Skip to Main Content
Quick Read

Self-Directed CBT Outperforms Traditional Therapy for Chronic Pain

4 Minute Read

Self-directed cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) may be more effective for chronic pain than traditional CBT, a new Yale-led clinical trial suggests.

Chronic pain can interfere with one’s ability to carry out daily activities, an effect referred to as “pain interference.” Patients who participated in a self-directed CBT program called Cooperative Pain Education and Self-management (COPES) experienced greater improvements in pain interference lasting up to a year post-treatment than those receiving typical clinician-delivered CBT, researchers report in JAMA.

Nearly a quarter of adults in the United States experience chronic pain, but the availability of psychologists who specialize in treating it are limited. Self-directed CBT not only can help improve the accessibility of treatment, but also reduce the burden on clinicians juggling heavy caseloads, the researchers say.

“We’re figuring out how to make it easier for people to do the treatments for chronic pain that we know are effective,” says Alicia Heapy, PhD, associate professor of psychiatry at Yale School of Medicine who developed COPES and is first author of the study.

How does self-directed CBT work?

CBT is an effective and low-risk intervention for patients with chronic pain, but many face barriers to receiving care. Some don’t live near a therapist specialized in treating chronic pain, and work and family obligations can pose challenges for others trying to schedule multiple weekly sessions. Self-directed therapy enables individuals to access evidence-based treatment from their own homes.

Heapy has been studying psychological interventions for chronic pain and the use of technology to improve their accessibility since she was a postdoctoral researcher. When she first began exploring the efficacy of self-directed treatment, her team initially hoped to demonstrate that it was as effective as clinician-delivered CBT. Her team’s work has shown over time that self-directed CBT is as effective, and sometimes more effective, than standard interventions.

“The pattern was very clear—at each time point across almost all outcomes, the self-directed treatment was better."

Alicia Heapy, PhD
Associate Professor of Psychiatry

Patients in the COPES program receive handbooks that teach pain management skills such as relaxation and healthy sleep strategies, and they set goals to practice them. They also participate in a walking program that challenges them to gradually increase their steps over the course of treatment.

A limitation of many self-directed treatment programs is low patient engagement. To improve engagement, Heapy included weekly personalized feedback as part of COPES. Each day, participants in COPES answered a brief survey about factors including the skills they practiced, progress towards their goals, sleep, steps, and pain interference. Participants also received weekly voice messages from a trained coach offering personalized feedback.

“People who are in our trials tell us that they liked getting that survey every day because it reminded them to practice and helped them feel more accountable to reach their goals,” Heapy says. “It’s also a form of self-monitoring, which we know is therapeutic in and of itself as people pay more attention to their patterns.”

Self-directed CBT more effectively reduces pain interference

The latest trial enrolled over 700 patients with chronic pain from U.S. Veterans Health Administration (VHA) healthcare systems across the country. They either received typical care from VHA clinicians or participated in COPES over 11 weeks. Importantly, the trial had broad eligibility criteria—researchers did not exclude participants with common conditions such as substance use disorders, depression, or post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).

“We did this so that the patients in the trial looked like the patients who are typically referred to CBT for chronic pain in VHA,” Heapy says.

The researchers measured how much pain interfered with patients’ daily activities at four, six, and 12 months post-baseline. While participants in both groups improved, those in COPES showed the greatest improvement, the findings showed. COPES also led to significantly greater improvements in other factors including sleep and depressive symptoms, and participants reported greater overall impressions of how well they thought the treatment worked.

“The pattern was very clear—at each time point across almost all outcomes, the self-directed treatment was better,” Heapy says.

She believes that the convenience of COPES contributed to its greater benefits—participants in this group were able to complete more sessions than those in traditional CBT.

COPES is available at VHA healthcare systems in multiple northeastern states, including Connecticut, Massachusetts, and Maine.

Article outro

Author

Isabella Backman
Senior Science Writer/Editor, YSM/YM

The research reported in this news article was supported by the National Institutes of Health (awards U24AT009769 and UG3/UH3-AT009767), the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (awards RCS 17-154 and RCS 11-222), and Yale University. The content is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of the National Institutes of Health or U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs.

Tags

Media Contact

For media inquiries, please contact us.

Explore More

Featured in this article