Institutional Review Board (IRB) for Those Initiating Clinical Studies
December 11, 2025Information
- ID
- 13697
- To Cite
- DCA Citation Guide
Transcript
- 00:01Jonathan Gower from OAPD office,
- 00:03and, we are
- 00:04honored today to have, Gina
- 00:06Larson talking to us. I
- 00:08said lightheartedly toward the beginning.
- 00:09I went to a recent
- 00:10talk she gave on this,
- 00:12general overview information of things
- 00:13we should all know, and
- 00:14I learned so much
- 00:16that, I quickly invited her
- 00:18and asked her if she'd
- 00:18come talk to the next
- 00:19group.
- 00:21So great to have you.
- 00:23Thanks for joining us, and,
- 00:25look forward to, hearing you
- 00:27here.
- 00:28Thank you.
- 00:29Great. Thank you so much,
- 00:30doctor Grauer. And, likewise, I,
- 00:32had a wonderful time speaking
- 00:34with the the other group,
- 00:35so I'm always excited to
- 00:36come back and and talk
- 00:38about the IRB and human
- 00:39subjects research with our faculty
- 00:41as well. So thank you
- 00:42all for having me. I'm
- 00:43excited to be here. My
- 00:44name is Gina Larson. I'm
- 00:45Associate Director for the Human
- 00:47Research Production Program. And today
- 00:49I'm here to give you
- 00:50some general information about the
- 00:51Yale IRB and Human Research
- 00:53Production Program.
- 00:55We're gonna cover some just
- 00:56general information you should know
- 00:58when you're starting to engage
- 00:59with the IRB. We're also
- 01:01going to talk about what
- 01:02types of projects would require
- 01:04IRB review and approval and
- 01:06those that might not need
- 01:07IRB review and approval.
- 01:09And then I'll provide you
- 01:10with some tangible
- 01:12information and guidance on how
- 01:13to submit research studies to
- 01:14the Yale IRB.
- 01:16This includes anything from chart
- 01:18reviews to, interventional
- 01:20research, and I'll also give
- 01:21you some tips and tricks
- 01:23for things like requesting HIPAA
- 01:24waivers, which I know will
- 01:25be extremely useful for this
- 01:27group. I have left a
- 01:28good amount of time at
- 01:29the end for questions. So
- 01:31if you could hold your
- 01:32questions to the end, that
- 01:33would be fantastic.
- 01:34And I'll obviously,
- 01:35be excited and willing to
- 01:37answer any questions that you
- 01:38have at that time. Time.
- 01:39You also have access to
- 01:40these slides. There's a lot
- 01:41of great links that are
- 01:43embedded within the slide deck.
- 01:44So I encourage you to
- 01:45go back and look at
- 01:46these slides
- 01:47at your convenience after we
- 01:49we have this workshop.
- 01:51With all of that out
- 01:51of the way, all of
- 01:52that housekeeping,
- 01:53let's get started.
- 01:56So first, let's talk about
- 01:57what is the Yale Human
- 01:58Research Protection Program and what
- 02:00is an institutional review board,
- 02:01which I'm sure many of
- 02:02you are familiar with, but
- 02:03we'll go over the basics.
- 02:05So the Yale Human Research
- 02:07Protection Program supports Yale University's
- 02:09dedication to excellence
- 02:11by promoting the rights and
- 02:12welfare of people who participate
- 02:13in research that's conducted at
- 02:15Yale,
- 02:16or by Yale faculty, students,
- 02:19staff, or any Yale affiliates.
- 02:21We are an AARP accredited
- 02:23institution. I'm sure many of
- 02:24you have maybe come from
- 02:25other AARP accredited institutions. That's
- 02:28pretty much the gold standard,
- 02:30when it comes to human
- 02:31research production programs, ensuring that
- 02:34we go above and beyond
- 02:35the federal regulations
- 02:36to make sure that people
- 02:37people are protected in research,
- 02:39and our researchers are also
- 02:40going above and beyond. So
- 02:42we're really proud of that
- 02:43designation,
- 02:44and we do get reaccredited
- 02:45by aHARP every five years.
- 02:49So obviously, there's a lot
- 02:50of people that are working
- 02:51together to ensure that people
- 02:53are protected in research all
- 02:54across Yale, and that includes
- 02:56our researchers, our study
- 02:58coordinators, our PIs,
- 03:00our HRPP,
- 03:01and all of our other
- 03:02departments that we work with,
- 03:04within the context of of
- 03:06Yale.
- 03:06However, the biggest component of
- 03:08a human research production program,
- 03:10whether it's here at Yale
- 03:11or anywhere, is an institutional
- 03:13review board, also known as
- 03:14an IRB, and I'm sure
- 03:15that's the acronym you're probably
- 03:17most familiar with when it
- 03:18comes to human research studies
- 03:20and submitting those studies to
- 03:21an ethics board.
- 03:23IRBs ensure that research involving
- 03:25humans is conducted following the
- 03:27ethical principles outlined in the
- 03:28Belmont Report, which we'll talk
- 03:30about very briefly next, and
- 03:32all of those applicable laws,
- 03:33regulations, and human research standards.
- 03:36This includes all of our
- 03:37Department of Health and Human
- 03:38Service regulations,
- 03:40our FDA regulations,
- 03:42federal, state, and local regulations.
- 03:44So sometimes when you submit
- 03:46your applications to the IRB,
- 03:48you might think, you know,
- 03:48they're asking a lot of
- 03:49questions, and they're making me
- 03:51change this and they're asking
- 03:52me to clarify this point.
- 03:54I promise it's not because
- 03:55we're being mean or we're
- 03:56being nitpicky or anything.
- 03:58It truly is because we
- 04:00have to ensure that you
- 04:01are following all of these
- 04:02different regulations
- 04:04so that people are protected,
- 04:05but also you are protected
- 04:07as a researcher as well.
- 04:09IRBs also ensure compliance with
- 04:11university policies. We monitor for
- 04:13risk and safety concerns in
- 04:14human subjects research, and we
- 04:16consider the local context, so
- 04:18the interpretations,
- 04:19standards of practice,
- 04:20and community considerations
- 04:22of human subjects research. How
- 04:24is the community that you're
- 04:25working with going to be
- 04:26impacted by this research? We're
- 04:28considering all of that as
- 04:29well.
- 04:31Unfortunately,
- 04:32as you all probably know,
- 04:33the birth of the IRB
- 04:34resulted,
- 04:35from a history of unjustifiable
- 04:38crimes against humanity and unethical
- 04:40practices
- 04:41in the name of science
- 04:42and research.
- 04:44I do, this session I
- 04:46I go into depth about
- 04:47some of these things that
- 04:48we've seen. Obviously, you all
- 04:49know of the Tuskegee syphilis
- 04:51study,
- 04:51obviously, the atrocities that happened
- 04:53in concentration camps,
- 04:55during World War two,
- 04:57and,
- 04:57many other things that you
- 04:58see on your screen here.
- 05:00So because of all of
- 05:01these atrocities,
- 05:02we knew we had to
- 05:03put ethics boards in place,
- 05:04and we had to have
- 05:05laws and guidelines and regulations
- 05:08to ensure that people are
- 05:09protected
- 05:10in the research endeavor.
- 05:13One of the biggest
- 05:14ethical documents that came out
- 05:16of these atrocities was the
- 05:17creation of the Belmont Report
- 05:19in April of nineteen seventy
- 05:20nine. This is still to
- 05:22this day the cornerstone
- 05:24document and statement of ethical
- 05:25principles that guide human subjects
- 05:27research.
- 05:28If you haven't read the
- 05:29Belmont Report, I definitely recommend
- 05:31that you do so. It's
- 05:32only ten pages long and
- 05:34the writing actually still holds
- 05:36up to today's language. And
- 05:37we actually have really close
- 05:39ties here at Yale to
- 05:40the Belmont Report because one
- 05:41of our faculty members was
- 05:43one of the authors of
- 05:44the Belmont Report. So definitely
- 05:46something that you should check
- 05:47out if you haven't done
- 05:48so already.
