Child Study Center Grand Rounds 09.21.2021
October 29, 2021Prenatal Maternal Depression and Antidepressant Exposure - Neurodevelopmental Trajectories
Information
- ID
- 7100
- To Cite
- DCA Citation Guide
Transcript
- 02:24Hey Jonathan, can you hear us? Let
- 02:28me introduce you to two
- 02:29people you've never seen.
- 02:30One is Doctor Jayme Mcpartland.
- 02:32Dr Taking what do you want to
- 02:33start talking with our speaker?
- 02:34We haven't let people into the room yet.
- 02:39Hey Jonathan, do you want to have a really
- 02:41publicly broadcast ketchup session?
- 02:45Sounds great. Good, you know.
- 02:50I had to admit I didn't notice
- 02:52telling your side just now.
- 02:53By the way, Jamie, Jamie eye contact.
- 02:57Yeah, that's correct.
- 02:58I didn't notice it.
- 02:59Said Duke University is that yeah.
- 03:02I mean he he doesn't know in autism.
- 03:04We don't make eye contact.
- 03:06Normally developing people would make typing.
- 03:08Yeah, I know,
- 03:09but as an autism eye contact specialist,
- 03:11we've ruled that eye contact being
- 03:13meaningful during zoom settings.
- 03:15So it's like saying I mean,
- 03:16in fact I can communicate
- 03:18effectively like this.
- 03:19And then when it's time,
- 03:20so when did you make the move?
- 03:23September 1st, so
- 03:24it's brand new. Congratulations
- 03:26very exciting. Are you physically there? Yeah
- 03:29yeah yeah I came down with my
- 03:31family over the summer so we could
- 03:33get our kids set up at school.
- 03:36Yeah yeah thanks yeah.
- 03:38And I'm I'm really excited about being here.
- 03:39It's been really great so far
- 03:41that is is really yeah I
- 03:43want to hear all about it.
- 03:44Yeah for sure not broadcasting
- 03:46to the entire Child Study Center,
- 03:49right? How are your kids doing?
- 03:52I'm good that great school is in person.
- 03:56They're happy, started high school in,
- 03:58started high school this year.
- 03:59So so far, so good. Now you did you.
- 04:02Are you still on CPD? Yes I am I
- 04:05I'm done. I
- 04:06know you graduated. You will be.
- 04:08You will be greatly missed.
- 04:12I will enjoy the break but
- 04:13I will miss it too, yeah.
- 04:16Oh, you're you finished up.
- 04:20You were you were on the Zoom study
- 04:22section for one or two sessions.
- 04:24Is that right? Yeah, yeah.
- 04:26For the time being, we're continuing on
- 04:28zoom, which is, I find, a bit painful.
- 04:31It is it makes for a very long day.
- 04:33Yeah, yeah, I thought you're gonna
- 04:36say my timing was good because they
- 04:37did away with continuous submission.
- 04:39So I actually meant to thread
- 04:40the needle in terms of period
- 04:42of time for continuous submission.
- 04:46I I didn't know that they got
- 04:47rid of continuous emission.
- 04:48If I if I'm not mistaken,
- 04:50I thought they changed the policy.
- 04:53OK, I didn't really thought. But
- 04:55now I'm going to inquire about some protocol.
- 04:58So what Andres, what's the what's
- 04:59the is when we want to start?
- 05:14Where's your schooling?
- 05:47Kids.
- 05:54The people.
- 05:57They can only hear it.
- 06:04Sure.
- 06:06Remember the test. Unless.
- 06:22OK, silly.
- 06:25Epic.
- 06:28And I can see your cat.
- 06:31Do you want me to start letting people in?
- 06:36While he's talking just because,
- 06:38well, who is wow? Yeah,
- 06:43just because critics are perfect
- 06:45is over there with translating,
- 06:47but right now we're going
- 06:48to start with it. Yes, OK?
- 06:54Yeah, it's.
- 07:05Very sophisticated plan for managing
- 07:07your question and answer session.
- 07:09I promised that I will screw it
- 07:11up and so I apologize in advance.
- 07:15Make room for Kyle.
- 07:19Sharp
- 07:22so did people type their questions
- 07:24into the chat function today?
- 07:26They will get to ask and they will
- 07:29be able to ask in person. Yeah.
- 07:40That's.
- 07:44Rights. Oh, because I asked.
- 08:02Introduction.
- 08:22Yes.
- 08:35I think we're good. Well,
- 08:37everyone. Welcome to today's grand rounds.
- 08:41My name is Mike Crowley.
- 08:42I'm a member of our Grand rounds committee.
- 08:44Last week we heard from Carol,
- 08:46I just want to remind everyone
- 08:48before I introduce Dr.
- 08:50Mcpartland that I that we have
- 08:52compassionate care grand rounds next
- 08:53week and the title of that grand
- 08:55rounds is refractory providers and
- 08:57systems come together to care for a
- 08:59severely depressed and suicidal youth.
- 09:01So out further ado.
- 09:02Doctor mcpartlin.
- 09:08Hey welcome everyone.
- 09:09Today it's my pleasure to introduce Doctor.
- 09:13Jonathan Posner is a child and
- 09:16adolescent psychiatrist and
- 09:17vice chair for research in the
- 09:19Department of Psychiatry at Duke,
- 09:20which is news hot off the
- 09:23presses as of September 1st.
- 09:25He directs pediatric brain imaging
- 09:28laboratory that has maintained
- 09:29consistent NIH funding since
- 09:31founding over ten years ago.
- 09:32His research focuses on neuro
- 09:34development with an emphasis on
- 09:35imaging approaches to studying
- 09:37neurobiological correlates of mental.
- 09:39Illness and cognitive development
- 09:42is Pi on 312 N family based
- 09:45studies aimed at understanding
- 09:46the influence of family history.
- 09:48Psychosocial adversity in prenatal
- 09:49exposures on the development of neural
- 09:51circuits involved in executive functions.
- 09:53In emotion regulation.
- 09:55You know, having reviewed the CD,
- 09:56he's a piece of many,
- 09:58many more grants than that he's an
- 10:00extremely productive researcher.
- 10:01His work has been published in leading
- 10:03journals including JAMA Psychiatry,
- 10:05John Pediatrics, Pediatrics,
- 10:06Lance Psychiatry in The Lancet.
- 10:08He's a.
- 10:09A very engaged mentor and educator and has
- 10:12served mentor to many new junior faculty,
- 10:14postdocs,
- 10:15and psychic residents who've done well.
- 10:19Came to know,
- 10:19gentlemen,
- 10:20through our mutual serving on
- 10:22a study section,
- 10:23childhood safe theology and
- 10:25developmental disorders,
- 10:26and one of the things that I
- 10:28recognized by Jonathan isn't in
- 10:30addition to having deep technical
- 10:32knowledge of his methods.
- 10:33He also has very strong clinical
- 10:36sense and is extremely thoughtful.
- 10:38And so I'm really looking forward to
- 10:39hearing what he has to say because
- 10:41I I think it's gonna actually
- 10:42even be more rewarding with his
- 10:45comments during study section.
- 10:46If you can believe it or not,
- 10:47and he's going to be talking about.
- 10:49Kind of depression and
- 10:50antidepressant exposure,
- 10:51and how that influences
- 10:53neurodevelopmental trajectories.
- 10:54Thank you so much,
- 10:55Jonathan.
- 10:57Thank you so much Jamie. UM,
- 10:59really appreciate that introduction.
- 11:02And I just wanted to mention that it's a.
