're in there.
- 18:58You can already do what you need to do,
- 19:01oftentimes for these precancerous lesions,
- 19:04with almost every other screening test,
- 19:06it's going to basically stratify
- 19:08a patient to a low risk,
- 19:10meaning there was nothing detected
- 19:11on the tests or high risk group,
- 19:13which means that the test was abnormal,
- 19:15and therefore the patient needs
- 19:17a colonoscopy.
- 19:18So a lot of these,
- 19:19even the best non colonoscopy
- 19:23screening modalities are still routing.
- 19:25Folks,
- 19:25two colonoscopy when they have
- 19:27an abnormal test.
- 19:29So there is a little bit of this
- 19:30question of you know if there's
- 19:31so much that can be gleaned from
- 19:33a colonoscopy to begin with,
- 19:34should we putting everyone through
- 19:36the colonoscopy round and then,
- 19:37as I mentioned before,
- 19:38the the biggest argument against that,
- 19:40is that colonoscopy for some
- 19:41folks is has an undue burden,
- 19:44both in terms of pleasantness but also
- 19:46in terms of work loss and so forth.
- 19:48So if you can do,
- 19:49for example a stool test that
- 19:51you can do in your home at 1
- 19:54evening when you've got the time.
- 19:55To do it and send it off for analysis,
- 19:57and that if it's negative then you're done.
- 19:59You have no further burden on
- 20:00your day to day life to get your
- 20:02results you need to go back to
- 20:04being an average risk individual
- 20:06with no further colonoscopy needs.
- 20:08So I think we're the both the the.
- 20:13The clearance for these tests.
- 20:15In other words,
- 20:15what they're allowed to proclaim to be,
- 20:17and also where they really do,
- 20:18have a sweet spot as the average
- 20:21risk individual who's never had
- 20:22any abnormal findings on a prior
- 20:24colonoscopy and does not have
- 20:26the high risk family features
- 20:27that we talked about before those
- 20:30individuals if interested in
- 20:32pursuing a non invasive test like
- 20:35a colonoscopy have been shown to
- 20:38have equal benefit from one of the
- 20:40more advanced tests out there.
- 20:42It's basically a test that you
- 20:44give a stool sample and it uses a
- 20:47variety of assays or laboratory
- 20:49tests on that sample to look for both
- 20:51cancerous DNA in the stool as well as
- 20:54a signature of what a bleeding
- 20:56lesion in your colon might be like,
- 20:58which is one of the micro bleed
- 21:00is one of the hallmarks for pre
- 21:02cancer or early cancer in the colon,
- 21:05so that's what it's detecting and it's been
- 21:07shown to have a very good detection rate.
- 21:10And so if that's normal,
- 21:12then we can confidently say that
- 21:14patient does not need a colonoscopy if
- 21:16they have no other high risk features,
- 21:18there are a number of different options
- 21:19that are listed in the guidelines,
- 21:21but those two are probably the
- 21:23most common recommended today.
- 21:24The biggest drawback to the stool test that
- 21:27I mentioned is that it is quite expensive.
- 21:30Depending on insurance
- 21:31reimbursements and so forth,
- 21:33so it's not the biggest.
- 21:36The biggest benefit to it is
- 21:37the is the burden of going to
- 21:39get a colonoscopy more so than.
- 21:41Anything else in regards to
- 21:42resource use for it?
- 21:45Cool, so let's suppose you
- 21:47went for your colonoscopy,
- 21:49and a lesion was found.
- 21:52A polyp was found and biopsied and
- 21:54it turns out that it is a cancer.
- 21:57Can you help us to understand a
- 21:59little bit more about how you know
- 22:01whether this is kind of a good
- 22:03cancer where your colonoscopy
- 22:04has has gotten it and you don't
- 22:07need anything further versus a
- 22:08not so good cancer where there
- 22:10might actually be a need for you
- 22:13to see a colorectal surgeon and?
- 22:15Have more therapy done
- 22:17so there's a couple key things that
- 22:18you need to know when you as a
- 22:21surgeon when you're getting given a
- 22:23biopsy report from a colonoscopy.