- 05:49And there's three pillars of
- 05:51the Belmont Report. So when
- 05:53IRBs are reviewing research, we
- 05:54have to ensure that each
- 05:56of these pillars is being
- 05:57met in order for a
- 05:58study to be approved.
- 06:00The first pillar is respect
- 06:01for persons, so treating people
- 06:03as autonomous agents, ensuring that
- 06:05people have a decision about
- 06:07if they want to participate
- 06:08in research or not, and
- 06:10they're not being forced or
- 06:11coerced in any way.
- 06:13The second pillar is beneficence.
- 06:15So you're maximizing
- 06:16benefits of research as much
- 06:18as possible while minimizing harms.
- 06:20And then the third pillar
- 06:21is justice.
- 06:23So you're selecting participants in
- 06:25an equitable manner. You're not
- 06:27maybe targeting a very vulnerable
- 06:29group or vulnerable population that
- 06:31they're going to see receive
- 06:32all of the negative effects
- 06:34of research, but at the
- 06:35same time, you're not only
- 06:36offering really great treatments and
- 06:38research to individuals who have
- 06:40the means to be able
- 06:41to travel and access these
- 06:43clinical trials.
- 06:44So you're you're
- 06:46spreading out the the burdens,
- 06:48and also the benefits of
- 06:50research,
- 06:51equally amongst your populations.
- 06:55Let's go into some federal
- 06:56regulations,
- 06:57really quickly because these are
- 06:59some of the things that
- 07:00you will likely encounter when
- 07:01you're submitting your research studies
- 07:03and some of the things
- 07:04that you should be aware
- 07:05of. You don't have to
- 07:06be experts in the federal
- 07:07regulations. That's why we're here.
- 07:09We will help you through
- 07:10them, but it's good to
- 07:11know where your research may
- 07:13or may not fall depending
- 07:14on your funding source
- 07:16so that you know if
- 07:16there's, certain reporting requirements or
- 07:18something down the road and
- 07:20if something happens.
- 07:21So first, we have the
- 07:23HHS regulations.
- 07:25This is more commonly referred
- 07:26to as the common rule.
- 07:28This was created in nineteen
- 07:29ninety one. We actually had
- 07:31a revision to the common
- 07:32rule in twenty seventeen that
- 07:34became effective in twenty eighteen.
- 07:36So you might have seen
- 07:36there were some changes to
- 07:37like exempt research categories and
- 07:40some restructuring of the consent
- 07:42form that needed to happen
- 07:43with that new key information
- 07:44section. These are some of
- 07:46the things that changed with
- 07:47that revision to the common
- 07:48rule. But these are essentially,
- 07:50you know, this is the
- 07:50basic HHS policy.
- 07:53This provides us with all
- 07:54of the information we need
- 07:55to understand with regards to
- 07:57what is required for informed
- 07:58consent,
- 07:59how are you going to
- 08:01handle enrolling vulnerable populations in
- 08:03research. So the regulations say
- 08:05that pregnant women, fetuses, neonates,
- 08:08prisoners, and children are vulnerable
- 08:10per the regulations. Again, we
- 08:11know there's much more vulnerable
- 08:13populations than that, but those
- 08:15are the ones that are
- 08:16carved out in the regulations.
- 08:18So if you have any
- 08:20research that's funded by NIH,
- 08:23NSF,
- 08:24any of those, I think
- 08:25there's over, you know, thirty
- 08:26to forty departments that are
- 08:28regulated by HHS. If you're
- 08:30funded by any of those,
- 08:31you are subject to these
- 08:32regulations.
- 08:33However, even if you are
- 08:34unfunded,
- 08:35we do, like I said
- 08:36before, going by those ARP
- 08:38standards, we go above and
- 08:39beyond the regulations. So we
- 08:41do apply these regulations
- 08:43even to unfunded research as
- 08:45well. The only thing that
- 08:46we don't apply
- 08:47equally is if there's something
- 08:50like a,
- 08:51serious noncompliance
- 08:53or an unanticipated
- 08:54problem, we don't report that
- 08:55to HHS if it's not
- 08:57funded, but everything else remains
- 08:59the same.
- 09:00In addition to HHS, we
- 09:02have our FDA regulations.
- 09:04So if you're going to
- 09:05be working with a drug
- 09:06or a device,
- 09:07these are the regulations that
- 09:09pertain to you and your
- 09:10research studies.
- 09:11Thankfully, a lot of the
- 09:13basic policy is the same
- 09:14as the Department of Health
- 09:16and Human Services,
- 09:17but there are obviously other
- 09:19types of subparts with FDA
- 09:20regulated research just because of
- 09:22the nature of the research.
- 09:23Right? So we have part
- 09:25eleven compliance, you've probably heard
- 09:27of. Those are requirements for
- 09:29electronic signatures.
- 09:31And then obviously, we have
- 09:32various subparts for working with
- 09:35INDs,
- 09:36biological
- 09:37products,
- 09:38devices.
- 09:39So again, you don't have
- 09:40to be experts in all
- 09:41of these
- 09:42rules and and regulations, but
- 09:44certainly know that they may
- 09:46apply to your research. And
- 09:47it's important to be just
- 09:48familiar with the general structure
- 09:50of what we are abiding
- 09:52by when we're reviewing your
- 09:53research studies.
- 09:55So now that we've given
- 09:56you an overview
- 09:57of the landscape of IRBs,
- 10:00let's talk about what is
- 10:02and what is not human
- 10:03subjects research. Again, that that
- 10:05may or may not require
- 10:06IRB review and approval.
- 10:08And it's easier to start
- 10:09with what is not human
- 10:10subjects research. We get a
- 10:12lot of questions about various
- 10:13projects. What is something that
- 10:15you wouldn't need to submit
- 10:16to an IRB?
- 10:17One is data on deceased
- 10:19persons.
- 10:21So if you are looking
- 10:21at medical records or information
- 10:23from individuals who have passed
- 10:25away, you actually don't have
- 10:27to submit that to an
- 10:28IRB for review because as
- 10:29you'll see in the next
- 10:30few slides when we get
- 10:31into what is human subjects
- 10:32research,
- 10:33it's only about living individuals.
- 10:36However, one caveat here that
- 10:37I think is important to
- 10:38note is the HIPAA Privacy
- 10:40Rule protects the individually
- 10:42identifiable health information about a
- 10:44decedent for fifty years after
- 10:46they pass.
- 10:48So if you are looking
- 10:49at
- 10:50decedent information from somebody or
- 10:52a group that has passed
- 10:53away, you know, five years
- 10:54ago, ten, twenty, even though
- 10:56you don't need IRB approval,
- 10:58you will still need,
- 11:00approval from a HIPAA perspective.
- 11:01So I have linked
- 11:03a form here for you,
- 11:05which is a request for
- 11:06access to PHI for research
- 11:08purposes for decedents.
- 11:10So that will be, useful
- 11:12for you to have in
- 11:13your pocket.
- 11:14Also, what is not human
- 11:15subjects research is obviously data
- 11:17about health facilities, businesses, or
- 11:20organizations.
- 11:21So if you're not talking
- 11:22to somebody, you're not collecting
- 11:23their information,
- 11:25that's not human subjects research.
- 11:26If you're looking at processes
- 11:28at an organization
- 11:29or, you know, bus routes
- 11:31and and what that means
- 11:32from an engineering perspective, that's
- 11:34not something that you would
- 11:35interface with a human for
- 11:36and ask them about themselves
- 11:38or their opinions.
- 11:39So, obviously, those types of
- 11:40projects are not human subjects
- 11:42research. And then finally, on
- 11:44this slide,
- 11:45de identified
- 11:46human data or specimens.