- 11:04It's such an honor to be
- 11:06presenting to you all as a child,
- 11:08not a lesson psychiatrist I I never did any
- 11:11of my own training at at Yale Child study,
- 11:15but so many of the the mentors
- 11:17who taught me so much about child
- 11:19psychiatry all grew up at Yale,
- 11:21so the Child Study Center is
- 11:23always loom very large in my mind,
- 11:25so the real treat to be
- 11:27presenting to you all today.
- 11:29Uhm, so I'm going to be talking
- 11:32today about the safety of
- 11:36antidepressant use during pregnancy.
- 11:39And specifically the use
- 11:41of SSRI antidepressants.
- 11:43Uhm, and this is a topic that I
- 11:45I really find quite interesting
- 11:48because on the one hand it's it's
- 11:51a question that we want very,
- 11:52very badly to know the answer to.
- 11:54We want to know whether we can
- 11:57safely prescribe these medications.
- 11:58And yet we are somewhat hamstrung in
- 12:00how we how we approach this question,
- 12:03because the most rigorous methodology
- 12:05that we would have to answer this would
- 12:09be a randomized clinical trial and for both.
- 12:13Uh,
- 12:13and pragmatic regions.
- 12:15It would be very,
- 12:16very difficult to to use that methodology,
- 12:19so we're left in this situation
- 12:21where we want a definitive answer.
- 12:23And yet our our approach is somewhat limited.
- 12:26I'm going to be talking to you today
- 12:28about how we're trying to tackle this
- 12:30problem in lieu of those limitations.
- 12:36Uh, so some some disclosures to mention.
- 12:39So I have received research support
- 12:42from Shire which is now part of the
- 12:45Cada Avino mix and Innovation sciences.
- 12:48But none of that research support
- 12:51was related to the data that I'm
- 12:53gonna be presenting to you all today.
- 12:56Uhm, so uh before getting started,
- 12:59uhm, I first wanted to discuss two
- 13:04foundational concepts that really guide my.
- 13:08And the first is the
- 13:11centrality of development,
- 13:13and I was essentially axiomatic that most,
- 13:17if not all mental illness.
- 13:21Has it had development to origins
- 13:23or or to put that another way
- 13:27that I think if we really want to
- 13:29understand the etiology of psych.
- 13:32We have to understand development,
- 13:34but development is of course difficult.
- 13:38Not only now are we are we trying
- 13:41to understand this incredibly
- 13:43complex organ in the human brain,
- 13:46but when we take a developmental perspective,
- 13:49we're now chasing after a moving target.
- 13:52As the brand grows and matures.
- 13:57The second principle that guides
- 13:59my work is the importance of.
- 14:01It's all of our approaches to
- 14:03understanding the brain and
- 14:05mental illness have limitations.
- 14:08Whether it be preclinical models for example.
- 14:17Relation based research
- 14:18epidemiology that have.
- 14:23Clinical samples may have
- 14:26limited generalizability.
- 14:27But when translational science
- 14:28is really working at its best,
- 14:31we're able to triangulate across
- 14:34these domains, and that's when I
- 14:36think we can really make progress,
- 14:38and my hope is that.
- 14:40By the end of this talk,
- 14:42I've convinced you.
- 14:45That the story of prenatal SSRI
- 14:47exposure is 1 where this trend?
- 14:55By giving you some background on depression
- 14:58during pregnancy to provide some context
- 15:01for why antidepressant use during
- 15:03pregnancy is such an important topic.
- 15:06So to begin, UM, depression
- 15:09during pregnancy common,
- 15:10it's estimated that anywhere from
- 15:1310 to 20% of women will experience
- 15:16depression during pregnancy,
- 15:18and then there are a host of associated
- 15:21risks that go along with that.
- 15:23So, first and foremost is the
- 15:25depressed and anxious mood.
- 15:27But the suffering of the depression
- 15:29experience by the by the individual.
- 15:32But then there are a host of
- 15:35other potential complications.
- 15:36So one is that, UM,
- 15:38prenatal depression is associated
- 15:40with worse prenatal care,
- 15:42poor nutrition.
- 15:44An increased risk for substance
- 15:46abuse and suicide.
- 15:48There's also concerns about premature
- 15:50delivery and low birth weight.
- 15:53A another growing concern is that
- 15:56prenatal depression may increase
- 15:58stress hormones and have trickle down
- 16:01effects on the fetus by altering
- 16:05the intrauterine environment.
- 16:07And then last but certainly not least,
- 16:09is that prenatal depression is really
- 16:11a set up for postpartum depression,
- 16:13which can have negative effects on
- 16:16the parent infant interaction with
- 16:19downstream effects on neural development.
- 16:24So if a pregnant woman develops
- 16:27depression and discuss his
- 16:28treatment with her doctor,
- 16:30it's really important to keep
- 16:32in mind that this decision,
- 16:34the treatment decision,
- 16:35is really a balancing act.
- 16:37The the physician and the pregnant
- 16:39woman are trying on the one hand
- 16:42to weigh the negative effects of
- 16:44the depression while at the same
- 16:47time considering potential risks of
- 16:49prenatal antidepressant exposure.
- 16:50And when I say enter the present.
- 16:52Oh sure, I'm referring primarily
- 16:54to SSRI exposure,
- 16:55and I'll show you later that's the
- 16:59primary medication class that's used.
- 17:01Uhm, and the SSRI.
- 17:03Exposure to the fetus really is not trivial.
- 17:06These medications readily
- 17:08pass through the placenta,
- 17:10and it's estimated that their levels in
- 17:13fetal circulation are anywhere from 70
- 17:15to 80% of that of the maternal levels.
- 17:20Safety concerns have come up over the
- 17:24years with a variety of FDA warnings.
- 17:28But most of these concerns
- 17:30have been put to rest,
- 17:32or at least these concerns have
- 17:34seemed far less significant than
- 17:36the risk of untreated depression.
- 17:40And as these safety concerns have subsided,
- 17:43prenatal SSRI use in EU.
- 17:45S has steadily increased.
- 17:47So what I'm showing here is the
- 17:50percentage of pregnant women taking
- 17:52an antidepressant in EU. S. Overtime.
- 17:55Then you can see this steady increase.
- 17:57The top line here.
- 17:59Is any antidepressant and the
- 18:01next line down is of those.
- 18:03The percentage of SSR eyes and
- 18:05so you can see that the Lions
- 18:07sharing enter depressant prescribed
- 18:09during pregnancy are indeed.
- 18:11SSRI, enter the presence.
- 18:14And so we're now at a point where
- 18:17SSR eyes are used by anywhere from 4
- 18:21to 8% of pregnant women in the US,
- 18:24and that translates to anywhere from
- 18:26160 to 320,000 babies born each year.
- 18:31In EU.
- 18:32S who have been prenatally exposed to SSRI's.
- 18:39So now that I've I've given you
- 18:41some of the clinical context
- 18:43regarding SSRI use during pregnancy,
- 18:46I want to shift to the second part
- 18:48of my talk where we move from the
- 18:51clinical setting to the bench or
- 18:53do basic neuroscience research and
- 18:56starting in the early 2000s Neuro
- 18:59Neuro scientists started trying to
- 19:02use preclinical models to understand
- 19:05how SSR eyes are effective.
- 19:08And at the most proxamol level,
- 19:11we have a pretty good sense of how they work,
- 19:14so you have your presynaptic and
- 19:17postsynaptic neurons and SSRI's
- 19:19block the transporter that reabsorb
- 19:21serotonin from the synaptic cleft
- 19:23from the synaptic cleft.
- 19:27So one approach that was used
- 19:30early on to try to understand how
- 19:33SSRI's work was the transporter,
- 19:36knockout mouse and the idea here.