- 22:24The things that we think about
- 22:26the most are for a true cancer is
- 22:30something called TNM staging or
- 22:32tumor nodes and metastasis staging.
- 22:34The tea or the tumor is what
- 22:36is happening at the microscopic
- 22:38level in terms of local invasion.
- 22:40Where is the thing that was biopsied?
- 22:42Where is it going?
- 22:43Is it in just the very first flute fuels
- 22:46level layers of cells of the colon?
- 22:49Is it invading through the colon?
- 22:50Is invading into other structures in
- 22:53as nodes or there are nodes lymph
- 22:55nodes that are basically the first
- 22:57sign that a colon cancer has been
- 23:00getting to spread beyond the original
- 23:02tumor and then finally, is Amar metastases?
- 23:05That means they're spread of the
- 23:07cancer beyond the colon,
- 23:08intestine into other organs.
- 23:10The body,
- 23:10most commonly the liver or the lungs.
- 23:13So four colon cancer that's been diagnosis.
- 23:15Colon cancer.
- 23:16On colonoscopy it is important to
- 23:18get a complete scan of the body of
- 23:21particularly of the chest and the
- 23:23abdomen to make sure that you don't
- 23:26have any far ranging metastases
- 23:28or or tumor spread.
- 23:30The second issue that is
- 23:32where does it look locally?
- 23:34And that's where sometimes
- 23:35the biopsy alone can do that.
- 23:37If the biopsy comes back as cancer
- 23:40and the entire polyp was not
- 23:42removed with that biopsy,
- 23:43then that's kind of the first step
- 23:45that someone needs to go back and see
- 23:47if that can be removed into Scopic Lee.
- 23:49Sometimes it's very obvious from the
- 23:51original colonoscopic exam that it's
- 23:53not going to be removed locally,
- 23:55but if it's on a stock,
- 23:56if it's kind of dangling into the colon,
- 23:58sometimes those are at a very
- 24:00good candidates for local removal
- 24:02with Columbus scope.
- 24:03If that's done and on the micro,
- 24:05the microscopic evaluation of that specimen,
- 24:08you can say clearly that here's
- 24:10the cut edge of where we took this
- 24:12tumor off this polyp off and there
- 24:14is no cancer at that.
- 24:16And then we looked at the individual
- 24:18cancer cells in the bulk of the
- 24:20polyp and we can see that they have
- 24:22certain features that are favorable
- 24:24then that may be all that patient needs.
- 24:27On the flip side,
- 24:28if there is tumor invasion,
- 24:29if there's high concerning features
- 24:31of the polyp in terms of what it
- 24:33looks like under the microscope,
- 24:34then that's something we're a segment of.
- 24:36The colon needs to be removed,
- 24:38and that would require a typically,
- 24:41and in 2021 it would typically
- 24:43require mentally invasive surgery
- 24:44to remove a segment of the colon and
- 24:46the nodal bundle that's attached to it.
- 24:48To get that end staging for very
- 24:51early tumors,
- 24:52the risk of an end spread meaning
- 24:54a nodal spread is so low that for
- 24:56those very early tumors that we
- 24:58just took off. Instead, we're done.
- 24:59Those don't need that nodal bundle,
- 25:01which is where that justification comes from.
- 25:03So Speaking of burden,
- 25:05if you had a very small cancer
- 25:08such that it was just in a polyp,
- 25:11do those patients still need the
- 25:13scans of their chest in their abdomen
- 25:15to look for distant metastases?
- 25:17One would think that if
- 25:18the nodal burden is low,
- 25:20then the distant metastases
- 25:21burden should also be very low.
- 25:24I think it's certainly consideration
- 25:25this is one of those particularly
- 25:27controversial points and staging
- 25:29guidelines that has is up for discussion,
- 25:32and I think shared decision
- 25:33making does come into it.