- 11:48Now this is very important
- 11:50to note. This does not
- 11:51mean that you are going
- 11:52into the medical record and
- 11:53then de identifying that information
- 11:55yourself and then taking that
- 11:57data set and conducting research
- 11:58with that data set. It
- 11:59truly means that somebody is
- 12:01giving you a completely deidentified
- 12:03data set per the eighteen
- 12:05HIPAA identifiers.
- 12:06In those cases, you would
- 12:08need to submit that type
- 12:09of project to the IRB
- 12:10for review.
- 12:13Also, what is not human
- 12:14subjects research is a case
- 12:15study or a case report.
- 12:18As you're probably familiar with,
- 12:20these are presentations of a
- 12:21detailed critique, so the characteristics,
- 12:24evaluation, or treatment
- 12:25of one or more patients
- 12:26that share a common condition
- 12:28to provide insights into aspects
- 12:30of the clinical case. Let's
- 12:32say you have three individuals
- 12:33that share a very common
- 12:35disorder, and in the clinical
- 12:37sphere, you're seeing that a
- 12:39certain treatment is working really
- 12:40well for them, and you
- 12:41want to publish this and
- 12:42talk about this from a
- 12:43case study perspective to help
- 12:45others in your field
- 12:46understand this case.
- 12:48That would be okay to
- 12:49do without any type of
- 12:50IRB approval.
- 12:52The reason is because this
- 12:53is really analysis of a
- 12:54unique situation,
- 12:56and it does not include
- 12:57any activities defined as research.
- 13:00Again, similar to the decedent
- 13:02information we talked about a
- 13:03couple of slides back, when
- 13:05you're publishing case studies,
- 13:07don't refer to it as
- 13:08research, but you still need
- 13:09to obtain permission from the
- 13:11individual
- 13:12via a non research permission
- 13:14form in order to use
- 13:16their information
- 13:17for that case report or
- 13:18case study. Again, I have
- 13:20linked a form for you
- 13:21here that you can use
- 13:22for those purposes. And if
- 13:24you do have questions on
- 13:25this, feel free to reach
- 13:26out to me directly. I'd
- 13:27be happy to talk with
- 13:28you about any case studies
- 13:29or case reports you might
- 13:30be interested in in publishing.
- 13:34What is also not human
- 13:35subjects research is activities
- 13:37prepped to research.
- 13:38So let's say you're looking
- 13:39at medical records or other
- 13:41sources
- 13:42to determine whether there is
- 13:43a sufficient population to conduct
- 13:45the research that you want
- 13:46with meaningful results.
- 13:48You can look at the
- 13:49medical records. You can look
- 13:51at information.
- 13:52However, you cannot record any
- 13:54identifying information. You can't go
- 13:56into the record and then
- 13:57type in some notes about,
- 13:58you know, there's this many
- 13:59patients and these are the
- 14:01birth dates and this is
- 14:02the medical information tied to
- 14:03it. It really is you
- 14:05just looking at the medical
- 14:06record to see if there's
- 14:08information that would you would
- 14:10be able to create a
- 14:11a full research study out
- 14:12of and and look at
- 14:13that data, and then you
- 14:14would submit to the IRB
- 14:15to conduct that research that
- 14:17you want to.
- 14:19Probably the biggest question that
- 14:21we get about is my
- 14:22project something that needs to
- 14:24be submitted to the IRB
- 14:26is quality improvement projects. And
- 14:28I know there's a lot
- 14:29of questions on quality improvement
- 14:31because it's a huge gray
- 14:33area.
- 14:34I will say,
- 14:36if you have a quality
- 14:37improvement project you're conducting or
- 14:39you're you're not quite sure,
- 14:40please just reach out to
- 14:41me directly. I'd be happy
- 14:42to talk about that with
- 14:43you. We also have a
- 14:45really, really nice guidance document
- 14:47that we've created
- 14:48that goes through various case
- 14:50studies and shows what might
- 14:51be a quality improvement project
- 14:53versus a research project, and
- 14:55you can kind of check
- 14:56off this these checks check
- 14:57boxes we have,
- 14:59in that guidance document. So
- 15:00I certainly recommend that you
- 15:02take a look at that.
- 15:03But what is a quality
- 15:04improvement project?
- 15:06It's a data guided initiative
- 15:07designed to improve clinical care,
- 15:09health care operations,
- 15:11services and programs,
- 15:13or for developing new programs
- 15:15or services. This could be
- 15:16teaching evaluations,
- 15:18patient employee service surveys.
- 15:20Let me give you an
- 15:21example of a true quality
- 15:22improvement project. Let's say you
- 15:24are working in a clinic,
- 15:26and you're noticing that you're
- 15:27not quite happy with handwashing
- 15:29practices amongst the staff,
- 15:32the clinicians,
- 15:33so you wanna change that
- 15:34behavior.
- 15:35Let's say you do a
- 15:37pre survey
- 15:38to assess handwashing practices.
- 15:41You conduct the intervention,
- 15:43and then you do a
- 15:43post survey to see if
- 15:45there's been a change in
- 15:46behavior with handwashing.
- 15:48Maybe at the same time,
- 15:49you're looking at medical records
- 15:51of patients and assessing rates
- 15:52of infection. Right? So you're
- 15:54trying to link if the
- 15:55handwashing intervention,
- 15:57led to a decrease in
- 15:58infections in the hospital.
- 16:00That is a true quality
- 16:02improvement project. Right? It's applicable
- 16:04to a particular setting. It's
- 16:06not intended to be generalizable,
- 16:08and it shouldn't be referred
- 16:10to as research.
- 16:11We do have people that
- 16:12want to publish quality improvement
- 16:14projects, and that's certainly okay.
- 16:16I would recommend in those
- 16:18cases that you submit a
- 16:20not human subjects research application
- 16:23to the IRB.
- 16:24It's essentially a form that
- 16:25says, hey. I'm not conducting
- 16:27research. I'm conducting a quality
- 16:29improvement project, here's a really
- 16:30quick snippet of what it
- 16:31is, you send it to
- 16:32the IRB and we will
- 16:34issue a letter that says,
- 16:35yep, you're correct, we reviewed
- 16:37it, this is a quality
- 16:38improvement project, it's not reach
- 16:40research, but the IRB has
- 16:41taken a look at at
- 16:42it because sometimes journals will
- 16:44ask for that type of
- 16:45letter from the IRB assessing
- 16:47that. So I would say
- 16:48that even though you don't
- 16:49need to submit these projects
- 16:51at all to the IRB
- 16:52for review and approval,
- 16:54if you are hoping to
- 16:55publish, it might be something
- 16:56you might want to submit
- 16:57to the IRB just to
- 16:59have that letter that says
- 17:00an IRB did take a
- 17:01look at this.
- 17:04This is a nice, a
- 17:05very rudimentary
- 17:06graph that kind of shows
- 17:07you various elements of your
- 17:09projects and when it might
- 17:10fall into the research bucket
- 17:12versus quality improvement.
- 17:13So what is the purpose
- 17:15of your study or your
- 17:16project? What is the design?
- 17:18Are there benefits? Are there
- 17:19risks? And what are your
- 17:20publication intentions?
- 17:22And this helps you to
- 17:23determine if your research might
- 17:25fall in if your project
- 17:26might fall in the research
- 17:27bucket versus the quality improvement
- 17:29bucket. But again, if you
- 17:30have questions on this, it's
- 17:32a huge gray area.
- 17:33I'd be happy to chat
- 17:34with you about your project.
- 17:37So now that we've talked
- 17:38about what is not human
- 17:40subjects research, let's talk about
- 17:42what is human subjects research
- 17:43that would require IRB review
- 17:45and approval. And before I
- 17:46do that, the sun is
- 17:47in my face, so let
- 17:48me just pull this shade
- 17:49down really quickly. I appreciate
- 17:50that.
- 17:53Okay.
- 17:54So we're we go by
- 17:55the HHS definitions here, but
- 17:57the FDA have very similar
- 17:59definitions.
- 18:00Let's start with the definition
- 18:01of research and break it
- 18:02down a little bit.