- 19:39And this was work done in
- 19:41large part by J Gingrich.
- 19:43The idea here was that it's
- 19:46SSRI lock the transporter,
- 19:48then simply removing the transporter
- 19:51should mimic those SSRI effects and
- 19:54essentially creating a highly resilient
- 19:56mouse or or a type of mighty mouse.
- 20:01And what's quite interesting is that
- 20:03that's not at all what was found.
- 20:06Uhm, instead of a less anxious mouse,
- 20:09the knockout mouse actually displays more
- 20:13anxious like behavior and an example of
- 20:16that is using the latency to feed paradigm.
- 20:20So what you see here is a mouse in
- 20:23a cage with a tasty food pellet
- 20:25in the middle of the cage,
- 20:27and the investigators measure
- 20:28how long it takes for the mouse.
- 20:31To get up the courage to go into the
- 20:33middle of the cage and and eat the
- 20:35treat and so first you see the latency
- 20:38to feed in the the wild type mouse.
- 20:41Uhm and then come with a mouse have been
- 20:44pretreated with the necessary you see,
- 20:46a decrease in the latency to feed.
- 20:48So in other words the mouse gets up the
- 20:51courage sooner and it goes into the
- 20:53middle of the cage and eats the pellet.
- 20:55Uhm, but with the knockout mouse you
- 20:58actually see this increased latency.
- 21:00So surprisingly,
- 21:01it actually takes that in-house,
- 21:03longer to get up the courage to go and
- 21:07explore the middle of the of the cage.
- 21:13Uhm? And I realized that I'm being
- 21:16a bit loose in my my language here.
- 21:19When I when I say I'm out
- 21:20getting up the courage.
- 21:21Obviously I'm not meeting that literally.
- 21:23What I mean really is anxious like behaviors.
- 21:27Uhm? And so this finding has
- 21:29actually been replicated.
- 21:30Now many, many times what I'm showing
- 21:33the slides here on the left these are.
- 21:37Brain slices that are staying for
- 21:39this for the serotonin transporter
- 21:41and the wild type you see that the
- 21:44transporter is relatively ubiquitous
- 21:45across the the mouse brain,
- 21:47and then on the slide on the right
- 21:49it's entirely absent, so the the
- 21:51knockout process does indeed do it.
- 21:53It's supposed to do.
- 21:54And then, in terms of behavioral phenotypes.
- 21:59What I described previously was
- 22:01to increase latency to feed,
- 22:02but there's also increased anxiety
- 22:04like behaviors on an open field test,
- 22:07there's increased stress responsivity,
- 22:09increased social avoidance,
- 22:11and increased sensitivity
- 22:12to alcohol and to cocaine.
- 22:19Now, this finding of increased
- 22:21anxiety and depressive like behaviors
- 22:24is somewhat paradoxical because if
- 22:27SSRI's or disabling the transporter,
- 22:29then why should it be that
- 22:31removing the transporter should
- 22:33actually have the opposite effect?
- 22:36And to answer this is where having a
- 22:40developmental perspective is so so critical.
- 22:43So if we think of the,
- 22:44the knockout mouse is having the
- 22:47transporter removed from the gecko,
- 22:49so there's increased serotonin
- 22:51signaling from conception all
- 22:53the way through development.
- 22:55And what the FINA?
- 22:56The behavioral phenotype that
- 22:57we see is increased, anxious,
- 22:59and depressive like behaviors.
- 23:01The story is quite different
- 23:03with an SSRI treated.
- 23:07A mouse where you expose the mouse
- 23:09to an SSRI later in development
- 23:12and therefore only have increased
- 23:14serotonin signaling on a much
- 23:16more mature brain and see a
- 23:18different behavioral phenotype.
- 23:23So this, UM, this sort of developmental
- 23:26insight LED Mark answer Key and
- 23:29others to conduct a really elegant
- 23:32series of experiments where they
- 23:34asked what would happen if you
- 23:37block the serotonin transporter over
- 23:39distinct periods during development.
- 23:41And so using an SSRI in this case Prozac,
- 23:45they blocked the transporter in mice
- 23:47at different developmental stages,
- 23:49and then probed the anxious and
- 23:51depressive like behaviors in
- 23:53these mice during adulthood.
- 23:57And what they found was that
- 23:59if they blocked the transporter
- 24:01during the adult period during post
- 24:04day to post Natal Day 90 to 190,
- 24:06they did not see this increased in
- 24:09anxious or depressed like behaviors.
- 24:11Similarly, post data 21 to 41.
- 24:15And it was only in this relatively
- 24:18narrow window window that they saw that
- 24:21adult phenotypes increased anxiety from
- 24:24post Natal Day two to post Natal Day 11.
- 24:31So. Uhm? If we now translate that
- 24:38period into the human analogue.
- 24:40That period of post Natal Day
- 24:43two through post Natal Day 11,
- 24:45translates into the third
- 24:47trimester gestation in humans.
- 24:50So the prenatal period.
- 24:54Mark and others then went on to show
- 24:57that this early increase in serotonin
- 24:59signaling caused abnormalities in
- 25:01morphology and electrophysiology,
- 25:04and the informit cortex as well as.
- 25:08Alterations in theater learning.
- 25:15So now, uhm. The question that we
- 25:17need to ask is why should serotonin
- 25:21signaling have such different effects
- 25:23depending on the stage and development?
- 25:29It occurs the answer to this
- 25:32question is still somewhat unknown,
- 25:34but it likely relates to the
- 25:36functional role of serotonin changing
- 25:38over the course of development.
- 25:40So in adulthood, serotonin acts
- 25:42like a canonical neurotransmitter,
- 25:44but during the fetal period serotonin
- 25:46seems to act more like growth factor
- 25:50influencing neuronal proliferation,
- 25:51migration as well as the
- 25:54organization of early neurons and.
- 26:00My favorite example of this
- 26:02comes from Pat Leavitt's lab,
- 26:04where they found that the actual
- 26:07direction of axonal growth and can
- 26:11actually be reversed depending
- 26:13on serotonin concentrations.
- 26:16The mechanisms underlying how serotonin
- 26:18function changes over development
- 26:19are still being worked out and
- 26:21not within the scope of this talk,
- 26:23but there is a lot of really interesting
- 26:26work being done in this area,
- 26:28and I provide a reference here
- 26:29for those who are interested.
- 26:34So I now want to take you to
- 26:37the next part of the talk,
- 26:39so we've gone from the clinic where we
- 26:42talked about the increase in the use of
- 26:45SSR eyes during pregnancy to the bench,
- 26:48where we learned that at
- 26:51least in a preclinical model.
- 26:54Prenatal exposure to accessorize seemed to
- 26:57have long lasting our development effects,
- 27:00but the question now is,
- 27:02does this have any relevance to humans?
- 27:05And to answer this question,
- 27:07we're going to move from the bench to
- 27:10population studies or epidemiology.
- 27:14So I'm going to take you on a trip
- 27:18across the Atlantic to Finland.
- 27:21And Finland is really an extraordinary
- 27:23place to do epidemiologic work,
- 27:26because their health system
- 27:28tracks their health system,
- 27:30has a national registry where they can
- 27:33track all citizens from from birth forward,
- 27:37allowing investigators such like Andre
- 27:40surrender to look at the effects
- 27:43of exposures at a population level.
- 27:47So using this finish register registry,
- 27:50Andre and his colleagues were able
- 27:52to identify 60,000 infants who
- 27:54were born between 1996 to 2010.
- 27:57And then they stratified that sample
- 28:00into 33,000 who were born to healthy,
- 28:03nondepressed mothers.