- 25:34This is something that either that a
- 25:36colorectal surgeon should probably involve
- 25:38with to talk to the patient about one on one,
- 25:40because there are very small risks up
- 25:44spread and that needs to be discussed.
- 25:48With the patient eventually,
- 25:49because those guidelines are in flux,
- 25:51and then if I can go back for one second,
- 25:53I think you know we we talked a lot about
- 25:55the kind of you see a polyp in the colon,
- 25:57just to kind of clarify,
- 25:58one of the tricky parts about the
- 26:00anatomic specificity that we mentioned
- 26:02earlier was that colon cancer can
- 26:04be dealt with and more with less
- 26:06the way that we just discussed.
- 26:07Whereas rectal cancer is a different bird,
- 26:09rectal cancer does make up about
- 26:1130% of all colorectal cancer,
- 26:13and the decision making around how
- 26:16to address those tumors does differ.
- 26:19OK, tell us more about that.
- 26:20How does it differ?
- 26:22So the interesting thing with
- 26:23rectal cancer is biologically,
- 26:24it's very similar to colon cancer.
- 26:26It looks very the same under the
- 26:27microscope and it's the same
- 26:29kind of cell story that created
- 26:30those cancers in the first place,
- 26:31where rectal cancer does differ
- 26:33is that it's anatomically fixed,
- 26:35meaning the ****** is fixed in the pelvis,
- 26:37whereas the colon flops around.
- 26:39It's an incredibly powerful difference
- 26:42that becomes more so every day
- 26:44because we realize that we have more
- 26:47modalities or options for therapy
- 26:48that we can use for rectal cancer
- 26:50because of its anatomically fixed.
- 26:52Position what this means in 2021 is
- 26:55that many many rectal cancers need
- 26:58chemotherapy and radiation upfront,
- 27:00which is entirely different.
- 27:01Colon cancer, which if anything,
- 27:03only gets those options for therapy
- 27:05after the original tumor is removed.
- 27:08Rectal cancer has been shown that it
- 27:10seems to do better if we give those
- 27:12modalities up front and then follow
- 27:14with surgery after considerable
- 27:15lead in period of often times,
- 27:17three to six months of chemo
- 27:19radiation therapy.
- 27:21This brings up an interesting point.
- 27:23Oftentimes, here on the show we we
- 27:26talk about multidisciplinary care and
- 27:28we talk about personalized therapy.
- 27:31So how do you decide which
- 27:33patients need chemotherapy?
- 27:35Which patients need radiation?
- 27:36Which patients do well with surgery alone?
- 27:40It the multidisciplinary point
- 27:42that you mentioned is critical.
- 27:44It's getting increasingly complicated,
- 27:46particularly with advanced disease.
- 27:48It's very hard to make these decisions
- 27:50without a colorectal surgeon,
- 27:52medical oncologists and a number
- 27:54of others supporting positions
- 27:56from radiology pathology.
- 27:58Interventional radiology all
- 27:59getting together to talk about
- 28:02what's the best course of action?
- 28:04There are a couple sort of
- 28:06easier points to make here.
- 28:07I think that for colon cancer that's
- 28:10early stage in the colon and not the
- 28:13****** that's typically a surgery
- 28:15first approach in most cases for things
- 28:18that are in that for rectal cancer
- 28:20as well as advanced colon cancer,
- 28:23it really does require everyone in the room
- 28:25to have that conversation about a patient.
- 28:28Ultimately,
- 28:28with the patient to see what's
- 28:31the best first line approach.
- 28:33Doctor Ira leads is an assistant professor
- 28:35of surgery at the Yale School of Medicine.
- 28:38If you have questions,
- 28:39the address is cancer.
- 28:40Answers at yale.edu and past editions of
- 28:43the program are available in audio and
- 28:46written form at yalecancercenter.org.
- 28:48We hope you'll join us next week to
- 28:50learn more about the fight against
- 28:52cancer here on Connecticut Public
- 28:54radio funding for Yale Cancer
- 28:55Answers is provided by Smilow
- 28:57Cancer Hospital and Astra Zeneca.