- 18:04Research is a systematic investigation,
- 18:06including research development, testing, and
- 18:08evaluation
- 18:10designed to develop or contribute
- 18:11to generalizable
- 18:13knowledge. So you want to
- 18:14add to literature in your
- 18:15field,
- 18:16you want to contribute to
- 18:17that literature,
- 18:18and you have a hypothesis,
- 18:20you have research questions,
- 18:22that is the true definition
- 18:23of research, the systematic investigation.
- 18:26And a human subject is
- 18:28a living individual. Remember, we
- 18:30talked about decedents before? It's
- 18:32a living individual about whom
- 18:34an investigator conducting research either
- 18:36obtains information or biospecimens
- 18:39through intervening or interacting with
- 18:41somebody,
- 18:42or they obtain, use, study,
- 18:44analyze, or generate identifiable
- 18:47private information or biospecimens.
- 18:49So in order for you
- 18:50to have a project that
- 18:52requires IRB review and approval,
- 18:54it has to involve,
- 18:56human subject per this definition,
- 18:58and you have to be
- 18:59conducting research per this definition.
- 19:01And then that's something that
- 19:02the IRB would need to
- 19:03see.
- 19:05This is again another very
- 19:06simple decision tree for you,
- 19:09to help walk you through
- 19:10if you are conducting a
- 19:11research project, and it's essentially
- 19:13the definitions that we just
- 19:14went over in the previous
- 19:16slide.
- 19:18So we review a lot
- 19:19of different types of research.
- 19:21I know this is a
- 19:21very busy slide, but I
- 19:23will break it down for
- 19:23you step by step.
- 19:25We see
- 19:27research that involves
- 19:29interventional,
- 19:30drugs. We see devices.
- 19:33We see greater than minimal
- 19:34risk studies,
- 19:36we see studies that involve
- 19:38controversial
- 19:39issues, prisoners,
- 19:41most of that is reviewed
- 19:42at the full board level.
- 19:44That means that we have
- 19:45IRB chairpersons,
- 19:47experts in the field, community
- 19:48members that meet, and they
- 19:50actually review the study together.
- 19:52They go over the
- 19:54risks, the benefits,
- 19:56are all of the criteria
- 19:58per the federal regulations being
- 19:59met, is it ethical?
- 20:01So they're meeting to really
- 20:02talk about this, and you'll
- 20:03get your approval from the
- 20:05fully convened board. Again, these
- 20:07are those greater than minimal
- 20:08studies, drug device studies.
- 20:11The really cool thing about
- 20:12Yale, which may be different
- 20:13than some institutions that you've
- 20:15been at, is we actually
- 20:16have nineteen
- 20:18IRBs,
- 20:19which is a huge number.
- 20:20Some institutions only have, you
- 20:21know, one or two or
- 20:23three. Because we have so
- 20:24many IRBs, we meet several
- 20:26times a week. So once
- 20:27you submit your study, it
- 20:29will get assigned to a
- 20:30meeting,
- 20:31you know, very, very shortly.
- 20:32And as long as you
- 20:33are, working with us and
- 20:35when we're asking questions, you're
- 20:36getting back to us really
- 20:37quickly. Thankfully, we're able to
- 20:39approve those studies
- 20:41at a relatively,
- 20:43good good level, and then
- 20:45it doesn't take too long
- 20:46to approve those studies.
- 20:48We also have expedited studies
- 20:50that we see. So these
- 20:51are studies that are always
- 20:52going to be minimal risk,
- 20:54and they fit into one
- 20:55of the expedited categories that
- 20:57we have per the regulations.
- 21:00These are studies that maybe
- 21:02involve a it's it's not
- 21:03greater than minimal risk, but
- 21:05maybe there's, like, a blood
- 21:06draw involved, or there's some
- 21:07type of, like, physical intervention,
- 21:09or maybe it's a very
- 21:10sensitive research project,
- 21:12you're working with a very
- 21:13vulnerable population,
- 21:15that might be something that
- 21:16would push it into an
- 21:17expedited level,
- 21:19and again, it's
- 21:20not reviewed at this full
- 21:21board level so it's a
- 21:23little bit quicker of a
- 21:24process
- 21:25similar to exempt research. So
- 21:27exempt research is probably the
- 21:28most research that we see,
- 21:30and it's the lowest risk
- 21:32research, but there's a lot
- 21:33of different types of research
- 21:34that can be done under
- 21:35the exempt research categories.
- 21:38I will say here at
- 21:39Yale, we do require
- 21:41that investigators submit exempt research
- 21:43to the IRB. I know
- 21:44some institutions allow investigators
- 21:47to make their own exempt
- 21:48determinations.
- 21:49We do not allow that
- 21:50at Yale. So you will
- 21:51need to submit those chart
- 21:52reviews to us. You will
- 21:54need to submit those interview
- 21:55and survey studies to us,
- 21:56and we'll get you that
- 21:57approval. Again, it's a pretty
- 21:58quick it's a it's a
- 21:59pretty quick turnaround for our
- 22:01exempt research. So it's
- 22:03within a few days to
- 22:04a week as long as
- 22:05you're getting back to us
- 22:06if we have questions to
- 22:08you. So that's that's really
- 22:09great. And I'll walk you
- 22:10through that process in just
- 22:11a few slides.
- 22:13So, again, these are all
- 22:14of our minimal risk surveys,
- 22:15interviews, focus groups, observation of
- 22:18public behavior, research on educational
- 22:20techniques,
- 22:21review of data that is
- 22:23either publicly available or no
- 22:24identifiers are being recorded.
- 22:26And the biggest one that
- 22:27we see is the HIPAA
- 22:29category, essentially, is what we
- 22:30call it. So that's secondary
- 22:32research use of identifiable private
- 22:34information
- 22:35or identifiable biospecimens
- 22:37regulated under HIPAA. So many
- 22:39of our medical record reviews
- 22:41that we see. It also
- 22:42includes this new interesting category
- 22:44that was added in the
- 22:45twenty eighteen regulations
- 22:47called benign behavioral interventions.
- 22:49So,
- 22:50that was a new one
- 22:51that was interesting for us
- 22:52to, navigate as as that
- 22:55was added in the regulations.
- 22:57Okay. So let's talk a
- 22:58little bit about chart reviews
- 23:00because I know many of
- 23:00you are going to be
- 23:01submitting these to the IRB.
- 23:03So these are found at
- 23:04exempt category four.
- 23:07You will have when you're
- 23:08submitting these to the IRB,
- 23:10there's going to be an
- 23:11exemption request form that's going
- 23:12to ask you about the
- 23:14category you believe your research
- 23:15is. You don't have to
- 23:16be right. The IRB will
- 23:18help you out here, but
- 23:19it's good to know if
- 23:20you are conducting a medical
- 23:21record review, it will be
- 23:22that exempt category four.
- 23:24Specifically, this little,
- 23:27little little I, three little
- 23:28i's or or number three.
- 23:30So this is secondary research
- 23:32for which consent is not
- 23:33required.
- 23:34Secondary research uses of identifiable
- 23:36private information or identifiable biospecimens
- 23:39if at least one of
- 23:40the following criteria is met.
- 23:42So for those chart reviews,
- 23:44it's this third point here.
- 23:46The research involves only information
- 23:48collection and analysis involving the
- 23:50investigator's use of identifiable
- 23:52health information
- 23:54that is regulated under these
- 23:55regulations
- 23:56and for the purposes of
- 23:58health care operations
- 23:59or research. So, again, this
- 24:00is that HIPAA category to
- 24:02be aware of.
- 24:04So how can protected health
- 24:05information be used in research?
- 24:07There's a few different ways
- 24:08that you can use PHI
- 24:10in the conduct of your
- 24:11research.
- 24:12One is just obtaining a
- 24:14participant's authorization. So in order
- 24:16to use or disclose PHI
- 24:18for research, you can obtain
- 24:20authorization
- 24:22from the individual.