- 28:0410,000 born to mothers with
- 28:07a diagnosis of depression.
- 28:09And then another 17,000 born to
- 28:13mothers who had a psychiatric illness
- 28:15and used an SSRI during pregnancy.
- 28:20And here's what they what
- 28:22they found and this slide.
- 28:24I realize it's a. It's a bit busy,
- 28:25so let me walk you through it.
- 28:28So what we're looking at here
- 28:30are four different outcomes in
- 28:32the children and the top left.
- 28:34The outcome is depression,
- 28:35and these are the percentage of
- 28:37children who develop depression,
- 28:39and these are the ages of the children.
- 28:41So as you move from from birth
- 28:43all the way up to 14 and you
- 28:45see there's this increase in
- 28:46the prevalence of depression.
- 28:48The top line has the infants
- 28:51who were exposed prenatally to
- 28:53SSRI's and you can see that that
- 28:56group is significantly higher
- 28:58than all the other groups.
- 29:01The other groups that they looked at were
- 29:04infants who were exposed to a maternal
- 29:08psychiatric illness during pregnancy,
- 29:10but with no medication.
- 29:12You see that in blue and yellow
- 29:15you have mothers who discontinued.
- 29:19SSRI before becoming pregnant.
- 29:23Uhm and and and then the black.
- 29:26You have a healthy control group.
- 29:30So there's a few things to note about this,
- 29:33so one is that the effects surprisingly
- 29:36seems to be somewhat specific,
- 29:38and that we see the effects of.
- 29:40On depression outcome but we don't see
- 29:42those effects for anxiety disorders,
- 29:45autism or ADHD.
- 29:46We don't see separation across the groups.
- 29:49And also the stratification that they use.
- 29:54Controls for the the presence of
- 29:57psychiatric illness in the mother.
- 30:00So it's unlikely to be attributable to.
- 30:04Prenatal psychiatric illness alone.
- 30:09Uhm? So this finish epidemiologic
- 30:11study is consistent with the
- 30:14preclinical findings that I showed you.
- 30:17But there really are some critical
- 30:20limitations that are that are
- 30:22important to be mindful of.
- 30:24First and foremost,
- 30:25there's a problem of what's called
- 30:28surveillance bias and what that refers to is.
- 30:31The idea that if they if a pregnant
- 30:34woman developed depression goes
- 30:35to her doctor and decides to
- 30:38take an anti depressant.
- 30:40That woman,
- 30:40when she becomes a mother may be
- 30:43more likely to notice depression
- 30:44and her offspring and bring her
- 30:47offspring to see a a physician
- 30:51rather than relative to a woman
- 30:53who who's depressed but does
- 30:55not seek SSRI treatment.
- 30:59The second issue is post Natal factors.
- 31:03So the finish study really did
- 31:05not address post Natal issues,
- 31:07so it's possible, for example,
- 31:09that the SSRI exposed group also
- 31:12experienced more negative post
- 31:13data exposures and these post Natal
- 31:16exposures were really driving the
- 31:18outcomes rather than the SSRI per say.
- 31:24And then the third limitation,
- 31:26and this is really a critical
- 31:27one in a really difficult.
- 31:30It's called one to address.
- 31:31This is called confounding by indication,
- 31:33and this is an issue that I'm going to
- 31:36continue to refer to later in the talk.
- 31:38This compound refers to the idea
- 31:39that there could be something
- 31:41systematically different about the
- 31:43mothers who took SSRI during pregnancy.
- 31:46So, for example,
- 31:47there might be some reason why
- 31:49those mothers were prescribed
- 31:51SSRI's versus the mothers who had
- 31:53depression and were not prescribed.
- 31:56Perhaps, for example,
- 31:57they had a more severe depression,
- 31:58and that's really what was
- 32:00driving the finding.
- 32:04So to try to address these
- 32:07limitations, I'm going to.
- 32:08I'm going to take you back to the
- 32:11clinic to a clinic based study
- 32:13that that we recently completed
- 32:15where we tried to address at least
- 32:18these first two limitations.
- 32:23So this is a an infant MRI study
- 32:26that we completed at New York
- 32:29Presbyterian Hospital where we
- 32:31recruited pregnant women from the OBGY
- 32:34and clinics at New York Presbyterian.
- 32:38We then conducted prenatal diagnostic
- 32:41and medication assessments and anywhere
- 32:45from 19 weeks to 39 weeks gestation.
- 32:48And then we stratified the
- 32:50women into three groups.
- 32:51So we had our healthy control
- 32:53group with no psychiatric illness.
- 32:55Are group of women who developed
- 32:58who are experienced depression
- 33:00during pregnancy but did not take
- 33:02medication and and then our SSRI group?
- 33:08We then obtained MRI scans on their
- 33:12babies at about 3 1/2 weeks of age.
- 33:15These were non sedated infants
- 33:18naturally put to sleep.
- 33:20And we covariate for intersex
- 33:23agents can birth weight and any
- 33:27post Natal depressive symptoms.
- 33:30So the strength of doing MRI scanning
- 33:33so early in life is that it limits the
- 33:37possibility of post Natal exposures.
- 33:40So we're essentially phenotyping
- 33:42the brain prior to the infant
- 33:44having many post Natal exposures
- 33:46by virtue of the young age.
- 33:51And this is work that was
- 33:53spearheaded by Claudia Lugo.
- 33:54Condo lesson juchau that they
- 33:57published in JAMA Pediatrics in 2018.
- 34:00So what do we find?
- 34:03So there's a couple findings that I
- 34:05I want to draw your attention to.
- 34:08Using structural MRI and
- 34:10looking across the whole brain,
- 34:13we found that the prenatally
- 34:16exposed babies had.
- 34:21Really two important findings.
- 34:23One was an increase in the
- 34:25volume of the right amygdala,
- 34:27and that was above and beyond what
- 34:28we saw in the depressed only group,
- 34:31and the healthy controls.
- 34:33And then similarly we saw a volume
- 34:35increase in the right amygdala,
- 34:37again in the SSRI group above,
- 34:39and beyond what we saw in
- 34:41our two comparison groups.
- 34:45We then looked at a diffusion tractography
- 34:49to look at white matter connectivity
- 34:52and again here we looked across the
- 34:55whole brain and unbiased approach.
- 34:57And and we found that there were four
- 35:01white matter connections that were
- 35:04increased differentially in the SSRI group.
- 35:07And what was most striking and that is that.
- 35:12The similar to the structural MRI findings
- 35:15we found increased connectivity between
- 35:18the right amygdala and the right insula,
- 35:21and that's displayed here in the
- 35:23violin plot again in the SSRI group,
- 35:25but not in our two comparison groups.
- 35:30So while these findings are consistent
- 35:33with what we would expect from the
- 35:35preclinical data that I showed you,
- 35:37as well as the population
- 35:39based study in Finland,
- 35:40they're not without important limitations.
- 35:44So first and foremost,
- 35:45our sample size was quite small.
- 35:47We only had 16 babies who were
- 35:49prenatally exposed tests, or I.
- 35:51Second, we still haven't addressed this
- 35:53issue of confounding by indication,
- 35:55which again I'm going to.
- 35:56I'm going to come back to 3rd.
- 35:59We had no in this study.
- 36:00We had no behavioral follow-ups,
- 36:02and we really don't know the behavioral
- 36:05significance of our MRI findings.
- 36:07And then, third importantly,
- 36:09there were really striking demographic
- 36:12differences across our samples.
- 36:14So if we looked at the SSRI group
- 36:17versus the depressed but no SSRI group,
- 36:20the SSRI group was significantly wealthier.