- 24:23Let's say you're doing a
- 24:24drug study or a device
- 24:25study or even a a
- 24:27focus group and you're talking
- 24:28with somebody or you're intervening,
- 24:31obviously it's important for you
- 24:33to get that consent from
- 24:35that individual and if you're
- 24:36dealing with protected health information
- 24:38in addition to consent
- 24:39you will need that HIPAA
- 24:40authorization.
- 24:42At Yale, our consent templates
- 24:44templates actually have a built
- 24:45in HIPAA authorization form as
- 24:47well, so they only essentially
- 24:49sign one document
- 24:50that contains an embedded
- 24:52research authorization form, but you
- 24:54can also have a standalone
- 24:55form as well if that's
- 24:56something that you're interested in.
- 24:58What do I mean by
- 24:59using or disclosing PHI for
- 25:01research?
- 25:02Use is the use of
- 25:04PHI.
- 25:05Use means communicating, utilizing, examining,
- 25:08or analyzing
- 25:09PHI within the covered entity,
- 25:12And disclosure means the release,
- 25:14transfer, provision of access to,
- 25:16or divulging in any manner
- 25:17of information outside the entity
- 25:19holding the information.
- 25:21It's a very technical terms,
- 25:22but essentially,
- 25:24are you taking somebody's
- 25:26PHI? Are you identifying? Are
- 25:28you, is it leaving the
- 25:29covered entity? Is it leaving
- 25:31Yale? Is it going to
- 25:32other researchers at other institutions?
- 25:35So, again, if you have
- 25:36questions on that, let me
- 25:37know, but just wanted to
- 25:38provide the definitions for you
- 25:40here.
- 25:42In order to
- 25:43use or disclose PHI, you
- 25:44could also request a waiver
- 25:46of HIPAA authorization.
- 25:48This is what you're going
- 25:49to need to request when
- 25:50you're looking at those medical
- 25:51record reviews, those chart reviews.
- 25:54Obviously, it's not always possible
- 25:56to obtain informed consent or
- 25:58obtain HIPAA authorization
- 26:00from individuals.
- 26:01Let's say you're looking at
- 26:02a thousand records, right, or
- 26:04you're looking at ten thousand
- 26:05records or five hundred records.
- 26:07It would be impractical
- 26:09for you to go and
- 26:10get consent and research authorization
- 26:12for those, from those individuals
- 26:14to access their data for
- 26:16research purposes.
- 26:17So you can request a
- 26:18waiver of HIPAA authorization from
- 26:20the privacy board, which here
- 26:21at Yale, the Yale IRB
- 26:23serves as the privacy board.
- 26:24So you can request that
- 26:26authorize waiver of authorization
- 26:28in your IRB application, and
- 26:29I'll show you how to
- 26:30do that. And then finally,
- 26:31you can certainly use and
- 26:33disclose PHI for research when
- 26:34you're working with decedents, which
- 26:36we already talked about, and
- 26:37activities prep to research.
- 26:41So what are the criteria
- 26:42for a waiver or alteration
- 26:44of HIPAA authorization?
- 26:46In order to use or
- 26:48disclose PHI, we have to
- 26:50ensure that
- 26:51that disclosure is going to
- 26:52involve no more than a
- 26:54minimal risk to the privacy
- 26:55of individuals
- 26:57based on the presence of
- 26:58the following elements. One, is
- 27:00there an adequate plan to
- 27:01protect the identifiers
- 27:03from improper use of disclosure?
- 27:05Is there an adequate plan
- 27:06to destroy the identifiers
- 27:08at the earliest convenience?
- 27:10Is there an adequate written
- 27:11assurance that the PHI will
- 27:13not be reused or disclosed
- 27:15to any other person or
- 27:16entity?
- 27:18And can the research not
- 27:19be practically carried out without
- 27:21the waiver or alteration
- 27:23and, cannot be conducted without
- 27:25access to and the use
- 27:27of that PHI? So, again,
- 27:29for the most part, many
- 27:30chart reviews are going to
- 27:31meet this this criteria, and
- 27:33you're going to be able
- 27:34to request that waiver of
- 27:36HIPAA authorization.
- 27:38So I'll show you this
- 27:39in just a few, slides
- 27:41here, but when you're going
- 27:42to be submitting your research
- 27:44studies to the IRB, if
- 27:45it is exempt research, maybe
- 27:47it's that exempt category four,
- 27:49you're looking at medical records,
- 27:51there's a question on the
- 27:52exemption request form, it's question
- 27:54number seven. It's going to
- 27:56ask you to list all
- 27:57health information that will be
- 27:59recorded for the research.
- 28:00Only the items that are
- 28:02listed on this exemption request
- 28:04form may be recorded. Okay?
- 28:06So you have to make
- 28:07sure that every identifier you're
- 28:08going to be looking at
- 28:09in the medical record is
- 28:11included in your exemption request
- 28:13form.
- 28:14If you're using an Excel
- 28:15spreadsheet to provide,
- 28:17JDAT with your request, you
- 28:18can upload the document in
- 28:20IRS IRB
- 28:21and include a reference to
- 28:22the spreadsheet in this section
- 28:24of the exemption request form.
- 28:26So I'm sure many of
- 28:27you have done this. If
- 28:28you have not, whenever you
- 28:29want to look at medical
- 28:30records for research purposes that
- 28:32are not your own records,
- 28:33they're, you know, in epic
- 28:34or something and you're interested
- 28:36in a certain population,
- 28:38you first need to get
- 28:39IRB approval to do so.
- 28:40You have the list of
- 28:41identifiers that you're going to
- 28:43want access to, and you'll
- 28:45work with the joint data
- 28:46analytics team who is going
- 28:47to ask for your IRB
- 28:49approval, and they're the ones
- 28:50that actually provide you the
- 28:52information
- 28:53that you're requesting. So just
- 28:54keep that in mind.
- 28:56Some common identifiers that are
- 28:58quite obvious that you might
- 28:59be looking for
- 29:00are things like name, address,
- 29:02social security number, medical record
- 29:05number, phone number, email, a
- 29:07full face photo.
- 29:08But there's also less obvious
- 29:10identifiers. So if you want
- 29:11to collect these or,
- 29:14you don't realize that these
- 29:15also might be identifiers that
- 29:17you shouldn't be sharing or
- 29:18accessing,
- 29:19those include things like just
- 29:21general dates. This could be
- 29:22dates of
- 29:23visit, dates of surgery,
- 29:25health plan number, account number,
- 29:28license number, license plate,
- 29:30device number, IP addresses is
- 29:33something we don't think about
- 29:34a lot,
- 29:35finger and voice prints, or
- 29:37other unique identifying
- 29:39numbers, characteristics,
- 29:41or codes.
- 29:43So these, I
- 29:45if there's anything that you
- 29:46remember from this presentation, I
- 29:47hope it's a lot, but
- 29:48I would say the next
- 29:49two slides will be very
- 29:50useful for you to have
- 29:52in your pocket when you're
- 29:53submitting your studies to the
- 29:54IRB.
- 29:56This first slide is sample
- 29:58text that you can use
- 29:59when you're trying to describe
- 30:01how data is going to
- 30:02be recorded so that subjects
- 30:04will not be identified.
- 30:05So you will need to
- 30:06tailor this as appropriate for
- 30:08your study, but you'll essentially
- 30:09be able to copy this
- 30:10information,
- 30:12and then paste it when
- 30:13it's asked of you in
- 30:14the IRB application or the
- 30:15exemption request form.
- 30:17So, you can see on
- 30:19your screen here, it's just
- 30:20indicating that, you know, patient
- 30:22medical record numbers obtained from
- 30:23a JDate request will be
- 30:25recorded onto a master list.
- 30:27There's going to be a
- 30:28code. This is how it's
- 30:29going to be assigned.