- 36:24We can't know for sure why that happened,
- 36:26but we assume it relates to access to care,
- 36:29and we of course tried to control
- 36:31for this and our analysis.
- 36:33But when the when the difference
- 36:34is that stark,
- 36:35there's a limit to what you can control.
- 36:37Or just statistically?
- 36:42OK. So this brings me to our
- 36:46our current ongoing study which
- 36:48were conducting in Sherbrooke,
- 36:51QC and this is a collaborative project
- 36:54that we're doing with Larissa Taxor,
- 36:57who's a professor at the University
- 36:59of Sherbrooke and Adi Talati,
- 37:01who is an associate professor
- 37:03at Columbia University.
- 37:04And the first question that I
- 37:06always get when presenting this
- 37:08work is why are we doing this
- 37:10study in Sherbrooke and in Quebec?
- 37:13And there's a few reasons for that.
- 37:16One is that as many of you know,
- 37:19Canada has universal health care,
- 37:22so that issue that I described before
- 37:24having the demographic differences that
- 37:26we think we're related to access to care.
- 37:29We're hoping that by doing this study
- 37:30in an area with universal healthcare,
- 37:32that should no longer be an
- 37:35issue in our follow-up study.
- 37:37The second Sherbrooke,
- 37:39being in Quebec,
- 37:41is Quebec is the only French speaking
- 37:43province in Canada and as a result
- 37:46people who are born in Quebec tend to
- 37:48stay in Quebec and for anyone who's
- 37:51ever done birth cohort brief research,
- 37:54you really don't want people
- 37:55moving out of area and makes it
- 37:57much much harder to do followups,
- 37:58so doing this type of study
- 38:00in in Quebec is advantageous,
- 38:02and our collaborator lyrics attacks
- 38:04are Rana prior birth cohort study and.
- 38:07At 90% retention up into adolescence,
- 38:10which is really remarkable for
- 38:12that type of study.
- 38:14And then third,
- 38:15although Sherbrooke is a
- 38:17relatively small city,
- 38:18it has about 200,000 people.
- 38:20It's the tertiary Center for
- 38:22all of eastern Quebec,
- 38:24so their volume of deliveries
- 38:25is actually quite high.
- 38:27They get about 2000 deliveries per year.
- 38:32So in this new study we are going
- 38:35to be recruiting women during
- 38:37the first trimester of pregnancy,
- 38:40following them over the course of
- 38:42gestation while tracking their depressive
- 38:44symptoms and their medication use.
- 38:47Will then be scanning their babies
- 38:49with MRI at about one month of age
- 38:51and then continuing to follow the
- 38:53babies for the 1st 24 months of life.
- 38:57And there's really three aims
- 38:59that we're trying to tackle.
- 39:02The first is can we replicate
- 39:04our prior infant MRI studies
- 39:06regarding the amygdala and insula?
- 39:09Uhm, the second ummites determine whether
- 39:12there are any behavioral effects.
- 39:14So we'll be doing will be looking
- 39:17at behavioral effects related to
- 39:19emotion regulation in the babies
- 39:20at 12 months and 24 months,
- 39:22testing whether there's any effect
- 39:24of SSRI on those behaviors,
- 39:26and whether that relates to the
- 39:29MRI findings and then third,
- 39:32will be testing for post Natal modifyers.
- 39:36So, for example, does the parent.
- 39:40Infant interaction during the foot needle
- 39:42period does that alter our outcomes?
- 39:48So I want to return again to this
- 39:51issue of confounding by indication,
- 39:54because this is an issue that
- 39:56we really struggled with in
- 39:58trying to design this study.
- 40:00Uhm, and the you know,
- 40:02the only way to fully address this confound.
- 40:05If through randomization
- 40:07randomizing or a group of depressed
- 40:10women to either SSRI or SIBO.
- 40:12But we we felt that that
- 40:15would not be feasible,
- 40:16and the ethics of that would be
- 40:19would be somewhat questionable.
- 40:21So in lieu of randomization, uh,
- 40:23we're trying to carefully phenotype
- 40:26the the nature of the depression and
- 40:29the SSRI use throughout gestation,
- 40:32so we will be through remote tracking,
- 40:35will be tracking the pregnant
- 40:37woman's mood symptoms every
- 40:38two weeks throughout gestation.
- 40:41Beginning in the first trimester,
- 40:43and will also be quantifying SSRI
- 40:46exposure through pharmacy records.
- 40:48So I want to give you an example
- 40:50of how we're thinking about.
- 40:51That's so if you take this
- 40:54case as one example,
- 40:55if you have a a pregnant woman
- 40:57during the first trimester,
- 40:59her level of depressive symptoms are
- 41:01low and she's not taking an SSRI.
- 41:04Then during the second trimester
- 41:06her depressive symptoms increase.
- 41:07Still,
- 41:07no SSRI.
- 41:08And then during the surgery master she
- 41:11has high depressive symptoms and no
- 41:13SSRI that will be one case example.
- 41:16And then you might have another pregnant
- 41:18woman woman wear during the first trimester.
- 41:21She has both high levels of depressive
- 41:23symptoms and is taking a high dose of
- 41:25an SSRI during the second trimester.
- 41:27The depressive symptoms remain high.
- 41:29SSR eyes drop a bit third trimester.
- 41:32Her depressive symptoms drop
- 41:33and her SSRI use goes up.
- 41:38What we can do with with that level
- 41:41of granularity then is essentially
- 41:43create individualized areas under
- 41:44the curve to quantify the degree
- 41:47of exposure to depressive symptoms
- 41:49that that the fetus has as well
- 41:52as the degree of SSRI exposure.
- 41:55Uhm, and what we're hoping is that
- 41:58this approach should minimize the
- 42:00likelihood that there are systematic
- 42:03differences in the maternal depression
- 42:05across our different groups,
- 42:07or to the extent that there
- 42:09are systematic differences,
- 42:09will be able to quantify those
- 42:11differences and account for them.
- 42:18So this is a an R1 funded study
- 42:21that we launched in 2019.
- 42:24In our original plan was to have
- 42:28recruitment of about 350 women
- 42:30for the first 2.5 years of the
- 42:33study and then have our final
- 42:35assessments four to five years later.
- 42:38That timeline has unfortunately
- 42:39been significantly altered
- 42:40due to COVID where we were.
- 42:43We were shut down for a
- 42:44significant period of time,
- 42:46but our overall strategy.
- 42:49Remains the same.
- 42:51And another point that I want to
- 42:53make is that our our hope and our
- 42:56expectation from this study is not
- 42:59that will find that prenatal SSRI
- 43:01use is harmful or on the other
- 43:04hand that it's entirely benign,
- 43:07but rather that our study can aid
- 43:10women and clinicians when they're
- 43:12making decisions about whether to
- 43:14use antidepressants during pregnancy.
- 43:16So currently that decision
- 43:18as I mentioned before,
- 43:19really is a balancing act
- 43:22between various risk factors,
- 43:24but we really aren't clear
- 43:25about what those risks are and
- 43:28what those ramifications are.
- 43:29The decisions being made simply
- 43:32with far too many unknowns.
- 43:35And we think that whether or
- 43:38not we find neurodevelopmental
- 43:39effects of prenatal SSRI use these
- 43:42results will be helpful either way.
- 43:45So, for example,
- 43:46if we have find that the effects of
- 43:48the SSRI really are minimal on the offspring,
- 43:51this will allow clinicians to
- 43:53more confidently prescribe SSR
- 43:54eyes and will allow pregnant women
- 43:56to use them with with much less
- 43:59anxiety about their effects.