- 30:30The master list is going
- 30:32to be stored in an
- 30:33Excel spreadsheet on SharePoint. It's
- 30:35only going to be available
- 30:36to x y z individuals,
- 30:39and then it talks about
- 30:40password protection. So this should
- 30:41be really useful for you
- 30:43when you're submitting your projects
- 30:44to the IRB.
- 30:46And then the second one
- 30:47is the request for a
- 30:49waiver of HIPAA authorization for
- 30:51those chart reviews. So, again,
- 30:52you'll need to tailor this
- 30:53as appropriate to your study,
- 30:55but this is essentially the
- 30:57language that can be used
- 30:59to request that full waiver
- 31:00of authorization.
- 31:01Again, this is something that
- 31:02you can find in the
- 31:04exemption request form,
- 31:06or the IRB submission form,
- 31:08which is the document that
- 31:09would you would instead use
- 31:10if you are conducting a
- 31:11drug or a device trial.
- 31:15So now that we've talked
- 31:15about all of the basics,
- 31:17how do you actually submit
- 31:18your research application to the
- 31:20Yale IRB?
- 31:21Before you submit, ask yourself,
- 31:23can you serve as the
- 31:24principal investigator?
- 31:26So we go by the
- 31:27Yale faculty handbook regarding who
- 31:29can serve as a principal
- 31:30investigator.
- 31:32I would say that most
- 31:33faculty are able to serve
- 31:34as PI's. The only individuals
- 31:36that we don't allow to
- 31:37serve as PI's, from a
- 31:39faculty perspective is adjunct faculty.
- 31:42So in those cases, adjunct
- 31:43faculty will need to give
- 31:45special permission to serve as
- 31:46the PI from the dean
- 31:48of their department. So we
- 31:50do have a form that
- 31:51can be completed in those
- 31:52circumstances.
- 31:54Also, ask yourself,
- 31:55what training does your team
- 31:57and and do you need
- 31:58to complete?
- 31:59We do require human subject
- 32:00protection training.
- 32:02This is done via the
- 32:03CITI
- 32:04program, which I'm sure many
- 32:05of you have worked with
- 32:06before.
- 32:07We also require HIPAA training
- 32:09that's done within here within
- 32:11Yale that for anyone that's
- 32:12going to be working with
- 32:13protective health information.
- 32:15And then if you're going
- 32:16to be conducting a clinical
- 32:17trial,
- 32:18you will need to take
- 32:19GCP
- 32:20training as well, and that
- 32:21can be done via the
- 32:23CITI program. So I have
- 32:24included links for you here.
- 32:26Also, are any ancillary groups
- 32:29going to need to review
- 32:30your research as well? Just
- 32:32to give you an idea,
- 32:33if you're working with, you
- 32:34know, radiation, we have a
- 32:35radiation safety committee that will
- 32:37need to review your research.
- 32:38If you're working with children,
- 32:39we have a pediatric protocol
- 32:41review committee that reviews all
- 32:43research involving children. So once
- 32:45you submit your application to
- 32:46the IRB,
- 32:47we might tell you that
- 32:48you need to contact these
- 32:49ancillary groups
- 32:51in order to get their,
- 32:52approval for your study as
- 32:54well. Thankfully,
- 32:56that can be accommodated for
- 32:57the most part in the
- 32:58IRIS IRB system, which is
- 33:00the system that you'll use
- 33:02to submit your IRB applications.
- 33:05So, again, these are some
- 33:06documents that you might need
- 33:07for review. I will say
- 33:09one great thing about our
- 33:10system is it's a very
- 33:12heavy document upload system. So
- 33:14instead of having, like, fifty
- 33:16pages that you have to
- 33:17complete, there's only a few
- 33:19pages in the IRB application,
- 33:21that electronic system,
- 33:22but we ask you to
- 33:23upload a lot of those
- 33:24documents. So your protocol, consent
- 33:26forms, recruitment materials,
- 33:29anything else that you're going
- 33:30to need to conduct your
- 33:31study, that those are going
- 33:32to be uploaded as documents
- 33:34in the application,
- 33:35but it's pretty straightforward about
- 33:36where you actually need to
- 33:37put those documents.
- 33:39So I'll start out with
- 33:40when you're conducting exempt research.
- 33:42Let's say you're do those
- 33:43you're doing those chart reviews,
- 33:45those interviews, focus groups,
- 33:47you will complete this exemption
- 33:49request form that I've linked
- 33:50for you there.
- 33:52This can be uploaded as
- 33:54your protocol, essentially, in IRS
- 33:56IRB.
- 33:57And, obviously, in addition to
- 33:58that, you'll upload any consent
- 34:00documents you may or may
- 34:01not be using, surveys,
- 34:03questions,
- 34:04recruitment materials, letters of support,
- 34:06etcetera. So that's a pretty,
- 34:09easy application
- 34:10to complete this form and
- 34:11then upload into IRS IRB.
- 34:14If you are conducting
- 34:15expedited or full board research,
- 34:17so let's say you're working
- 34:18with drugs or devices,
- 34:20you will need to complete
- 34:22a protocol
- 34:23and the IRB submission form
- 34:25and upload those in IRIS
- 34:27IRB.
- 34:27We do have templates available
- 34:29for you in the IRIS
- 34:30IRB library that you can
- 34:32use for your protocol. We've
- 34:33got various biomedical templates, social
- 34:36behavioral templates,
- 34:38and we are actually revising
- 34:39those then. They're looking really
- 34:41good. Those should be available
- 34:42in the spring, so we're
- 34:43happy about that, but we
- 34:44do have some nice templates
- 34:45for you there currently.
- 34:47You will also need to
- 34:48upload this IRB submission form.
- 34:51This is essentially a complimentary
- 34:53document to the protocol that
- 34:55asks a little bit more
- 34:56information about your study with
- 34:58regards
- 34:59to local context.
- 35:00So what waivers are you
- 35:02requesting? Let's say you're doing
- 35:03that drug device trial, you
- 35:05need to request some type
- 35:06of HIPAA waiver, that's actually
- 35:08done in the IRB submission
- 35:09form instead of the exemption
- 35:11request form obviously,
- 35:13and more information about recruitment
- 35:15is is asked in the
- 35:16IRB submission form. So keep
- 35:18in mind if you're conducting
- 35:19that full board or expedited
- 35:21research, both of these documents
- 35:23will need to be uploaded.
- 35:25Regardless of if your research
- 35:26is exempt, expedited, full board,
- 35:28everything else also needs to
- 35:30be uploaded. So, again, those
- 35:31consent documents, assent documents, we
- 35:34do have templates available for
- 35:35you in the library.
- 35:37Something that's great to to
- 35:38announce is that we did
- 35:39just update our ascent forms.
- 35:41So for adolescents and children,
- 35:43we did just update those
- 35:45forms to be more user
- 35:46friendly for children. So those
- 35:48are available in the Iris
- 35:49Iribe library.
- 35:51And, again, upload any other
- 35:52documents that are going to
- 35:53be part of your research.
- 35:56If you are conducting international
- 35:58research, we also will ask
- 35:59that you complete this international
- 36:01checklist
- 36:02and upload it in IRIS
- 36:03IRB as well.
- 36:06This is the iris IRB
- 36:07library. What's nice about iris
- 36:09IRB is it's you log
- 36:11in with your Yale NetID.
- 36:13So if you just Google
- 36:14iris IRB, or I've provided
- 36:15a link for you later
- 36:16on, you will log in
- 36:18with your Yale NetID and
- 36:19password. You don't have to
- 36:20sign up for a separate
- 36:21account, so it's pretty easy
- 36:23to navigate and and get
- 36:25into the system.
- 36:26If you go to the
- 36:27library, which is this banner
- 36:29up top, you can access
- 36:31our protocol templates. Again, that's
- 36:33where you're going to find
- 36:34the exemption request form, all
- 36:35of our biomedical and social
- 36:37behavioral templates.