- 44:00Alternatively,
- 44:00if we find that there are significant
- 44:03effects or significant concerns that.
- 44:06This will steer the field towards
- 44:08towards other treatments for depression
- 44:11treatments such as psychotherapy
- 44:13or non serotonin antidepressants.
- 44:18Before concluding, I also I wanted to
- 44:21briefly mention some of the methodological
- 44:25challenges of doing infant MRI work as
- 44:28this was quite relevant to our study.
- 44:32So up here on the left hand corner
- 44:35I'm showing you infant MRI scans,
- 44:37T2 weighted MRI scans from the same child
- 44:40when the child was three weeks old,
- 44:42and then again when the child was 16
- 44:45months old and what I want to point
- 44:47out is that this was the same MRI
- 44:49pulse sequence and yet you can see
- 44:51the contrast in the brain differs
- 44:54quite dramatically and the reason
- 44:55for that is that the water content
- 44:58of the brain changes substantially
- 45:00over the course of development.
- 45:02And that causes major challenges when
- 45:06doing infant MRI research because
- 45:09most of our existing pipeline and
- 45:12approaches for doing MRI analysis
- 45:14are based on a mature brain.
- 45:16And so if you change the
- 45:18contrast dramatically,
- 45:19those approaches are going
- 45:20to become much less accurate.
- 45:24So this is one UM example,
- 45:27where an existing pipeline in MRI
- 45:31pipeline and automated software is used
- 45:34to segment the amygdala and infant brand.
- 45:37So each one of these pictures is
- 45:39a different amygdala that's been
- 45:41segmented from an infant MRI scan and
- 45:43what I want to draw your attention
- 45:45to is that there's the overall
- 45:47curvature does look like the amygdala,
- 45:49but there's bumps and ridges in this
- 45:51that are clearly not representing.
- 45:53Anatomy and are just in accuracies
- 45:56and in the processing.
- 45:58So we are trying to leverage
- 46:02artificial intelligence to improve
- 46:05upon these techniques,
- 46:07and so these are the results
- 46:10from our AI approach.
- 46:11Segmenting the amygdala
- 46:13in from infant MRI scans,
- 46:16and you can see it's it's
- 46:18certainly not perfect,
- 46:19but these types of bumps are are much,
- 46:21much less common in in our segmentation
- 46:24relative to the standard case.
- 46:27Another huge.
- 46:28Advantage of UM,
- 46:31that this artificial intelligence
- 46:33approaches the the computational time.
- 46:35So segmenting a infant brand
- 46:38using standard software,
- 46:39it takes up to 8 hours per MRI scan,
- 46:43and if you're working with,
- 46:44you know large datasets that can
- 46:46be incredibly cumbersome for
- 46:48artificial intelligence which
- 46:50can do the same operation about
- 46:52literally about 10 seconds.
- 46:54We've also measured the accuracy of
- 46:56our AI AI approach against a gold
- 46:59standard human tracing of the amygdala,
- 47:02and ours outperforms the standard techniques,
- 47:06and this is work that's being
- 47:08spearheaded by Yun Wang and Claudia Lugo.
- 47:10Can Dallas.
- 47:13Uhm? So in summary, UM,
- 47:17some of the lessons that we've
- 47:20learned in doing this work.
- 47:23I realize this is probably preaching,
- 47:25preaching to the choir,
- 47:27but first is the the the importance
- 47:29of development and not forgetting
- 47:32that the infant brain is is not only
- 47:35is not an adult brain, only small,
- 47:37or that the Physiology of the
- 47:39infant brain of the developing
- 47:41brain really can differ quite
- 47:43substantially from the adult brain.
- 47:47The second is the importance of
- 47:50translational research that all of
- 47:53our approaches have limitations,
- 47:55and what we really should be shooting for
- 47:58is triangulation across those modalities.
- 48:01Uhm, and speaking to that point,
- 48:03I I want to conclude with a quote from
- 48:06Michael Rutter who said it would be a
- 48:08great mistake to see translation simply
- 48:10in terms of applying at the bedside.
- 48:13The findings of basic science.
- 48:15Many of the pathways start with clinical
- 48:17studies and not with basic science and
- 48:20an even greater proportion involve a
- 48:22complex iterative interplay between the two.
- 48:24And it's that iterative interplay
- 48:26that I think we're we're really after
- 48:28in in many questions of psychiatry,
- 48:30but certainly.
- 48:31The safety of SS variety during pregnancy.
- 48:37So I want to acknowledge that the
- 48:39people that have supported this work,
- 48:41UM, NIH, UM, the Webster Foundation,
- 48:46several others, and really wanted to
- 48:48thank you for your time and attention
- 48:50and happy to take any questions.
- 49:05Thank you Jonathan. I don't
- 49:07know how it worked on zoom,
- 49:08but if you were here in real
- 49:09life people just clap for you.
- 49:10I want you to know that.
- 49:12No, thank you.
- 49:14But really excellent and elegant
- 49:16program of research you described for me.
- 49:19Really cool to see the kind
- 49:21of bringing together at the.
- 49:23From everything from very basic kind
- 49:24of animal work to stuff that's very
- 49:26very relevant and applied one second
- 49:29while we changed the view here.
- 49:34Jonathan, could you stop sharing? Sure yes.
- 49:43He sent over a share. OK,
- 49:44here you go,
- 49:45Jonathan. There we go.
- 49:49OK, so now my understanding is
- 49:52that people in the audience
- 49:54can actually ask a question with
- 49:56their own mouths if they would like.
- 49:58If they unmute, I don't.
- 50:00I don't know that anyone's unmuted yet,
- 50:02but I can go ahead and
- 50:04start with a question
- 50:06so. I thought it was really cool to see
- 50:09to get an understanding of the mechanism
- 50:11of how SSR eyes could be affecting
- 50:14prenatal brain growth from the mice,
- 50:16and it's really cool to see the differences
- 50:20that you saw in the the neonates.
- 50:23And I guess my questions are,
- 50:25I mean, another thing interesting
- 50:26is if I understood correctly,
- 50:28like the the mechanisms of what
- 50:30the authorized we're doing.
- 50:31It's not simply like there's just and
- 50:34there's too little, too little serotonin.
- 50:36It's a different structure,
- 50:37it's affecting around migration.
- 50:39So I guess my question is,
- 50:40is do the mice,
- 50:42the differences you see in the mice brains.
- 50:46I know that the structure is
- 50:47going to be different,
- 50:48but are they at least consistent
- 50:50with the differences that you see in
- 50:52infant brains and an infant brains?
- 50:53Is the pattern of kind of insula,
- 50:55amygdala enlargement and
- 50:57connectivity differences?
- 50:59Is that an established kind of neural
- 51:01phenotype for people with major
- 51:03depressive disorder in adulthood?
- 51:06Those are great great questions.
- 51:08Jamie. Thanks so much for that.
- 51:10Yeah, you know I. I think it's
- 51:13really fascinating to think that.
- 51:15The, UM, the Physiology of serotonin
- 51:17or or it's a it's a fax on the brain
- 51:21can differ so substantially depending
- 51:23on the developmental period that you're
- 51:26you're looking at and you know one of
- 51:28the things that I I didn't mention.
- 51:30Also is that expression of the
- 51:34serotonin transporter also changes
- 51:36substantially across development.
- 51:38So in the adult or mature brain the
- 51:40expression is somewhat circumscribed,
- 51:43whereas in the fetal and infant brain.
- 51:46It's it's rather ubiquitous,
- 51:47so it's it's expressed,
- 51:48although for the brain, and interestingly,
- 51:51it's also it's not in the adult brain,
- 51:54its expression is limited to
- 51:56serotine ergic neurons,
- 51:58which would,
- 51:58which would make sense given its role.
- 52:00But in the fetal brain it's
- 52:02expressed in neurons that that
- 52:04don't actually release serotonin.
- 52:06Again, speaking to the more plausible
- 52:09role of serotonin as a neurotrophic
- 52:12factor rather than a neurotransmitter.
- 52:15Uhm, but to answer the other
- 52:18part of your question.
- 52:20So I I guess I would say yes and no,
- 52:23UM, so certainly,
- 52:25UM,
- 52:25the the behavioral phenotype that
- 52:28they're seeing in the rodent models
- 52:32relate to emotion regulation and
- 52:35what we saw in our Internet MRI
- 52:37scans the effects and the amygdala.
- 52:39The campus,
- 52:40certainly those are heavily
- 52:42implicated in emotional responses
- 52:44or emotional responses in how we
- 52:47respond to various emotional stimuli.
- 52:49So there's there's consistency.
- 52:51There.
- 52:52Uhm,
- 52:52where there's less,
- 52:53consistency is the the specific
- 52:56brain substrates.
- 52:57So in the rodent models the lion's
- 53:00share the lion's share of the
- 53:02findings were hippocampal based in,
- 53:04at least in our hands.
- 53:05We we did not.
- 53:06We did not see the effects
- 53:08and that the campus.
- 53:11But I you know I, I don't.
- 53:13I don't know that, UM,
- 53:15we should expect to see sort of a
- 53:17one to one correspondence in terms
- 53:19of in terms of neural substrates.
- 53:22You know, I think the fact that
- 53:25analogous brain circuits are
- 53:27involved is probably enough to
- 53:30motivate further work in humans. And
- 53:33what about babies to adults is like
- 53:36the insular amygdala and a kind of
- 53:38depressive neural phenotype in adults.
- 53:41Yeah, for sure, and I'm sorry that I
- 53:44I didn't mention that so alterations
- 53:47in connectivity between the amygdala
- 53:50and insula have been implicated
- 53:53in anxiety disorders in adults,
- 53:56and have also been implicated
- 53:58in trait levels of anxiety.
- 54:00So not just the disorder per say,
- 54:03it's more implicated in
- 54:05anxiety than depression,
- 54:06but I think probably trying to
- 54:09parse anxiety from depression.
- 54:11Particularly at that early stage,
- 54:14it may be asking too much of the data.
- 54:17Thank you. Other
- 54:19questions, either in the
- 54:20room or in cyberspace.
- 54:27I'll explain my position
- 54:29and then I'm also curious,
- 54:30given that kind of breath.
- 54:32I guess you describe it as kind of civic,
- 54:35but the the breadth of
- 54:36disruptions that you see.
- 54:37It's interesting to me that you
- 54:39the epidemiological effects you see
- 54:41are really specific to depression,
- 54:44which I guess isn't really a question,
- 54:45but that's just some striking to me.
- 54:48It is it is striking, yeah.
- 54:52And and it is striking.
- 54:54And all honestly,
- 54:55I don't quite know what to make of that.
- 54:58I I certainly would have
- 54:59predicted that if there were,
- 55:01in effect on depression, you would
- 55:03also see that affecting on anxiety II.
- 55:06Suppose one possibility for that is
- 55:09that the anxiety effects were elevated,
- 55:13they just weren't elevated above
- 55:15and beyond the other groups.
- 55:17So it it may be that the because the.
- 55:22The prenatal maternal illness
- 55:24is also increasing anxiety.
- 55:27We're not seeing a differential effect.
- 55:30And for whatever reason,
- 55:32that differential effect is
- 55:34only located in depression in,
- 55:36you know, I realize that's not
- 55:37a very satisfying answer, but.
- 55:40If others have thoughts on that,
- 55:42I would I would love to hear your your views.
- 55:46I'm less good at Andres than making
- 55:48vague threats to people on zoom
- 55:51who aren't and drink questions,
- 55:52and we've gotten in vivo question.
- 55:56But we've got to run the mic to you,
- 55:59OK.
- 56:17Can you on me? Yeah, can someone on the
- 56:20zoom give me a thumbs up if you can hear me
- 56:22Linda or Faye? Yes, I can hear you.
- 56:25I can hear you well understood you well
- 56:28and we can hear you as well.
- 56:29So that's good.
- 56:30Hold on one second.
- 56:30We have a question.
- 56:31It just say your name.
- 56:34Hi, I'm Cassie.
- 56:35I'm a postdoc or post graduate trainee.
- 56:38UM and I've had two.
- 56:41There's sort of half baked questions,
- 56:42but one of the things I was thinking
- 56:45about is I was wondering like what
- 56:47kinds of sort of subjective self
- 56:49report information you might be
- 56:50getting from others during their
- 56:52pregnancies and thinking about like.
- 56:54What kind of I guess I've met anxiety they
- 56:56might be having about being on an SSRI
- 56:59and potential developmental effects if
- 57:01these are women who are of High SC accident.
- 57:05I don't know, just like putting
- 57:07myself in that potential situation,
- 57:09I could imagine not only
- 57:11be anxious in general,
- 57:12but like having anxiety about my anxiety
- 57:14and knowing that that might have an
- 57:16effect on my child's development.
- 57:17So I was curious about what kinds
- 57:19of subjective self report stuff
- 57:21you might be getting from moms,
- 57:23and then honestly,
- 57:24my seeking questions is keeping me so.
- 57:26I guess I'll just leave it at that.
- 57:29Yeah,
- 57:29I, I think it's I think it's a really,
- 57:31really great question and I and
- 57:33I I think that also you know it
- 57:35speaks it Harkins back to this
- 57:36issue of confounding by indication.
- 57:38So you know, if you have a a group
- 57:40of women who are depressed and not
- 57:42taking necessary versus a group
- 57:44of women who are depressed and
- 57:46taking this try is there some?
- 57:47Is there some reason for that?
- 57:48Is there some reason why one
- 57:51group was prescribed and SSRI?
- 57:53And uhm. You know,
- 57:56really definitively answering
- 57:58that is is really difficult.
- 58:01You know our our approach was to
- 58:04enroll early on pregnancy so we
- 58:07could start assessing from the get go
- 58:11throughout the course of pregnancy
- 58:12and then to assess quite frequently,
- 58:15so we'd have multiple data points so we
- 58:17could look at things like trajectories.
- 58:19You know,
- 58:20changing the depression symptoms overtime.
- 58:23Uh, the differences across
- 58:25various trimesters,
- 58:27which which likely have an
- 58:29effect on on fetal development.
- 58:32The the the cost in doing that in
- 58:35doing this very frequent assessments
- 58:37is that our we didn't want to send
- 58:42women no extensive questionnaires
- 58:43every two weeks to fill out.
- 58:45We just didn't think that would be feasible.
- 58:47That people understandably would get
- 58:49frustrated and stop completing them.
- 58:51So our our assessments are are somewhat
- 58:53cursory and that we're using that.
- 58:55The PHQ 9 and GAD,
- 58:59which is a I can't remember a
- 59:00seven or nine item questionnaire.
- 59:03Self Report questionnaire about anxiety.
- 59:05And then we're also assessing
- 59:07any substance use,
- 59:08so we're assessing frequently
- 59:10over a long period of time,
- 59:12but the type of granularity that
- 59:15you're talking about in terms
- 59:17of the nature of the.
- 59:19Anxious feelings I think it's going to be.
- 59:21It's going to be difficult to to tease apart,
- 59:24but I I think you I think you
- 59:25raised a great point.