- 36:38If you click on the
- 36:39breadcrumbs here, this is where
- 36:40you can also access consent
- 36:42form templates,
- 36:43our handbooks and manuals, so
- 36:45our SOP manual, our investigator
- 36:48manual.
- 36:48And then if you click
- 36:49on the IRB tab that's
- 36:51up here,
- 36:52you will also have access
- 36:53to our help center, which
- 36:55has some really nice guides
- 36:56about
- 36:57submitting,
- 36:58clarifications
- 36:59back to the IRB
- 37:00and other types of training
- 37:02videos.
- 37:05So the last thing I'll
- 37:06talk about is what happens
- 37:08once you submit that project
- 37:10to the IRB. What does
- 37:11the review process and the
- 37:13flow look like?
- 37:14Investigators,
- 37:15when they submit all those
- 37:16documents in IRS IRB,
- 37:18that application is going to
- 37:20be assigned to a Yale
- 37:21IRB regulatory
- 37:22analyst. They're going to conduct
- 37:24a pre review of your
- 37:25application. They're going to make
- 37:26sure that all of your
- 37:27training is complete,
- 37:29that you have uploaded everything
- 37:31correctly,
- 37:32and then they'll either triage
- 37:34that application to the fully
- 37:36convened IRB for, again, those
- 37:37greater than minimal risk or
- 37:39drug device
- 37:40studies, or they will, send
- 37:42it to an IRB chair
- 37:43or a designated reviewer for
- 37:45exempt or expedited research.
- 37:47They're going to look at
- 37:48your study. They may have
- 37:49questions for you, so please
- 37:51note that once you submit
- 37:52your study, you might get
- 37:54emails from the IRIS IRB
- 37:56system saying there's action needed
- 37:57from you.
- 37:58Please, please complete those
- 38:01clarifications
- 38:02as quickly as possible because
- 38:04the sooner you get back
- 38:05to us, the sooner we're
- 38:06gonna approve your study.
- 38:08So we might just have
- 38:09one or two things you
- 38:10need to change, just get
- 38:11that done quickly
- 38:13so that you can start
- 38:14your research,
- 38:15quickly and and everyone's happy.
- 38:17So once we are done
- 38:19cleaning up your application, all
- 38:20clarifications
- 38:21from the IRB have been
- 38:22addressed.
- 38:23You will receive an email
- 38:25that has a link to
- 38:27your approval letter. So then
- 38:28you are ready to begin
- 38:30your research once you do
- 38:31receive that approval letter from
- 38:32the IRB.
- 38:33It'll be a a PDF
- 38:35document
- 38:36in your IRIS IRB application
- 38:38that you can certainly download.
- 38:40Be sure to read that
- 38:41letter also before you start
- 38:42your research because there might
- 38:44be information the IRB needs
- 38:45to convey with you convey
- 38:47to you in that in
- 38:48that letter. So certainly read
- 38:50the the approval,
- 38:51before you you begin your
- 38:53research.
- 38:54So these are our additional
- 38:56resources I wanted to share
- 38:57with you.
- 38:58We have our website. We
- 38:59have our policies and procedures,
- 39:01our our standard operating procedure
- 39:03manual, our investigator manual,
- 39:05and a link to IRIS
- 39:07IRB.
- 39:08I will also say if
- 39:09you're new to Yale or
- 39:10even if you're not new
- 39:11to Yale, a really useful
- 39:13guidance document is our guidance
- 39:15four ten. This is all
- 39:16about research recruitment at Yale
- 39:18and Yale New Haven Hospital.
- 39:20How do you work with
- 39:21MyChart
- 39:22to send out MyChart messages?
- 39:24What is acceptable with regards
- 39:26to approaching somebody in health
- 39:27care facilities and asking them
- 39:29to participate in research? So
- 39:31we just updated this a
- 39:33little over a year ago,
- 39:34and we worked with our
- 39:36colleagues at the health system
- 39:37as well. So this is
- 39:38a really nice document to
- 39:39get you,
- 39:41fully educated on what we
- 39:43allow or don't allow when
- 39:44it comes to research recruitment.
- 39:45So take a look at
- 39:46that. And the last thing
- 39:48I'll say before I take
- 39:49any questions from the group
- 39:50is we truly are committed
- 39:52in our office to a
- 39:53partnership with our research community.
- 39:55We're always available to answer
- 39:57questions,
- 39:58to talk with you about
- 39:59your project,
- 40:00and we're always going to
- 40:01ensure that you are supported
- 40:03so that you can conduct
- 40:04all of the great research
- 40:05that you do and ensure
- 40:06that the research that you
- 40:08do conduct is safe and
- 40:09ethical. I promise we're a
- 40:10very friendly bunch, and, again,
- 40:12we're always happy to to
- 40:14collaborate with you.
- 40:15So with that being said,
- 40:17I did wanna leave a
- 40:18good amount of time for
- 40:19questions, and I'm happy to
- 40:21take any questions at this
- 40:22time.
- 40:27Thank you so much.
- 40:30Maybe as people if people
- 40:32have plenty of questions, but
- 40:34one that I'm always surprised
- 40:35on is how quick the
- 40:37process is. You know, with
- 40:38exemptions being the most common
- 40:40other than when
- 40:41the people submitting
- 40:43kinda don't follow through on
- 40:44the queries to them. How
- 40:46long would you tell people
- 40:47it should take on average?
- 40:48Like, do you see coming
- 40:49out of the office? Like,
- 40:51what do you tell people?
- 40:52Yeah. That's a great question.
- 40:54So I would say that
- 40:55for exempt or expedited research,
- 40:57as long as you are
- 40:58responding to the IRB,
- 41:00a week to two weeks
- 41:01from when you submit is
- 41:03when you should receive your
- 41:04approval, which is we're really
- 41:05proud of that. So, obviously,
- 41:07there's outliers, as you say,
- 41:08doctor Grauer. So if you
- 41:10submit your study and the
- 41:11IRB the next day ask
- 41:13for clarifications and you don't
- 41:14respond for a month, that's
- 41:15another thing. But for the
- 41:16most part, I'd say one
- 41:17to two weeks max probably
- 41:19for those.
- 41:20For full board, it's a
- 41:22it just depends on full
- 41:23board. I would say that
- 41:24it can be as little
- 41:26as
- 41:28three weeks,
- 41:29but it just depends on
- 41:31the
- 41:32study, how elaborate the study
- 41:34is, the interventions involved, if
- 41:36there's a vulnerable population. So
- 41:37that's a little bit harder
- 41:38to parse out.
- 41:40Yeah.
- 41:41Good question. I would tell
- 41:42you my experience with expedited
- 41:44or exempt is is even
- 41:45faster than that. You are
- 41:46certainly, if anything, overestimating.
- 41:48Okay.
- 41:49Well, good. I'm glad to
- 41:50hear that. You yes. It
- 41:52can be a a day
- 41:53sometimes for exempt research, but
- 41:54I like to,
- 41:55just in case, give ourselves
- 41:57a little bit of of
- 41:58leisure. Great that you do,
- 41:59but just everyone knows, it's
- 42:01it's pretty fast. So it
- 42:02surprises me. Glad you've had
- 42:03a good experience with that.
- 42:05Yeah.
- 42:06Am I one other kind
- 42:07of before we kinda push
- 42:08for anybody else? But one
- 42:10of the things I find
- 42:10is it's a little anonymous
- 42:12feeling when you kinda send
- 42:13to these, like, general mailboxes,
- 42:16but I've been very impressed
- 42:18how quickly it becomes
- 42:20a email dialogue with a
- 42:21person, as opposed to a
- 42:22general mailbox. Because I I
- 42:23don't know. Y'all kinda feel
- 42:24like some of these
- 42:26office, like, centralized things, it
- 42:29you kinda feel like, is
- 42:30somebody really reading that? And
- 42:31my experience has been
- 42:37if asked for.
- 42:39That's thank you for saying
- 42:40I'm I'm I'm so glad
- 42:41that that's been your experience,
- 42:42but you're you're totally right.
- 42:43As soon as you submit
- 42:44your application, there is somebody
- 42:46that is assigned to your
- 42:48So you're gonna start getting
- 42:49emails from that person. That
- 42:50person is dedicated to your
- 42:52research study. I will say
- 42:53even if you send like,
- 42:54you have you see our
- 42:55our
- 42:56email there, it's h r
- 42:57p p at yale dot
- 42:58e d u. That's our
- 42:59general email.
- 43:00We have staff members,
- 43:02looking at those emails
- 43:04every single
- 43:05basically, twenty four seven because
- 43:07the world that we live
- 43:07in, we have to be
- 43:08on call to ensure that
- 43:09there's not emergencies happening.
- 43:11So when you submit that,
- 43:13we are going to have
- 43:14a response to you, I'd
- 43:15say, within a couple of
- 43:16hours. We say twenty four
- 43:18hours, but we've never I've
- 43:19never had anyone not be
- 43:21responded to in,
- 43:22twenty four hours. So we're
- 43:24proud of that as well.
- 43:25But, again, if you do
- 43:26have individual questions as well,
- 43:27you can always contact me,
- 43:28and I'm always happy to
- 43:29either field the question or
- 43:31or talk with you directly
- 43:32about that.
- 43:35Gary, do you have any
- 43:35it looks like you might
- 43:36have a question. I had
- 43:37a question. I actually had
- 43:38a couple of questions. The
- 43:39first, can you give me
- 43:40their email address to contact
- 43:42IRB? I've been looking for
- 43:43a address if I had
- 43:44questions.
- 43:45So what what is the
- 43:46email address if I have
- 43:48questions to ask?
- 43:50Sure. So the general one
- 43:51is this h r p
- 43:52p at yale dot e
- 43:53d u.
- 43:54H r p
- 43:56p? Yes. H as in
- 43:58human, r as in Ralph,
- 44:00and p and p as
- 44:01in pen and pen.
- 44:04At,
- 44:05h r p p at
- 44:06human research?
- 44:08At yale dot e d
- 44:09u. At Yale. Just like
- 44:10our normal Sorry. Email. Yeah.
- 44:12Yeah. That's good. Sorry. Time
- 44:14for my coffee in the
- 44:15evening, I guess. My other
- 44:17question was,
- 44:18so I'm a pathologist,
- 44:20and if I had like
- 44:21you mentioned that if if
- 44:22it is a study that
- 44:24involves,
- 44:25using specimens,
- 44:26like, I'm looking at biopsies
- 44:28or exigent specimens from patients,
- 44:30that is exempt.
- 44:33My question was if
- 44:35if if I want to
- 44:36do any kind of molecular
- 44:37analysis
- 44:38on those,
- 44:40specimens,
- 44:41is that still considered exempt?
- 44:43I always submit an IRB
- 44:45for whatever I'm doing because
- 44:47there is chart review involved,
- 44:49And I always submitted IRB
- 44:51for chart review.
- 44:52Mhmm. But if there are
- 44:53additional studies that are that
- 44:55are that I am going
- 44:56to be performing
- 44:58on the patient's specimens,
- 45:01under what category should I
- 45:03submit it?
- 45:05Yeah. That's a good question.
- 45:05So I guess my first
- 45:06question is the the research
- 45:08that you're talking about, the
- 45:09first part of it, are
- 45:10those
- 45:11discarded samples or those
- 45:13samples you're collecting as part
- 45:14of the research?
- 45:16No. No. They are, they
- 45:17are I'm not collecting anything
- 45:19new,
- 45:20as part of the research.
- 45:21It is I see. It
- 45:22is, it is the specimens
- 45:24that are already present in
- 45:26I see. In the lab.
- 45:27Yeah. Like a registry or
- 45:28something. Is that Yes. Yeah.
- 45:30Okay. Okay. Yeah. I would
- 45:31say that,
- 45:33that's a good question.
- 45:34Always submit those types of
- 45:36projects to the IRB.
- 45:37We do have a
- 45:39this wouldn't work in this
- 45:40case. We have a repository
- 45:42template that we just created.
- 45:43I would say in these
- 45:44cases,
- 45:45if you don't know the
- 45:45exact category, I would have
- 45:47to look at the research
- 45:47you're submitting before giving you
- 45:49a category. But that's okay
- 45:50to just, like, leave it
- 45:51blank on the form, and
- 45:52the IRB will help you
- 45:53decide, like, which category it
- 45:54falls in based on the
- 45:55parameters of your research.
- 45:57Okay. Yeah. And I might
- 45:58email somebody at this address
- 46:00to see if they can
- 46:01help me with what category
- 46:03it is, giving specific details
- 46:05about my,
- 46:06case. Or or I or
- 46:08you recommend that I just
- 46:09submit it and leave it
- 46:10blank, and they'll get back
- 46:11to me?
- 46:12I think it's, it's good
- 46:13to maybe email this, inbox
- 46:16first because they'll be able
- 46:17to put you in contact
- 46:18with the exact person that
- 46:19you'll will need to answer
- 46:21that question, and they'll be
- 46:22super helpful. And then in
- 46:23the meantime, you can start
- 46:24working on your application and
- 46:26get it ready to go.
- 46:26So once they respond, you
- 46:28know what category it is.
- 46:30Sounds great.
- 46:31I have one more question.
- 46:32So if I'm doing some
- 46:33research where I'm collaborating with
- 46:35an outside institution,
- 46:37I know I have to
- 46:37do a material transfer agreement.
- 46:40Is that separate from the
- 46:41IRB, or do I have
- 46:43to include that in the
- 46:44IRB as well? That's a
- 46:45great question. That is separate
- 46:47from the IRB process. Yep.
- 46:49Okay. But you're totally on
- 46:50board with that that needing
- 46:51to happen. Yep. Yeah. And
- 46:53my last question is, if
- 46:55I'm collaborating with an outside
- 46:56company, like, I'm getting funds
- 46:59from a company to do
- 47:00this. I know a lot
- 47:01of research
- 47:02is funded by federal agencies.
- 47:05But if if it is
- 47:06a research that is,
- 47:07getting,
- 47:08getting funded by
- 47:10by a company,
- 47:12Is there anything different that
- 47:13I do for the IRB?
- 47:14I'm, of course, a PI.
- 47:16No,
- 47:17PHI or no information is
- 47:18going to go to the
- 47:20company,
- 47:21about this except some,
- 47:23some of the data that
- 47:24they will use for sequencing
- 47:26or some studies. So do
- 47:27I have to make some
- 47:28kind of a modification to
- 47:30the IRB?
- 47:31Is there a place in
- 47:32the IRB to include this?
- 47:34Sure. So is this a
- 47:35study that is already approved?
- 47:37No. No. It's something that
- 47:39I will do in future.
- 47:40Got you. Yes. So, no,
- 47:41there's nothing different you would
- 47:42need to do except for
- 47:43you would need to list
- 47:44them as a funding source
- 47:45in the IRIS IRB application.
- 47:48And I'm sure you'll work
- 47:48with the Office of Sponsored
- 47:50Projects, OSP, who will set
- 47:52up the award, and it
- 47:52will actually you'll be able
- 47:54to link it in the
- 47:54IRIS IRB system. You'll kinda
- 47:56be able to pull up
- 47:57that, funding source in that,
- 48:00where it says, like, local
- 48:01funding sources or something. So
- 48:02that's the only thing that
- 48:03would be different in this
- 48:04case. Okay.
- 48:05Sounds good. Great question. So
- 48:06much. Yeah. This is very
- 48:08helpful. I really appreciate it.
- 48:10Good. Yeah. Let us know
- 48:10if you have questions.
- 48:12Okay. Sounds great. Thanks.
- 48:13Yeah. Thank you.
- 48:15Those were great. Any other
- 48:16questions?
- 48:24Okay.
- 48:25Well, thank you for your
- 48:25time. For joining and giving
- 48:27us all this information.