- 59:29Thanks Jonathan and we have
- 59:30a question from Malia.
- 59:31Hi, thank you so much for
- 59:33this great presentation.
- 59:33Such important work
- 59:35as we try to tease apart all day,
- 59:38probably some outcomes.
- 59:40And I'm really excited to see
- 59:42your your longitudinal findings,
- 59:44because my understanding at least,
- 59:46is that sometimes you know
- 59:48cross sectionally and infancy.
- 59:49You may see some of these changes, but later
- 59:51on the differences are not
- 59:53significant any longer, so I'm
- 59:56curious if you could comment a little
- 59:57bit about that
- 59:58and and additionally I was wondering in
- 01:00:01your studies or other studies that you know
- 01:00:06about or you present
- 01:00:07it if of course, not with mice,
- 01:00:10but with with. Humans.
- 01:00:14How do you also control for other
- 01:00:17therapies that a lot of these
- 01:00:19mothers may be exposed to
- 01:00:21and thinking about the fact that
- 01:00:23some of these non pharmacologic
- 01:00:27treatments also have effects on
- 01:00:29brain morphology and connectivity?
- 01:00:32Yeah, you know, I think that the both really,
- 01:00:35really great question.
- 01:00:36So the first question about
- 01:00:38sort of the post Natal effect I.
- 01:00:40I think that is hugely important and you
- 01:00:44know, in a human longitudinal study.
- 01:00:48It's you know, the postnatal
- 01:00:50environment is really complicated,
- 01:00:51and so to be able to assess
- 01:00:53every aspect of it.
- 01:00:54Of course it's not not feasible, but we are.
- 01:00:58We're trying to really
- 01:01:00get a comprehensive view,
- 01:01:01and so the strategy that we're taking is
- 01:01:05that they'll be four post Natal visits.
- 01:01:08Two of them will be in the home
- 01:01:09where will have researchers go and
- 01:01:11actually assess the home environment,
- 01:01:13and two of them will be in the in the lab.
- 01:01:17There were quite, uhm, we.
- 01:01:21We think that's very,
- 01:01:22very important to have a good
- 01:01:23characterization of the parent
- 01:01:25infant interactions.
- 01:01:25So we're actually collaborating
- 01:01:27with accident investigator,
- 01:01:29who I believe has an affiliation with Yale.
- 01:01:32Ruth Feldman,
- 01:01:33who developed a coding scheme to
- 01:01:36to code parent interactions and
- 01:01:38will be assessing those at anywhere
- 01:01:41from two to three time points,
- 01:01:44will also continue to assess the the mothers.
- 01:01:48For for psychiatric symptoms,
- 01:01:51postnatally so postpartum depression
- 01:01:53anxiety and we are also this is
- 01:01:56going to be more of a challenge,
- 01:01:58but our goal is to also incorporate
- 01:02:00fathers into that assessment to be
- 01:02:02able to assess psychiatric symptoms and
- 01:02:04substance use in the father's as well.
- 01:02:08You know, I I. I, I think that we're
- 01:02:12doing our darndest to get a good
- 01:02:14characterization of the postman environment,
- 01:02:16but I I fully acknowledge that there's,
- 01:02:19you know, the environment complicated,
- 01:02:20and there's there's a.
- 01:02:21There's a limit to what we
- 01:02:23could do in that regard.
- 01:02:24But I I agree with your point.
- 01:02:26That's it. Very well could be the
- 01:02:29case that there are initial post
- 01:02:31Natal effects that are fully moderated
- 01:02:34by the the post Natal environment.
- 01:02:37Uhm? And your second question.
- 01:02:40Other other treatments?
- 01:02:41Yeah, I think that's I think that's a
- 01:02:44great point in our our short book study.
- 01:02:47We will have information about
- 01:02:49other treatments.
- 01:02:51It won't be as granular as I might
- 01:02:54like it to be, so we'll know if,
- 01:02:56for example,
- 01:02:57if a pregnant woman received
- 01:02:59psychotherapy for depression,
- 01:03:01but will have limited information about
- 01:03:03the nature of that psychotherapy and
- 01:03:06the duration of that psychotherapy
- 01:03:08in Sherbrooke.
- 01:03:09The access to psychotherapy
- 01:03:11is relatively limited,
- 01:03:12so we we don't think that's
- 01:03:14going to be particularly common,
- 01:03:15but certainly could be there
- 01:03:18another way to look at that is.
- 01:03:21You arguably there could be a direct
- 01:03:24effect of the psychotherapy on the fetus,
- 01:03:27but I think more likely it would be
- 01:03:29an indirect effect through the mother
- 01:03:31psychiatric symptoms, and so we will be.
- 01:03:33We will be capturing us.
- 01:03:36And we have one last
- 01:03:38question from the audience.
- 01:03:42Thank you Jonathan.
- 01:03:43Loved your talk. Just wonderful.
- 01:03:44The question is in terms of getting a
- 01:03:48cause and the impact of SSRI exposure.
- 01:03:51I'm wondering do you have any more
- 01:03:53granular data or senior Sherbrooke study
- 01:03:56in terms of the dosages
- 01:03:58that the moms are getting?
- 01:04:00Or maybe the
- 01:04:01timing of the doses that might be able
- 01:04:04to tell a little bit more about costs.
- 01:04:07Yeah, absolutely so.
- 01:04:09So timing, I think it's going to be
- 01:04:11hard to to get at a. We will have.
- 01:04:14We will have access to the medical
- 01:04:16records and the pharmacy records
- 01:04:18so we'll know what's prescribed.
- 01:04:20Although the dose prescribed and
- 01:04:22we'll know what's what was filled.
- 01:04:25Uhm, and so we can we can,
- 01:04:28you know from that we can calculate
- 01:04:31the net exposure.
- 01:04:32Will know if the doctor prescribed
- 01:04:34it for morning intake versus
- 01:04:36evening and take the extent to which
- 01:04:38the patient follows that advice.
- 01:04:40We won't be able to determine that.
- 01:04:44You know another thing that
- 01:04:45I I should mention,
- 01:04:46which is somewhat tangential and
- 01:04:48that's why I didn't bring it up
- 01:04:51before is that we will also have
- 01:04:53very a very extensive biorepository,
- 01:04:57so act deliberately delivery will
- 01:04:59be collecting placenta cord.
- 01:05:02Blood during pregnancy will have
- 01:05:04maternal blood, which if we wanted to,
- 01:05:06for example,
- 01:05:06we could test for SSRI levels
- 01:05:08in the maternal blood.
- 01:05:09It would be one snapshot,
- 01:05:11but it would be at least some
- 01:05:13quantification of of level.
- 01:05:14Uhm, and then we'll also be looking at,
- 01:05:17UM, some post Natal biospecimens as well.
- 01:05:19Things like breast milk and and how
- 01:05:22there are potential transmissions there.
- 01:05:27Alright, perfect timing and that
- 01:05:29we're at the top of the hour
- 01:05:30so everybody can hear actually stand
- 01:05:32up and walk like the old days work.
- 01:05:34Just click, leave meeting and
- 01:05:35then enter your next meeting.
- 01:05:37But Jonathan, thank you very
- 01:05:39much for spending your party afternoon with
- 01:05:41us as an outstanding talk and
- 01:05:42it's clear from the questions
- 01:05:44everybody found it enjoyable,
- 01:05:45engaging, so and personally it's
- 01:05:46nice to see you and I'll look
- 01:05:48forward to seeing you as a real 3
- 01:05:50dimensional movie sometime soon.
- 01:05:52Wonderful, thank you so much.
- 01:05:53Really a pleasure.